Am I Wrong For Not Forcing My Kid To Share Their Special Things?
The charcoal was still smoking on the grill last Saturday, and I had a half-melted popsicle and a warm glass of lemonade in my hand, when I heard the high, pleading voices drifting from the front hallway. My 7-year-old Leo had just finished building his 800-piece Millennium Falcon Lego set three days prior, and he’d been sleeping with his bedroom door cracked just so he could check on it before bed. My sister’s two boys, 5 and 6, had spotted it through the gap, and were already crowded against the frame begging to hold it.
Leo was right behind me, sticky fingers grabbing the hem of my shorts. “That’s mine,” he said, voice tight. “I don’t want them to touch it. They’ll break it.”
My sister laughed, soft and used to this sort of thing. “C’mon, buddy,” she said. “Sharing is polite. They’ll be careful with it.” My mom, who was flipping burgers behind me, nodded. “He’s just being a little selfish,” she said, not mean, just matter-of-fact. “Let the boys have a turn for 10 minutes, you can have it back after.”
That’s when I said it, the thing that made the whole patio go quiet for half a second: “Actually, this one’s off limits. We have a whole bin of cars and board games out back, and the sidewalk chalk is still by the porch. The boys can pick whatever they want from that.”
No one argued, but I caught the look my sister and mom exchanged. By the end of the barbecue, I was the one overthinking it, wiping down counters after everyone left and wondering if I was in the wrong.
Growing up, I was always the kid who was told to give up whatever I wanted to make someone else comfortable. My favorite stuffed rabbit? Give it to the crying cousin. My new notebook? Let your friend borrow it for art class. Being good meant sharing, no exceptions. So I get where that instinct comes from. But I’d watched Leo work on that Falcon for three straight days after saving up his allowance for it. He cried for 20 minutes when he lost a tiny connector piece under the couch. He stayed up 25 minutes past bedtime three nights in a row to get the laser cannon and the cockpit just right. This wasn’t a random old toy we pulled out of the bin for guests. It was his.
I learned this split a while back, after a mistake I still think about: we separate toys into two categories at our house: shared toys, and special things. Shared toys are the stuff that lives in the living room bin—board games, cars, bubbles, all that. If friends or cousins come over, Leo has to take turns with that. No arguments. But special things are the stuff that matters to him, that he built or found or got for a birthday that he’s not ready to let other people play with yet. That Lego set, his beat-up old baby stuffed bear, the rock he found on our camping trip that’s the exact shade of blue he likes—those are his, and he doesn’t have to share them if he doesn’t want to.
I didn’t make that rule up out of nowhere. Two years ago, Leo had a new rock collection he’d spent a month putting together, and he refused to let his best friend hold his favorite one. I pushed him to hand it over, told him he was being rude. His friend slipped, dropped it on the tile, and it cracked right down the middle. Leo didn’t throw a big fit, he just picked up the two pieces and went to his room and shut the door. When I went in an hour later, he was still sitting on his bed holding it, and he said, “You didn’t care that I didn’t want him to touch it.” That line stuck with me.
The thing is, forcing a kid to share when they’re not ready doesn’t teach them generosity. It teaches them that their feelings don’t matter, that they have to give up the things they care about just to keep other people happy. I don’t want that for him.
The concrete stuff I do, that anyone can try, is pretty simple. When another kid asks to play with a special thing, I don’t put the awkward back on my kid. I just say to the guest, “Leo’s still okay with this being just his right now. Let’s go find something else really fun to play with, yeah?” To my kid, I just say, “I get that this matters a lot. I’ve got your back, I won’t make anyone touch it.” That’s it, no big speech, no shaming.
I talked to Leo’s first grade teacher about this at parent-teacher conferences last month, actually. She said she does the exact same thing for show-and-tell: whatever a kid brings from home is their call if anyone gets to touch it. She said she’s had half as many toy-related fights since she started doing that three years ago.
I still second-guess it, sometimes. Last week at the playground, a little boy asked to ride Leo’s new birthday scooter, and Leo said no. The boy’s mom gave me that look, the one that says you’re raising a rude kid. I packed up our stuff and left the playground still wondering if I’d messed up.
But then last night, Leo came to me with that old dinosaur Lego set he outgrew a few months ago, all packed up in a box. He said the little girl down the street just turned five, and she loves dinosaurs, so he wanted to give it to her. He carried it over all by himself, knocked on the door, and gave it to her. He didn’t do it because I made him. He did it because he wanted to.
I don’t have this all figured out. I’m sure there are people who’d say I’m wrong, that I’m teaching him to be selfish. Some days I think they might be right. But right now, letting him hold onto his boundaries when it matters feels a lot more right than forcing him to share just to make everyone else comfortable. It’s still a work in progress, I guess. We’ll see how it goes.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Am I Wrong For Not Forcing My Kid To Share Their Special Things