Am I Entitled or Is This Actually Weird? What My Child’s “I Deserve It” Phase Taught Me
The other morning, my eight-year-old stood in the kitchen with his arms crossed.
“I don’t think I have to pack my snack,” he said. “I cleaned my room yesterday. So I should get to skip something today.”
It was 7:15. I had one sock on. There was a half-eaten bagel on the counter. And for a split second, I genuinely didn’t know if I was dealing with a future negotiator, a tiny philosopher, or just a kid who didn’t want to put pretzels in his backpack.
“Wait,” I said. “Cleaning your room means you don’t need to pack a snack?”
“I already did what you asked yesterday. So today should be easier for me.”
I stood there and thought: Am I entitled or is this actually weird?
I asked my husband later. He shrugged and said, “He’s eight. Everything is a transaction now.” That wasn’t entirely comforting, but it was honest.
Then I mentioned it to my son’s teacher at pickup. She laughed. “Oh, that’s nothing. Today I had a kid finish his center work and ask if he could earn extra recess by cleaning the whiteboard. Another one asked if helping a friend count glue sticks would get him a sticker. It’s like a whole phase they go through.”
That helped. But it also made me think.
Where did he get the idea that doing one good thing buys him out of another good thing? I mean, adults do operate like that sometimes. We work, we get paid. We cook dinner, someone else does dishes. But family life isn’t supposed to be a ledger. Yet here he was, trying to run the house like a small business.
It’s easy to see that and think, “Oh great, I’ve raised a narcissist.” But that’s probably not what’s happening. Between the ages of about five and nine, kids are trying to figure out what fairness actually means. They’re learning rules, social expectations, cause and effect. And they’re desperate to find some control in a world where they’re told what to do all day long.
So “I did this, so I deserve that” is not necessarily him feeling like the world owes him. It’s him testing how the system works. He cleaned his room. He didn’t get anything for it. So he’s trying to convert that effort into some kind of advantage. That’s not entitlement. That’s experimentation.
I also realized something uncomfortable: I had been teaching him this without meaning to.
Rewards are everywhere. “If you get your shoes on, we’ll stop for donuts on the way.” “Finish your math page and you can have screen time.” “When you put away your blocks, I’ll give you a sticker.” None of those are terrible. But when almost every task is attached to some kind of prize, a kid starts to think that’s just how things work. Why would you ever do something just because it needs to be done?
The problem isn’t that reward systems are evil. The problem is that they don’t get phased out. So kids start expecting payment for basic cooperation. Then when a parent asks them to do something that’s just part of being a family, the kid says, “What do I get?”
That’s the moment I realized I needed to change the way I framed things at home.
What worked was not a big lecture. It was a short, kind of boring answer.
“Snack packing is part of your morning routine,” I told my son. “Like brushing your teeth. Cleaning your room yesterday was great, but it doesn’t cancel today’s snack. We all pitch in around here.”
He frowned. “That’s not fair.”
“It’s fair because everyone helps. I don’t pay you to brush your teeth, right?”
“No.”
“Right. Some things just have to happen.”
It didn’t feel like a huge parenting win. He packed the snack, but he packed it with the energy of someone being asked to do community service. Still, I noticed something. He re-packed his snack the next morning without even mentioning his room. By day three, it was just part of the morning again.
But I also had to adjust some of my own habits. I started catching myself before I offered a treat for basic stuff. When I needed him to get ready in the morning, I didn’t say, “If you get dressed quickly, you can have a muffin.” I said, “Let’s get dressed, then we’ll have breakfast.” The sequence doesn’t have to be a trade.
I also started giving him real choices within the things that were going to happen anyway. “You don’t get to choose whether you pack a snack. You do get to choose whether it’s apples or crackers.” That helped a lot. He still felt powerful, but he didn’t get to bargain over the core expectation.
Another thing that surprised me was how much easier things got when I moved the snack shelf down to his level. He could do the whole job himself. When I stopped hovering, he also stopped treating snack-packing like something he was doing for me. It was just what he did before school.
This is something I’ve seen schoolteachers handle really well too. Instead of saying, “If you finish your work, you get a prize,” some of them say, “When you finish, you can choose a book or a quiet activity.” That’s not a reward for doing the work. It’s just what comes next. It keeps the momentum going without turning every assignment into a paycheck.
That’s not to say rewards are wrong. Sometimes they’re genuinely useful, especially for really hard tasks or new skills. But they work best when they’re not the default. If everything gets a gold star, the gold star stops meaning anything. And kids start thinking that no task has value unless there’s a payout attached.
What about the worry that your kid is actually becoming entitled?
I’ve had that worry too. But I’ve come to think that actual entitlement is more about a child not being able to handle the word no. A kid who asks for something and then cries when they hear no is not necessarily a spoiled person. They’re just a person still learning how to cope with disappointment. The difference is whether, after the feelings settle, they can eventually do the task anyway. That’s the skill worth practicing.
So when my son tries to pull another “I did X, so I deserve Y” move, I try not to argue with the whole logic. I try to answer the thing underneath it. Sometimes he wants control. Sometimes he wants a break. Sometimes he wants to feel like his effort mattered. The conversation goes different depending on which one it is. But the boundary stays the same.
It’s been a few weeks now. He doesn’t bring up his room every day. But I know this isn’t over. We’ll probably go through another version of this when allowances start getting discussed, or when he realizes that chores in other families get paid.
I don’t think he’s weird. I also don’t think I’m entitled for expecting him to contribute to the house he lives in. I’m just trying to make sure he knows the difference between being part of a family and being on a payroll. He’ll test it again, probably soon. And next time, I’ll probably still be a little annoyed.
But I’ll also remember the morning he crossed his arms and tried to use a clean room as currency. It was strange, but it was also kind of brilliant. He was figuring out how rules work, how effort works, and where he stands in this small system we call home. My job is to make the system clear enough that he doesn’t have to keep poking it to find out.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Am I Entitled or Is This Actually Weird