Am I a Normal First Time Mama? Answers to Your Unspoken New Parent Worries
It’s 2:17 a.m. I’m sitting on my bathroom floor, the door cracked an inch to listen for my 6-week-old’s cries from the bassinet down the hall. My shower rug is still damp from this morning, there’s a half-eaten peanut butter granola bar melting on the edge of the sink, and my phone is at 12% battery. I lean against the tub and type four words into the search bar: first time mama am I normal.
I’d just snapped 10 minutes earlier. I’d fed her, changed her, burped her, bounced her on my exercise ball for 25 minutes, and she still screamed, red-faced and snotty, like I was hurting her. I’d handed her to my partner, mumbled “I need a minute,” and locked myself in here before I said something I’d regret. I didn’t feel the warm, rush of overwhelming love everyone had warned me about. I felt tired and angry and like I’d somehow messed up this whole mom thing before we even got started.
The search results weren’t helpful. Half of them were glossy thinkpieces telling me “all moms feel this way you’re perfect!” and the other half were listicles screaming 10 Signs You Have Postpartum Depression Call Your Doctor Now. I didn’t think I had PPD. I just thought I was broken, because none of this matched the stories I’d heard from friends, or the reels I’d scrolled through while I was pregnant. Normal first time moms love every minute, right? Normal first time moms don’t get annoyed at a tiny baby who can’t even talk.
A week later, I was sitting in the waiting room for my daughter’s two-month checkup, folding a onesie covered in spit up, when I mentioned the bathroom incident offhand to the other first time mom next to me. She paused mid-bottle warm-up and stared at me. “I did that last night,” she said. “I locked myself in the pantry after my baby screamed through the whole Target run. Ate an entire bag of mini chocolate chips by myself while he screamed in his car seat. I thought I was the only one.”
That conversation stuck with me, so a few days later I brought it up to an old friend who teaches childbirth and new parent classes. She laughed, and said she gets this question at least once a week in her classes. No one asks it out loud in front of the whole group, but after class, when everyone else is packing up their bags, one or two first time mamas will hang back and whisper it: am I normal?
She told me the problem isn’t that our feelings are weird. It’s that no one tells you the messy stuff before you have the baby. Everyone talks about the instant bond and the tiny baby smells and how your life changes for the better, but no one talks about the part where you don’t feel that instant bond, or you want to cry because you can’t finish a hot cup of coffee, or you’re so tired you forget your own name half the time.
She gave me a few small, concrete things that have stuck with me, instead of the vague “you got this” speech everyone else gives. First, when you get that panicky “am I normal?” feeling, don’t google it. Google’s algorithm prioritizes the most extreme content first, so you’ll end up convinced you have a rare condition when you’re just tired. Instead, text one person who you know will tell you the truth—someone who had a baby within the last three years, not the one who only posts perfect family photos on Instagram. Specifically ask them for their worst messy new mom story, not the good one. When I texted my cousin, who had a baby 18 months ago, she wrote back 2 minutes later: “I once put my baby in her crib, locked the door, and sat in my car in the driveway listening to pop music for 20 minutes. I left her sleeping, she was fine. You’re normal.”
Second, split your worries into two categories: uncomfortable feelings, and dangerous feelings. Uncomfortable is everything from “I hate this right now” to “I didn’t cry when my baby was born” to “I want to go to the grocery store alone just to walk around in silence.” All of that is uncomfortable, all of that is normal. Dangerous is when you go more than a day without eating or showering because you can’t get out of bed, or when you keep having thoughts of hurting yourself or your baby that you can’t shake. If it’s the second, call your doctor or midwife right away. There’s no shame in getting help, and that doesn’t make you a bad mom. If it’s the first? It’s just part of the job.
I thought back to the day my daughter was born. I’d pushed for 3 hours, been in labor for 18, and when they laid her on my chest, I was so tired I could barely keep my eyes open. I thought she was cute, I thought she was mine, but I didn’t cry. I didn’t feel that explosive rush of love everyone talks about. I thought that meant I was a bad mom, that something was wrong with me. My friend told me that almost half of first time moms don’t feel that instant bond. Bonding builds over weeks, when you change the millionth diaper and sing the same stupid lullaby over and over. It’s okay if it doesn’t hit you the second they’re born.
My daughter is four months old now. Some days I still get that panicky little question in the back of my head: am I normal? Last week I cried in the Target parking lot because she spit up all over my only clean sweatshirt and I forgot to buy diapers. I still lock myself in the bathroom for 5 minutes most days just to eat a cookie alone without a tiny person staring at me. I haven’t finished a full hot cup of coffee in four months. I still don’t have it all figured out. But now, when the question pops up, I don’t google it. I text my cousin, or the mom I met in the waiting room, and they tell me their messy story, and I remember: normal isn’t what you see on social media. Normal is just getting through the day, loving your kid even when you don’t like the job right that minute. That’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Am I a Normal First Time Mama