Why I don’t force my young kid to share: a parenting confession I’ve never said out loud
Last Saturday at the neighborhood playground, I sat on a splintered cedar bench peeling a sticker off my water bottle while my 4-year-old, Milo, pushed his favorite blue dump truck through a pile of wood chips. The truck was a birthday gift from his grandpa, and it goes almost everywhere with us—he sleeps with it tilted against his pillow some nights, so I should have seen what came next. A little girl about his age wandered over, pointed at the truck, and looked up at me like I was going to make him hand it over. Her mom smiled from the next bench over, the polite “I’ll let you handle this” smile that every parent knows. Milo clamped both arms around the truck’s cab and yelled, “No! Mine.” I nodded, and said to the little girl, “He’s playing with it right now. There’s a green shovel by the slide that’s free, or we can ask him again in a few minutes, okay?” The mom’s smile slipped a little, and she herded her daughter over to the slide, and I could feel the unspoken question: What kind of mom doesn’t make her kid share?
That’s the thing I’ve never said out loud to most people: I stopped forcing my kid to share a year and a half ago, and I don’t plan to start again. I used to be the mom who would gently pry the toy out of his clenched hands and coo “we share with our friends, remember?” just like every parenting checklist I read when I was pregnant told me to. I’d laugh and apologize to the other parent, like I was checking the box for raising a kind, polite kid.
The turning point was a playdate when Milo was 2 and a half. He had this beat-up stuffed fox that he’d had since he was a baby, the kind where the fur is rubbed off one paw and the plastic eye is half fallen off. A friend’s toddler picked it up and started carrying it around, and I just brushed off Milo’s quiet protests, saying “it’s okay, let him play with it” like a good mom should. It wasn’t until after everyone left that I noticed how quiet he was. I couldn’t find the fox for an hour, and I finally found it crammed in the back of his closet, under a pile of dirty laundry. He cried for 20 minutes straight about how “everyone takes my things,” and that’s when I stopped following the unwritten parenting rule and started actually paying attention to how his brain works.
Turns out, kids under 5 don’t really grasp the idea of sharing and turn-taking the way adults do. They don’t understand that if they let someone else play with their truck, they’ll get it back soon. For them, it’s just gone, and their feelings about that are just as valid as an adult’s feelings if someone took their phone or their coffee mug mid-sip. Forcing them to hand over a favorite thing doesn’t teach them to be generous—it teaches them that adults don’t respect their boundaries, and that if someone else wants something they love, they don’t get a say.
I started testing small, low-effort changes that have worked far better than forcing ever did. When I plan a playdate at my house, I tell the other parent upfront that Milo gets to pick one special toy to put on his top shelf that no one else plays with, and I pull out all the rest of his toys for everyone to share. That takes the pressure off both of us, and most parents don’t mind at all—they usually say their kid has one special thing too. If we’re at the park and someone asks for a toy he’s holding, I don’t step in and take it. I just redirect the other kid to a free toy, and offer to check in again in five minutes to see if Milo is done. If it’s a popular toy that multiple kids want, I pull out my phone and set a 2-minute timer so everyone can see exactly when the turn will switch. No negotiating, no yelling, no forcing.
What’s surprised me is that Milo shares way more now than he did when I pushed him to do it. Last month, he walked over to a toddler who was crying because she dropped her ice cream and gave her half his popsicle, no one asked him to do that. Last week, he voluntarily let his cousin play with the dump truck for 10 minutes because he was done digging and wanted to go swing. He doesn’t hide his favorite toys in the back of the closet anymore when people come over, because he knows no one’s going to take them away from him without asking.
But I still don’t talk about this much. I’ve had my mom raise her eyebrow at me, my sister-in-law make a comment about raising a self-absorbed kid, and enough awkward side-eyes at the playground to know that this goes against what most people think good parenting is. I get it—when we were growing up, we were all taught to share immediately no matter what, and that if you don’t, you’re rude. I used to think that too.
I don’t think this is the right way for every kid or every family. Some kids are happy to share all their stuff all the time, and that works perfectly for them. I still slip up sometimes, when the other parent is watching and I feel that old pressure to be the nice, easygoing mom, and I’ll nudge Milo a little to hand it over. Every time I do, I see that old tightness come back to his shoulders, and I remember why I stopped. This is working for us, even if it looks a little wrong to everyone else on the bench. I still feel a little guilty saying it out loud, but it’s the truth: forcing a kid to share before they’re ready doesn’t make them kind. It just makes them feel unheard. Right now, that’s enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I don’t force my young kid to share: a parenting confession I’ve never said out loud