Why First Day of School Fits Happen and What You Can Actually Do About It
The bell had barely finished ringing on the first day of second grade when I heard it: a sharp, gasping scream from the cubby area by my door. I looked up from sorting name tags, and there was Mia, the seven-year-old who’d bounced into my classroom two weeks earlier for meet the teacher, rolling on the linoleum with her fists clamped around the strap of her unicorn backpack, snot and tears streaking the glitter on her cheek. Her mom stood over her, red-faced, repeating “we talked about this” under her breath, while a line of other kids and their parents craned their necks to see.
I’ve been teaching elementary school for 11 years, and I’ve seen my share of first day fits. I also know what it feels like to be on the other side: seven years ago, I stood in a first grade hallway just like this one, while my own son threw a fit so big he threw up on his brand new sneakers. I’d spent the whole week before quizzing him on his teacher’s name, letting him pick out a brand new lunch box, reading every first day of school picture book we owned. I had no idea what hit me.
Back in my classroom that first day this year, I walked over to Mia, didn’t grab her or try to pull her up right away. I leaned against the cubby next to her and said, “That backpack has so many sparkles, it’s hard to let go of, isn’t it?” She paused screaming for half a second to glare at me, which was progress. Her mom jumped in, saying she was so sorry, that Mia had been talking nonstop about starting second grade all summer, that she picked out her overalls two nights ago and laid them out on her bed herself. I nodded. That’s almost always how it goes: the excited ones are often the ones who melt down first.
What most people don’t talk about is that most first day fits aren’t actually just separation anxiety. They’re overload. Think about it: your kid has been out of routine all summer. They woke up at a new time, ate a breakfast they might not usually eat, walked into a building that smells like new paint and floor wax, there are 20 other kids all talking at once, the bell is louder than they remember, their new socks have a scratchy seam, their new tooth is coming in and hurts, they’re not sure where the bathroom is, they’re worried they’ll forget how to do math. They hold all that in for 10 or 15 minutes because they want to be brave, and then it all comes out as a fit. It’s not bad behavior. It’s their nervous system hitting its limit.
I asked Mia if she wanted to come with me to look at my rock bin. I keep a bin of smooth, polished river rocks by the door of my classroom, for kids who need something small to hold when things feel too big. She unclenched her fist from the backpack strap long enough to let me pull her up, and we walked over. She spent three minutes running her fingers over all of them, and picked out a gray one with a white stripe through the middle to put in her overalls pocket. I told her she could hold it anytime she felt like the room was too loud. Then I asked her mom to stand with us for a minute while Mia showed us how the zipper on her backpack pulls out to turn into a water bottle holder. By the time we were done with that, Mia’s breathing had slowed down. Her mom gave her a hug, reminded her she’d be waiting at the door right after school, and left. Mia sat at her desk, squeezed her rock for a minute, and by the time we did our opening read-aloud, she was raising her hand to answer questions.
When my son had that first day fit, I made every common mistake first. I got embarrassed. I told him he was being silly, that he’d been excited for weeks. I tried to drag him to his chair by the arm, when all he wanted to do was hold onto my shirt. His teacher, a woman with 20 years under her belt, just waved me off and said “why don’t you let him help me feed the goldfish before you go.” Ten minutes after I left, she texted me a photo of him standing by the fish tank, grinning, holding the fish food. What I learned from that is small, specific distractions work way better than big speeches about being brave.
Over the years, I’ve picked up a handful of small, concrete things that work way better than the generic advice you usually hear. First, don’t tell a kid having a fit that they’re fine or that there’s nothing to cry about. When they’re overwhelmed, their brain can’t process that. Instead, name what you see: “It feels like everything is too much right now, huh?” That gives them a word for the messy feeling in their body, which starts to calm them down. Second, give them something small that’s theirs to keep with them, or a tiny job to do. A rock in the pocket, a written note from you tucked in their lunch box, letting them be the first to hand out crayons – it gives them a small sense of control when everything else feels new. Third, for parents: don’t sneak out. Sneaking out makes kids feel like you disappeared without warning, and that makes it harder for them to trust you’ll come back. Say a clear goodbye, tell them exactly when you’ll be back, and then leave. It’s okay to let the teacher take over, even if they’re still sniffling. For teachers: don’t pressure parents to leave immediately. Five extra minutes to do a quiet thing together doesn’t ruin your whole day, and it helps the kid feel safe.
Mia came back for the second day yesterday, walked in holding her rock, and asked if she could help me water the plants. This year, I had three first day fits in the whole K-2 wing, and all three kids were playing on the playground by lunch. My oldest is starting seventh grade this year, and he still got a stomach ache while he was waiting for the bus this morning. He doesn’t throw fits anymore, he just leans against the porch rail and says “my chest feels funny.” I put an extra chocolate chip cookie in his backpack, remind him he can go to the nurse if he needs a minute, and that’s that. A first day fit isn’t a sign that your kid is going to hate school, or that you did something wrong. It’s just a sign that the first day is really, really big. Some years, you just need a minute to fall apart before you can fall into place.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why First Day of School Fits Happen and What You Can Actually Do About It