Why Kids Ask Other People To Fill Out Their Homework (And What To Do About It)
The crinkle of my 12-year-old’s Chromebook screen pulled me away from folding mismatched socks after dinner last month. He leaned against the kitchen counter, half a granola bar sticking out of his hoodie pocket, and pushed the device toward me. “Can you fill this out for me? It’s homework. Idk what they want.”
I rolled my eyes at first, same as I always do. I’m guilty of the same assumption most parents have: if your kid won’t fill out their own homework, they’re just procrastinating, trying to sneak off to play video games instead of checking one more thing off their to-do list. I leaned in to scan the assignment, ready to give my usual “it’s your work, you do it” speech. It was a 10-question reflective survey for 7th grade health class, all about family identity. Questions like “What is a tradition your family has that makes you feel like you?” and “What is one rule your family always follows, no matter what?”
I looked back up at him. “This is your assignment. Why can’t you fill this out?” He kicked the kitchen baseboard and mumbled that last time he turned in an open-ended assignment like this, his teacher took points off because he only wrote one sentence. “I don’t know what she wants me to say. All my answers are boring.”
Three days later, I was volunteering in my oldest daughter’s 4th grade classroom, helping with reading rotations, when a girl from her class wandered over with a crumpled worksheet in hand. She said the exact same line: “Can you fill this out for me? Idk what to put. My mom said she’s busy with my little brother.” It was a parent input sheet for their upcoming career day project. The teacher had forgotten to mark that only the first two questions were supposed to be filled out by an adult, so the kid thought the whole assignment was for someone else to do. She’d been carrying it around for two days, scared to turn it in incomplete.
That’s when I started noticing how common this line is, and how wrong our default assumption usually is. It’s not that every kid who asks someone else to fill in their homework is lazy or trying to cheat. Most of the time, it’s one of three really simple, fixable things: open-ended assignments don’t have clear right answers, so kids get paralyzed worrying they’ll get a bad grade; directions are confusing, so they don’t know who’s actually supposed to fill out what; or they’re just tired after a full day of school and soccer practice and robotics club, and they want to check one more thing off their list fast.
I used to just shut it down immediately, demand they do it themselves, and we’d end up in a 20-minute fight that left both of us cranky, and more often than not I’d end up filling it out anyway just to end the argument. Now I have a couple of small, low-effort things I do that work way better.
First, I always start by reading the directions out loud with them, word for word. Half the time, that fixes the problem immediately. My son missed the tiny line at the top of that health survey that said “Your opinion, any answer is fine.” That 4th grader missed the note in parentheses that said “caregiver section only” next to the first two questions. Skimming directions is what kids do, especially when they’re already stressed about getting it wrong. Reading them together takes 30 seconds, and it clears up most confusion before it becomes a fight.
If it’s their assignment and they’re still stuck because they think their answer is too boring or wrong, I write one silly, casual answer of my own first on a scrap of paper, and show it to them. When my son panicked about the “what’s your favorite family holiday meal” question, I wrote “We order pizza every Christmas Eve because my husband and I both hate cooking big holiday meals” and he laughed and said “That’s what I was going to put! I thought I had to say ham or something.” He filled out the whole thing in 7 minutes after that, and he ended up getting full credit because his teacher loved how honest his answers were. It’s a tiny thing, but it shows them you don’t have to write a fancy, perfect answer to get it right.
If they just want to get it done fast because they’re exhausted after a long day, I don’t give them a big talk about responsibility. I say “I’ll help you set a 10-minute timer to knock this out. If you finish it yourself before the timer goes off, we can have the last of the chocolate chip cookies before bed.” Small incentive, clear expectation, no fight. That works way better than a lecture that goes in one ear and out the other.
For teachers, there’s an even easier fix: just spell it out. If the assignment needs input from a grown-up, write “This section is for your caregiver to fill out” in big bold letters at the top. If it’s open-ended, add one line that says “There are no wrong answers here, just share what you think.” It takes 10 extra seconds when you’re copying the worksheet or posting it to Google Classroom, and it cuts down on so much confusion for kids at home.
I still don’t handle it perfectly every time. Last week, my son came to me right before bed with another assignment, saying “Can you fill this in idk I forgot it was due tomorrow.” I was tired, I snapped and said “I’m not doing your homework for you, you should have done it earlier.” We both went to bed annoyed, and I felt bad about it after. The next day we talked about it, and it turned out he just needed 5 minutes of help to clarify the directions, like always.
Some weeks he still asks, some weeks I still get it wrong. But I’ve stopped assuming he’s just being lazy or trying to cut corners. Most of the time, he’s just a kid who doesn’t know what the adult in the room wants, and he needs a little push to figure it out himself.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Ask Other People To Fill Out Their Homework (And What To Do About It)