How to Handle Kid Friend Drama: Practical Tips From a 4th Grade Teacher
Last Tuesday, I pulled into the school pickup line, already half thinking about the grocery list I left on the fridge, when Lila climbed into the back seat and slammed the door harder than usual. She crossed her arms over her sparkly backpack and didn’t reach for the bag of cheddar Goldfish I keep in the center console for after school, which is how I knew this wasn’t a regular bad day.
“Mia hates me,” she said, voice wobbly. “She and Zoe were passing notes during lunch that said I’m boring, and they hid them under the table when I walked over. We were supposed to get ice cream after soccer this weekend.” I gripped the steering wheel and thought back to two days earlier, when a parent of one of my students had emailed me panicking about almost the exact same thing: her son was being left out of the group chat for the class sleepover, and she didn’t know whether to text all the other parents or tell him to just get over it.
When Lila was in first grade, I would’ve jumped straight to fixing it. I would’ve texted Mia’s mom right there in the pickup line, or told Lila to just go play with the other nice girls on her soccer team, or called Mia and Zoe mean for hurting her feelings. I’ve learned over the years, both as a mom and a teacher, that none of those things actually help.
The first thing I did that day was pull into the gas station down the road from the school, grab a $1 frozen lemonade from the cooler (Lila’s favorite when she’s upset) and said, “Tell me everything. Start with what you did when you walked up to the table.” I didn’t interrupt, I didn’t offer opinions, I just nodded and sipped my soda while she talked. She mentioned that Mia got a new American Girl doll last weekend and Lila forgot to compliment it when she showed her, that Lila had to leave the playground early the previous Friday so she couldn’t help Mia finish her chalk rainbows, that Mia had been sitting closer to Zoe at reading group for a week. By the time we pulled into our driveway, Lila twisted the lid off her lemonade and said, “I think she’s just mad about the doll. Maybe I should bring my new galaxy slime to school tomorrow and give it to her?” That was her idea, not mine. And it worked.
Earlier this week, that same mom of my third grade student texted me asking if she should schedule a forced playdate between her son Javi and his former best friend, who’d kicked him off the recess soccer team for playing too rough. I told her the first thing to do is ask Javi what he wants, not just assume you know what’s best. You can say, “Would you want me to talk to his mom to work this out, do you want to try talking to him yourself, or would you rather just play with your other friends this week?” Giving them that choice lets them practice problem solving instead of learning that every time they have a hard time with a friend, an adult will step in to fix it for them. It also keeps you from wasting energy pushing for a resolution your kid doesn’t even actually want.
Of course, there are times when you do have to step in. If your kid is being bullied, or if the drama is turning into ongoing exclusion that’s making them scared to go to school, you talk to the teacher or the other parent right away. But most of the time, friend drama is just that: messy, small, growing-pain stuff that kids need to work through on their own.
Last semester, I had a girl in my class named Clara who came to my desk crying every day for a week because the other girls at her lunch table wouldn’t let her sit with them. Instead of calling all the girls over to my desk for a big awkward talk in front of everyone, I pulled each one aside individually between classes. I didn’t scold any of them, I just asked, “What’s going on with your lunch table?” Turns out they’d just decided they wanted a small table for people who were drawing anime, and they didn’t realize Clara wanted to join too. No one was being a bully, they just didn’t know how to include her without making it weird. After I mentioned it to them, one of them went up to Clara after class and asked her to bring her sketchbook the next day. It fixed itself faster than any big group lecture I could have given.
It’s trickier when your kid is the one leaving someone else out. A lot of parents’ first instinct is to yell and make them invite the kid to whatever, but that just makes kids resentful. What I tell parents to do is sit with them after dinner, when everyone’s calm, and ask, “What made you decide not to ask X to play?” Last month a mom told me she did this with her 5th grade daughter, who’d been leaving her old best friend out of her weekend plans. Turns out the old friend had been copying her math homework for a month, and she was scared she’d get detention if the teacher found out, but she didn’t know how to say it. Instead of forcing her to be best friends again, the mom helped her practice saying, “I can’t let you copy my homework anymore, but I still want to hang out with you.” That was way more effective than grounding her for being mean.
After Lila brought her galaxy slime to school for Mia, they made up within 10 minutes of recess. Last week, though, she came home upset again because Mia only invited Zoe to her birthday sleepover, not her. We sat on the porch after dinner and had lemonade again, and she talked through all the parts that hurt. When I asked her what she wanted to do, she said she wanted to invite our neighbor’s daughter, the one who likes the same dinosaur toys she does, to the zoo on Saturday. That’s what we did. She still has bad days, and there will be more friend drama next month, and the month after that. It doesn’t get fixed perfectly every time, and it’s not going away. But so far, just listening first, letting her lead, and only stepping in when she asks me to has worked a lot better than any of my old fixes ever did.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Handle Kid Friend Drama: Practical Tips From a 4th Grade Teacher