What Happens When One Parent Enables Your Kid’s ‘Sick Day’ Excuse: A Parent’s Real Story
7:12 a.m. last Tuesday, I was stirring burnt coffee and trying to pack my 11-year-old Lila’s soccer cleats for after-school practice when I heard it: the soft, deliberate cough into a sleeve over the cereal box. Lila leaned against the counter, eyes big, and said her throat hurt too much to go to school. Before I could open my mouth to ask when it started, my wife was already crossing the kitchen, palm pressed to Lila’s forehead. “She does feel a little warm,” she said. “Why don’t you just stay home today? I’ve got back-to-back emails I can do from the couch, we can order soup.”
I set down the coffee mug. “She was chasing our neighbor’s dog around the block at 8 last night, right after her soccer game. I think her throat’s just dry from the heat we ran overnight.”
My wife gave me that look—the one that says I’m being an unfeeling hardass—and pulled the digital thermometer out of the junk drawer. It beeped at 98.6, perfectly normal. “Still,” she said, nodding at Lila. “You sound congested. Take the day.” Lila was already putting her cereal bowl in the sink and heading for the living room couch, phone in hand.
This isn’t a new fight. Since Lila started sixth grade, the “I don’t feel good” morning excuse has become a regular thing. It’s never actually a real flu, not nine times out of 10. It’s the big algebra test she didn’t study enough for. It’s the group presentation she’s nervous about. It’s the friend fight that she doesn’t want to deal with in homeroom. And every time, my wife is the first to cave.
For months I called it enabling, plain and simple. I thought she was letting Lila learn that bailing when things get uncomfortable is okay. But after we had a big blowout after the orchestra recital last month, I realized it’s not that simple. My wife grew up with constant panic attacks as a kid, and her mom always told her she was faking it, forced her to go to school even when she was hyperventilating in the parking lot. She’s just trying not to do that to our kid. I get that. I grew up with a dad who told me “pain is just weakness leaving the body” and made me play soccer with a broken wrist, so I get where we’re both coming from. We’re just reacting to our own childhoods, that’s all.
The orchestra recital was the turning point. Lila had a 16-bar solo she’d practiced every night for three months. The night before, she woke up at 10 p.m. crying, saying her stomach hurt so bad she couldn’t go. My wife was already pulling up the contact form for the orchestra director to excuse her when I asked Lila if it was stomach hurt, or scared hurt. She cried harder and admitted she was scared she’d forget the notes in front of the whole gym.
I said we’d go, and if she still felt bad halfway through, we’d leave. No shame. My wife got mad at me after, said I was forcing her to push through panic. But Lila went. She messed up one line, kept going, and after she got off stage she ran to us grinning, her hands still shaking, and said “I did it.” That night, we sat on the porch after Lila went to bed and actually talked instead of fighting, and we decided we needed something that worked for both of us, not just my way or her way.
We talked to Lila’s school counselor a week later, and came up with two small concrete rules that have stopped almost all of our fights, and helped Lila stop hiding her anxiety behind a “sick” excuse. First, we put a three-question checklist on the fridge, held up by a lopsided clay magnet Lila made in art class. Any time someone says she’s too sick to go, Lila answers these three questions out loud, no pressure, no judgment: 1) Do you have a fever over 99 degrees, or are you throwing up? 2) Would you still stay home if you didn’t have the thing you’re nervous about today? 3) If you skip today, will you have to do twice as much work tomorrow that will make it even worse? It sounds small, but it just puts everything out in the open. Lila doesn’t have to lie about being sick to get a break, and my wife and I don’t have to fight about it in front of her.
Second, we agreed on a middle ground instead of the all-or-nothing stay home or go to school: the half day. If it’s anxiety, not actual sickness, Lila can go to school, get through the hard thing (test, presentation, whatever), and then we pick her up early, get ice cream, and spend the rest of the afternoon watching whatever she wants. That lets my wife know we’re not forcing her to push through overwhelming panic all day, and it lets me know she’s not learning that bailing entirely is the first option when things get hard.
Two weeks ago, we tested it out. Lila said her throat hurt the morning of her group presentation. We went through the three questions, and she admitted after a minute that she was just scared her group would forget their lines and she’d look stupid. We agreed on the half day: she went, did the presentation, I picked her up at 1, got her mint chocolate chip, and she told me in the car that it wasn’t even that bad—their teacher actually gave them an A.
It’s not perfect. We still slip up. Last week, Lila faked a headache to stay home and finish the new season of her favorite show, and my wife just let her, and I didn’t say anything because she’d had three tests in two days and she deserved it. Sometimes my wife still wants to just let her stay home before I even pull out the checklist, and sometimes I still get impatient and push her to go when she’s actually more overwhelmed than I realize.
I used to think enabling was a black and white thing: one parent is wrong, one is right. Now I know most of the time, it’s just two people with different good intentions trying to do right by their kid. We’re not going to get it right every time. Right now, this is working more often than not, and that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When One Parent Enables Your Kid’s ‘Sick Day’ Excuse: A Parent’s Real Story