GED vs High School Diploma: What California Colleges Actually Prefer, From a Parent’s Experience
The plastic chair in the Sacramento community college counseling office stuck to the back of my bare calves last month, the AC blowing too hard after I hiked three blocks from the overflow parking lot. I’d dropped my 16-year-old off at soccer practice 20 minutes early, and squeezed in this appointment to finally map out finishing my own education, 22 years after I quit 11th grade to work full time when my mom got diagnosed with stage 2 breast cancer.
I told the counselor I’d already signed up for GED prep classes at the local library, that’s what everyone I knew who dropped out did back in the 90s, and I’d always heard a GED was the same as a diploma for college. She leaned forward, tapped a pencil against my half-filled worksheet, and said the line that caught me completely off guard: “Just so you know, quite a few higher ed institutions here in California prefer a traditional high school diploma over a GED. If you can finish out your credits for a diploma, that’s the better move for most four-year programs.”
I left the office with a crumpled pamphlet in my tote bag and stopped for carnitas tacos on the drive home. I texted my friend Lila, who works in undergraduate admissions at a Cal State campus north of Los Angeles, and asked her if that was actually true, or just something counselors made up. She called me back 10 minutes later while I was folding my son’s soccer gear, and confirmed it. It’s not written in big bold letters on any admissions website, she said, but it’s a quiet preference most admissions teams hold. GEDs are accepted, of course—every public university in California has to take them from state residents—but when you’re comparing two similar applicants, the one with a traditional high school diploma almost always gets the nod. She said admissions counselors often read a GED as a sign you couldn’t commit to four years of consistent coursework, even if there was a good reason you left high school early.
I’d never heard this before. Growing up in a small Central Valley town, when I told my high school guidance counselor I had to quit to work, she just handed me a GED brochure and said that was the only option for people like me. I never questioned it until that day in the community college office.
I called my local public adult school the next morning to ask how this whole diploma thing works, and that’s when I got the second surprise: it’s totally free for California adults, and I don’t have to start over. All I need to do is bring in my old high school transcript, they’ll count every credit I already earned, I can test out of the classes I passed back in the day, and I just finish the 12 credits I’m missing. It’s only a few months slower than getting a GED for most people, but you walk out with an official California high school diploma, just like you graduated at 18.
Over the last few months, I’ve talked to more counselors and other adults going back to school, and the pattern holds. If you just need a high school equivalency to get into a 6-month trade certificate for welding or certified nursing assisting, or to qualify for a promotion at work that just requires any high school completion, a GED is totally fine, and it’s faster. No need to put in the extra time for a diploma. But if you’re aiming for a four-year degree, whether that’s a Cal State, UC, or even a private non-profit college in the state, the preference for a diploma is real.
This isn’t just useful for adults like me going back to school. I’ve seen it come up again and again with my son’s classmates. Half a dozen teens I know have struggled with mental health or family issues over the last few years, fallen behind on credits, and their high school counselors immediately suggest switching to a GED track as an easy out. Most parents I talk to have no idea that their kid can still work toward a traditional diploma, either through their high school’s credit recovery program or through the local adult school, for no extra cost.
The concrete advice I give these parents, and any adults asking me about this, is simple: First, pull your old or your teen’s current transcript before you commit to a GED. Count exactly how many credits you’re missing. More often than not, it’s fewer than you think, and most districts let you make up missing credits for free. Second, call your local public adult education program directly and ask if they issue state high school diplomas, and what the process is for someone who dropped out. Don’t just take the first suggestion you get from a general counselor who might not be up to date on local options. Third, if you’re going the college route, email the admissions office of the specific program you want and ask what their actual preference is. Some small private colleges don’t care at all, but most big public programs do lean toward diplomas.
I’m still on the fence, honestly. The GED would take me six months of part-time study, and I could be done with that requirement this year. The diploma will take me 18 months, going two nights a week after my shift at the daycare and on occasional Saturdays when my son doesn’t have a game. The child development bachelor’s program I want to apply to accepts both, but my community college transfer advisor told me the diploma will give me a clear edge when I apply for the competitive upper division slot, and later when I apply for a job at my son’s elementary school.
Next week I have my transcript evaluation appointment at the adult school. I don’t know if I’ll stick it out—if overtime at work will pile up, or my son will need more time driving to practices, or something else will throw my schedule off. But I’m glad I know this option exists, when for 22 years I thought a GED was my only choice. It’s one of those small, unadvertised bits of information that can change the whole trajectory of applying to school, and I’m still passing it on to anyone who will listen.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » GED vs High School Diploma: What California Colleges Actually Prefer, From a Parent’s Experience