Why Kids Hide Comfort Objects At School (And What I Learned From My Son’s New Backpack And Squirtle)
The August humidity still clung to my shirt when my seven-year-old stepped up to the bus stop, his new navy backpack pulling his small shoulders forward. I’d helped him pack it the night before: two sharpened pencils, a folder with a dinosaur on the front, a pack of fruit snacks for snack time, and a spare change of clothes just in case. It wasn’t until he squeezed it against his chest that I noticed the lopsided bulge on the inner side, pressing out against the zipper. “What’ve you got in there?” I asked, nodding at the bump. He kicked a crack in the sidewalk and mumbled “nothing” so quiet I could barely hear it. When the bus pulled up and he hurried up the steps, the top zipper caught on his hoodie and pulled open an inch. I caught a flash of faded blue felt: Squirtle’s tail.
Squirtle has been with my son since he was 18 months old. I picked him up at a Disney gift shop on a trip for his older sister’s birthday, and he’s never left my son’s side since. One ear is thin from years of chewing, the right eye is half loose, and we’ve sewn his left foot back on twice. Before school started, we talked a dozen times about whether Squirtle would come along. My son shut it down immediately. “Second graders don’t bring stuffed animals to school,” he told me, stirring his oatmeal one morning. “Jake brought a dinosaur last year and everyone called him baby. I don’t want to be baby.” I told him over and over it was fine if he changed his mind, that no one would tease him if he brought Squirtle. He just shook his head and went back to his oatmeal.
That afternoon, he dumped his backpack by the door to grab his soccer cleats for practice, and Squirtle tumbled out under the coffee table. He went bright red, dove after him before I could even see the whole plush, and tried to stuff him back into the bag before I said anything. I sat down on the carpet next to him, didn’t reach for Squirtle, just waited. After a minute he mumbled that the new backpack’s inner pocket was way deeper than his old one. “No one can feel him if I squeeze him tight against the side,” he said. “I just touch his foot when math is hard or when I miss you. No one knows.”
I’ve read all the casual parenting posts about comfort objects, how they’re normal for toddlers, how most kids leave them home full-time by the time they hit elementary school. I’d started to think this was a problem, that we’d let him keep Squirtle too long, that it meant he was too anxious to handle school on his own. But sitting there on the floor, with a half-chewed plush between us, I realized what he’d done wasn’t regression. It was problem-solving. He didn’t outgrow his need for comfort. He just figured out how to meet that need while fitting in with the unspoken social rules of his grade.
I’d been making the mistake of pushing him to be open about it this whole time. I kept saying “there’s nothing to be ashamed of,” which just made it more obvious that it was something people usually are ashamed of. The first small shift I made was stopping that. When he asked if I could help him rearrange his new backpack to make more room for Squirtle next to his lunch box, I just did it. I didn’t give a speech about being brave. I just moved the extra notebook to the outer pocket and showed him how to tuck Squirtle in so he wouldn’t shift around during gym class.
If your kid wants to hide their comfort object, let them. You don’t have to email the teacher to tell her, you don’t have to make it a class discussion, you don’t have to push them to “be confident” and bring it out for show-and-tell. If they wanted it out, they’d put it out. It’s their business, and respecting that builds more trust than pushing them to be someone they’re not ready to be yet. All you really need to do is small, concrete things: if they’re picking out a new backpack, let them prioritize one with a deep inner pocket or hidden zipper compartment if that’s what they want. If they leave the comfort object at home by accident, don’t make a big deal about it when you drop it off at school—just slip it to them in the hallway and leave, no fanfare. Don’t mention it to other adults or other kids unless they say it’s okay.
A lot of parents worry that still needing a comfort object at 7 or 8 means their kid is behind developmentally, or extra anxious. But that’s not true. All people have small, silly comfort things they hide. I keep a chipped lip balm my best friend gave me in my work bag for big meetings, I have a worn out college hoodie I only wear when I’m sick. We just hide ours better. Kids are just learning how to do that hiding.
Last week, I had parent-teacher conferences. His teacher said he’s had far fewer stomach aches this semester than last year, that he raises his hand more and seems more settled. I didn’t tell her about Squirtle tucked in the inner pocket of the new backpack. It’s not my secret to share.
The other night, my son was doing his math homework at the kitchen table, and he pulled Squirtle out and set him next to his worksheet. I was washing dishes, and I didn’t say anything, just kept rinsing plates. He didn’t announce it, he just did it. Some days I wonder if he’ll still be tucking Squirtle into his backpack when he’s in middle school, if that’s something we’ll still be navigating then. But right now, it works. The new backpack wasn’t just a back-to-school purchase we grabbed at Target. It was a safe place for him to be both a second grader who wants to fit in, and a kid who still needs a little piece of home with him. I don’t know when he’ll decide he doesn’t need to hide Squirtle anymore, or if he ever will. That’s okay. For now, I’m just here to help him rearrange the pockets when he needs it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Hide Comfort Objects At School (And What I Learned From My Son’s New Backpack And Squirtle)