When your teen wants to post on Reddit: What parents need to know about karma and account age rules
Last Tuesday, my 14-year-old daughter Lila leaned against the kitchen fridge after dinner, phone in one hand, half-eaten chocolate chip cookie in the other, and frowned like she’d just been told she couldn’t go to the weekend retreat her friend was hosting. “Mom, why won’t they let me post anything?” she said, turning the phone toward me. The pop-up message was clear: In order to post your account must be older than 10 days and have 100 positive karma. She’d made the account four days earlier, after months of begging to join the big crochet subreddit where all her favorite pattern designers posted. She’d just finished her most ambitious project yet: a plump green frog with hand-painted googly eyes and a tiny bump on its belly from a lopsided increase row she’d decided to keep instead of redoing. She was desperate to share it and credit the designer who’d written the free pattern.
I wiped flour off my hands onto my jeans and sat down next to her on the living room couch, the unpaired socks I’d pulled from the dryer that morning piled next to us in a laundry basket. I’d joined Reddit back in college, and I’d run into this exact rule when I made a new account a few years back, but I’d forgotten how confusing it is when you see it for the first time. Lila was convinced she’d already messed up, that someone had reported her for no reason, that the whole community hated new people before they even said anything. That reaction made total sense to me: when you’re 14, any barrier to sharing something you worked hard on feels personal.
I started by pulling up the subreddit’s about page, which spelled the rule out plain: the 10 day/100 karma requirement was put in place to cut down on spam bots and troll accounts that make new profiles every day to post scams, non-consensual explicit content, or hate speech. If you have to wait 10 days and earn positive engagement from other users before you can post to the main feed, it’s way too much work for bad actors who just want to flood the space with garbage. Most big public communities on Reddit use this rule for that exact reason, it’s not a personal snub to new users. That took a little of the edge off Lila’s frustration, but she still wanted to know how she was supposed to get 100 karma if she couldn’t post anything.
That’s where the practical part came in, the stuff I wish I’d known when I hit this rule years ago. I didn’t just tell her to “be patient” or “wait it out.” First, we found the sub’s weekly open thread for new users, which almost every big sub hosts specifically for people who haven’t hit the karma requirement yet. It’s a space for introductions, small shares, and chatting before you can post to the main feed. Lila uploaded her frog photo there, wrote a quick line saying she was new and loved the patterns from the sub, and then we scrolled through a few other people’s shares. I pointed out that comments that say something specific, like “I love that shade of purple, I’ve been looking for yarn that color forever” get way more upvotes than one-word comments like “cute.” That’s not a trick, that’s just how communities work—people respond to actual interaction.
Over the next four days, Lila popped on for 10 minutes a day after homework to comment on other people’s projects in the open thread and chat about Zelda in a small teen hobby sub she’d joined. By yesterday, that was 8 days after she made her account, she had 92 positive karma. She still needs 8 more, and two more days to hit the 10 day mark, so she’s got plenty of time. She checks her karma every morning when she wakes up, and teases herself for being obsessed, but she’s not mad anymore. She even added a little note to her phone with the caption she wants to use when she finally posts to the main feed, so she’s ready when the timer hits zero.
I’ve thought a lot this week about how these random, seemingly arbitrary online rules get framed, especially when we’re talking about kids online. A lot of parents I talk to would just tell their kid to get off the app, or offer to make an account under their name to post for them. That’s the first mistake I see people make: using an adult account that violates community rules not only can get both accounts banned, it skips the whole low-stakes lesson of learning how the community works. Another mistake is dismissing the rule as stupid gatekeeping, which just confirms for a kid that the whole world is out to get them. The reality is, this rule works exactly as it’s supposed to: it keeps bad actors out, and it gives new users a low-pressure chance to get used to how the community interacts before they post their own work.
The concrete steps I’ve ended up with for any parent whose kid hits this pop-up are simple, and don’t take more than 15 minutes to work through: First, confirm that the error isn’t a ban—it’s just a community rule, 99% of the time it’s nothing your kid did wrong. Second, find the new user open thread, that’s the fastest way to start earning karma legitimately. Third, remind your kid that specific, friendly comments get more engagement than low-effort one-liners, which is a good habit for any online space. Fourth, don’t upvote their posts over and over from your own account—most subs can detect vote manipulation, and it can get their account flagged, which is way harder to fix than just waiting a few days.
Tonight, Lila left her frog propped on the mantel next to her other crocheted projects, and we ordered pizza for dinner. She’s not stressed about the last 8 karma, says she’ll get it tomorrow when she comments on a few more posts. I don’t know if her frog will get dozens of upvotes, or just a handful, when she finally posts it next week. That doesn’t really matter to her, or to me. This small, silly little hoop to jump through has been a better lesson about how online communities work than any 30-minute talk I’ve given about internet safety. It’s not perfect, and there’s still a lot about online teen culture that I don’t get, but right now, this is working. We’ll see what happens when she hits post.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When your teen wants to post on Reddit: What parents need to know about karma and account age rules