Parenting Tips for Shy Kids: What I Learned When My 5-Year-Old Became a Flower Girl
The scratchy wool carpet of the church basement smelled like old coffee and glazed donuts leftover from the morning setup. My 5-year-old Lila had her face pressed into the side of my thigh, one hand fisted in the hole of my worn black leggings, and wouldn’t look up when the wedding coordinator knelt down to greet her. “We’re so excited to have our flower girl tomorrow,” the coordinator said, holding out a wicker basket full of pink rose petals. “You gonna show us how you’ll throw those pretty petals?” Lila only pressed harder into my leg. My cousin leaned over, voice low: “Do we need to line up a backup? I don’t mind stepping in if she bails.”
My sister had asked Lila to be flower girl six months earlier, right after Lila binged a princess wedding movie and announced she wanted to throw petals too. I was surprised she said yes – Lila’s always been the kid who hangs back at playdates, who won’t answer the phone when grandma calls, who sits out the group recital at the end of every dance class. For the first four years of her life, I spent a lot of time nudging her: “Just go say hi to the kids,” “It’s easy, just order your chicken nuggets,” “Don’t be shy.” I thought shyness was a habit I could talk her out of, something she’d grow out of if I pushed hard enough.
A month before the wedding, Lila’s preschool teacher pulled me aside after pickup. She’d noticed Lila wouldn’t participate in class show-and-tell, even when Lila brought the T-Rex toy she’d been talking about for weeks. She didn’t give me vague notes about being more supportive. She said: “Next time she has something big she’s nervous about, don’t tell her to not be scared. Tell her it’s okay to be scared, then let her practice in tiny chunks, on her time. She can stop whenever she wants, no pressure. And give her an out before it even starts – let her know if she gets halfway and wants to quit, you’ll come get her, no one will be upset.”
I decided to try that with the flower girl thing. Instead of quizzing her every night about whether she was going to go through with it, I pulled the basket of petals out one evening after dinner and said, “We can practice walking and throwing petals for as long as you want. If you don’t like it after 10 seconds, we put it away, no big deal.” First day, she held the basket for 20 seconds, then handed it back. I put it in the closet and didn’t mention it for three days. Next time, she wanted to walk from our front door to the fridge, throwing petals as she went. She did that twice, then wanted to go color, so we did. A week later, she dragged the basket out herself and asked me to stand at the end of the driveway, like I was the bride. She walked all the way down, throwing petals the whole way, then did it again for our golden retriever, who was napping on the grass.
The next morning, she let my sister curl her hair and pull the tulle dress on without complaining. When it was time to line up at the back of the church, her hand got sweaty in mine, and she squeezed so tight her knuckles went white. I didn’t say “you’re so brave” or “there’s nothing to worry about.” I knelt down so I was eye level with her and said, “If you get halfway down the aisle and you don’t want to keep going, just turn around. I’ll be right here to come get you. No one will be mad, I promise.” She nodded, and when the music changed, she stepped out.
She walked so slow. Halfway down, one petal stuck to her shoe, and she stopped to bend over and pick it off, then tossed it into the air like it was the most important thing in the world. Most of the petals landed in a lopsided pile on the left side of the aisle, but no one cared. Everyone smiled, and when she got to the front, she climbed right onto the step next to my sister and grinned out at the crowd. I cried a little, not because it was perfect, but because she did it entirely on her own terms.
A lot of people talk about quiet kids like they’re a problem to fix, like being outgoing is the only end goal. I used to think that too. But what I learned from this whole experience is that pushing shy kids to perform before they’re ready just makes them more likely to shut down. The small, concrete steps that worked for Lila here work for almost every new scary thing we face now.
If she’s nervous about a playdate, I don’t make her go say hi to the kids the second we walk in the door. I let her stand with me for 15 minutes, watching, before she decides to join. If she has to speak in front of class, we practice for one minute a day, not 10, and she can stop whenever she wants. We always talk about the out first: if you get up there and don’t want to do it, we can leave together, no questions, no disappointment. That takes the big, scary weight off the whole thing – most of the time, knowing they don’t have to do it is what gives them the courage to try.
It doesn’t mean Lila isn’t still shy. Last week, we went out for ice cream, and she still made me order hers for her. She told me last week she doesn’t want to be in the preschool holiday play next month, and that’s okay. I told her we can still go, sit in the back, and watch if she wants, and if she changes her mind, there’s a spot for her. I’m proud of my little flower girl not because she cured her shyness or became the life of the party. I’m proud of her because she tried something that scared her, when she was good and ready.
We’re still taking it one small step at a time. There’s no big finish, no big transformation. Some days she tries new things, some days she doesn’t. That’s okay with me now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Parenting Tips for Shy Kids: What I Learned When My 5-Year-Old Became a Flower Girl