What To Do When Another Kid’s Parents Won’t Let Their Child Hang Out With Yours
I leaned against my minivan after school last October, tapping my debit card on the cracked screen of my phone waiting for Lila, my 13-year-old, when she trundled over with her neon pink water bottle slung over one shoulder, goldfish crumbs dusted on her hoodie, and her shoulders hunched all the way up to her ears. Before I could ask how her day was, she said, “Mia’s parents canceled this weekend. They won’t let her hang out with me at all anymore.”
Lila and Mia had been attached at the hip since fifth grade, when they bonded over their shared love of bad anime and the same brand of glitter gel pen. We’d had Mia at our house for countless sleepovers, dragged her along to apple picking and birthday parties for my younger son. I’d driven both girls to the mall for back to school shopping more times than I could count. I knew Mia’s parents were stricter than most, stricter than me for sure, but this came out of nowhere.
A few days later, I heard from another mom at the middle school PTA meeting that Mia’s parents had seen the behavior mark on Lila’s account from September. Lila had gotten a lunch detention for talking back to her social studies teacher, when she refused to do a 45 minute test prep worksheet and said it was “a waste of time that could be spent actually learning things.” It wasn’t her first tiff with a teacher, and it wouldn’t be her last, but I never thought it would cost her her best friend.
A week later, I ran into Mia’s mom by the skim milk cooler at the grocery store. She tried to duck behind a display of orange juice, but I waved and walked over, made small talk about how expensive cereal was these days, before I said, “I heard the girls aren’t able to hang out right now. I wanted to check if there’s anything we can work out.” She shifted her gallon of milk from one hand to the other and said, “We just want Mia to focus on her grades right now. We think she should spend time with kids who take school more seriously.”
I wanted to snap back that my kid takes school more seriously than most, that she just hates pointless busy work, that she gets A’s and B’s anyway. But I bit my tongue. I’d already learned that getting defensive just makes people dig in harder. Instead I said, “That makes total sense. Any parent wants their kid around people that help them stay on track. If you ever want Mia to come over to study, I’m home most afternoons. They can get all their work done before they do anything else, I’ll make sure of it.” She nodded, mumbled a thanks, and we went our separate ways.
The first rule I set for myself at home was I wouldn’t badmouth Mia’s parents in front of Lila. It’s tempting, when your kid is hurt, to call the other parents unfair or ridiculous to make your kid feel better. But that puts kids in an impossible spot: they still love their friend, so they end up feeling like they have to choose between being loyal to you or to their friend. I stuck to that rule even when I was fuming about the situation. If Lila said Mia texted her a silly meme, I just said that sounds like Mia, she always makes me laugh. I don’t bring up the ban unless Lila brings it up first.
The second thing we did is we let the girls keep their connection going in small, low-stakes ways that don’t require Mia’s parents to approve a full hangout. Lila still sits with Mia at lunch, they pass notes in homeroom, they do 20 minute facetime calls after homework every night to catch up. We don’t push for sleepovers or weekend trips right now. Pushing would just make Mia’s parents more nervous that we’re trying to undermine their rules, which makes them less likely to say yes to anything down the line.
A lot of people assume when another parent won’t let their kid hang out with yours, it means you or your kid did something unforgivable. In my experience, it’s almost always about the other parent’s worries, not anything you did. Mia’s parents are first generation immigrants, they worked three jobs between them to get where they are, and they’re scared that one wrong step in middle school will derail Mia’s chance at college. They’re not mean, they’re just scared. That doesn’t make it hurt less for Lila, but it makes it easier to not take it personally.
It’s been two months now. Last week, Mia’s parents let her come over to work on the group science fair project Lila and Mia are in together. She stayed an hour and a half, they finished their display board, ate chocolate chip cookies I baked, drew for 20 minutes, and her dad picked her up right on time. I made small talk with him about the project, didn’t bring up the whole situation, and that was that.
We don’t know if they’ll ever let Mia come over for a sleepover again. Lila still gets quiet some nights, says it’s weird that her best friend can’t just come over to watch a movie like she used to. But things are better than they were two months ago. I used to think my job was to fight every battle my kid had, to make everything fair for her. Now I think, a lot of the time, the best thing you can do is let your kid feel sad about the unfair stuff, stay out of the way of the small connections they can still have, and give everyone time to adjust. It’s not a perfect fix, but it’s working for us right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When Another Kid’s Parents Won’t Let Their Child Hang Out With Yours