What to Look For In a Head to Toe Baby Wash: Real Mom Tips From Testing 12+ Brands
The bath mat was already soaked through when my 8-month-old, Lila, decided to face-plant into the tub, sending a half-empty bottle of lavender body wash sliding into the toilet. I fished it out, wiped the water off my sweatpants, and glanced down at the red, bumpy rash creeping along the back of her neck. It was the third wash we’d gone through in two months, and I was this close to just using my own drugstore body wash and calling it a day.
When I had my first two boys, I never thought twice about baby wash. I grabbed the pretty lavender one that was gifted at my first baby shower, used it for years, never had a single problem. If it said “pediatrician tested” on the bottle, I took it at face value. When Lila came along, four years after my youngest boy, I just grabbed the same brand I’d always used, assuming it would work the same way. For the first month, it did. Then the bumps started.
First it was just a little redness along her hairline after bath time. I thought it was dry skin from the heater being on in the winter. I slathered on extra baby cream, switched to the “ultra moisturizing” version of the same wash. A week later, the rash spread down her neck and to the folds of her arms, and she’d scratch at it while I nursed her, waking herself up mid-feed. I brought her to the pediatrician, who ruled out a food allergy and said it was most likely contact dermatitis from something in her products. “Most parents don’t realize how many baby washes have hidden irritants,” she told me. “Your baby’s skin isn’t done developing yet, so anything extra seeps right through that thin barrier.”
I left the office with a referral to a dermatologist and a short list of ingredients to avoid, and I started testing. I bought the $18 organic one from the natural food store, it was so thick it turned the bath water into a slippery mess and left a film on Lila’s scalp that made her cradle cap worse. I got the drugstore one that advertised “hypoallergenic for sensitive skin” — it had “natural fragrance” listed on the label, and by the next day her rash was back. I even tried the gentle wash I use for my face, just out of desperation, until I remembered it has salicylic acid that’s way too strong for a baby. After six weeks, I had 10 half-empty bottles lined up under my bathroom sink, each one a tiny failed experiment.
My friend Sarah, who’s a pediatric nurse and has two kids of her own with eczema, came over for coffee one night, saw me staring at the shelf of bottles and laughed. “You’re overcomplicating this,” she said, leaning against the doorframe. “Head to toe wash is supposed to make your life easier, not give you a stress rash. Most of the fancy marketing is just that — marketing.” She gave me two quick rules to follow, right there, that changed everything.
First, always skip anything with the word “fragrance” anywhere on the label, even “natural fragrance.” That term is a loophole, she said. Brands don’t have to list all the chemicals they use to make that scent, and 70% of the time, one of those unlisted ingredients is an irritant for baby skin. She also pointed out that “unscented” isn’t the same as “fragrance-free.” Unscented just means they added another chemical to mask the smell of the other ingredients, so it still has irritants. I just need to look for the exact phrase “fragrance-free” on the front of the bottle. That’s it, one quick check before I buy.
Second, you don’t need all the extra add-ins. Tea tree oil for cradle cap, shea butter for moisture, tear-free boosters that claim not to sting eyes. Most of those add-ins are unnecessary, and a lot of them cause irritation. For a baby that takes 10 minute baths three times a week, a simple wash is all you need. If you need extra moisture, you add it after the bath with lotion, not in the wash.
She sent me home with a sample of Vanicream Gentle Baby Wash, which I’d never even heard of before. It came in a plain white bottle, no fancy pictures of babies on the label, no scent at all. It doesn’t lather very much, which I thought was a problem at first — I was used to that big fluffy foam that means it’s working, right? I used half the pump the first time I washed Lila, and nothing. Sarah told me that’s the point: the sulfates that make all that lather are the same ones that dry out and irritate baby skin. A little bit goes a long way, even if it doesn’t foam up.
By the third bath, Lila stopped scratching her neck. Within a week, the red bumps were almost gone. It works as shampoo too, which is what I wanted from a head to toe wash — less stuff to balance on the edge of the tub when I’m holding a wiggly baby who keeps trying to stand up. It costs about $10 a bottle, which is more than the $3 generic I used to buy, but it lasts twice as long, so it evens out.
I’ve told a handful of new moms about this lately, and a lot of them ask if they need to switch to this even if their baby doesn’t have sensitive skin. The answer is no. My oldest boy never had a rash in his life, and he used that $3 Aveeno unscented head to toe until he was four, and it was perfectly fine. The point isn’t to throw out everything you have and run to the store. It’s just to know what to look for if you do run into problems. Most parents don’t know that a baby’s skin barrier doesn’t fully mature until they’re at least a year old. That’s not something they tell you in birthing class, or on the product labels. All those “pediatrician approved” labels don’t mean anything when your baby is the one that reacts to the hidden fragrance.
I still have all those half-empty bottles lined up under my sink. I keep meaning to throw them out, but a friend of mine is due in six weeks, and I’m just going to send them home with her so she can test samples instead of buying full bottles of a dozen different things like I did. Lila still gets a little redness on her neck if my husband grabs the wrong kid’s body wash by accident when he’s doing bath time half-asleep on a Friday night. I keep a small travel bottle of the Vanicream in my diaper bag now, just for emergencies. It’s not fancy, it doesn’t smell like lavender, and it doesn’t come in a pretty bottle for your Instagram nursery shelf. It works, though. And that’s all I really need from a baby wash, these days.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Look For In a Head to Toe Baby Wash: Real Mom Tips From Testing 12+ Brands