1 vs 2 Bedrooms for a Family of 3: What We Learned After Two Years of Trial and Error
It was 8:17 PM on moving day, I was standing in our 650-square-foot apartment holding a half-warm sippy cup of chocolate milk, staring at the twin air mattress we’d rolled out on the floor next to our queen bed, when my 6-year-old son Milo tilted his head and asked, “Do I not get my own room anymore?”
We’d left our two-bedroom apartment a week earlier, after my husband’s construction company cut hours and we needed to slash $800 off our monthly rent to stay in Milo’s elementary school zone. The only place that fit our budget was a one-bedroom. We’d gone back and forth for months on whether it would work: one room for all three of us, or rearrange the weird L-shaped living room to carve out a tiny second nook. We’d decided to try the all-in one bedroom first to avoid the hassle of moving furniture around right away.
The first eight months had good bits I didn’t expect. Mornings were softer – we’d all wake up tangled in blankets, Milo would crawl into our bed for 10 minutes of cartoons before school, no one had to trudge down a dark hall to round anyone up. When Milo had nightmares after that big thunderstorm last spring, he didn’t have to call for us and wait; he just rolled over and grabbed my hand. When he had a fever, I could check his temperature without leaving the room. For a while, I thought we’d pulled it off, that people made too big a deal out of needing separate rooms.
But the hard parts started creeping in slow. I work part-time from home, so I’d often be on work calls in the bedroom after Milo went to bed, and the blue light from my laptop kept him up. He started having more bedwetting accidents, and it took me a month to realize he was holding it all night because he didn’t want to walk past the foot of our bed in the dark to get to the bathroom. His kindergarten teacher pulled me aside one day and said he’d started hiding in the coat cubby during free play, and would snap at any kid who even brushed his backpack. She said it looked like he was guarding his only private space.
I talked to our pediatrician a week later, and she pointed out that around age 6, kids start developing a really clear sense of personal space. They need something that’s just theirs, where they can choose to be alone, change clothes without adults around, or just be messy without anyone commenting. I’d always thought that meant a full separate bedroom with a door and everything, but she said it doesn’t have to be that fancy – it just has to be a space they can call their own, that they can close off if they want.
So the next weekend, my husband and I spent a Saturday rearranging the apartment. We pushed our queen bed into the long part of the L-shaped living room, and used three 5-foot tall secondhand bookcases and a tension rod with a blackout curtain to block off the shorter end of the L for Milo. His new room is 7 feet by 8 feet – just big enough for his twin bed, his toy box, and a tiny little folding desk for coloring. It cost us less than $150 total, most of that for the curtain and the hardware to anchor the shelves to the wall so they don’t tip.
It’s been only a month, but the difference is obvious. Milo started closing the curtain to get dressed every morning, something he never cared about before. He invited his best friend from school over last week, and they spent an hour behind the curtain playing dinosaur battle, no adults allowed. The cubby hiding at school stopped a week after we rearranged.
We still have our messy moments: I trip over his action figures when I walk past the curtain to get to the kitchen, and our sleeping area is so small we can’t both open our suitcases at the same time when we’re packing for a trip. We still don’t have a separate guest space, so when my mom comes to visit, she sleeps on the couch in the dining nook.
I get asked all the time by other parents in our neighborhood who are also downsizing whether one bedroom is enough for a family of three, or if you have to spring for two. The answer isn’t one size fits all, but there’s a few things I wish I’d known from the start. First, if you’re stuck in a one bedroom, don’t assume you have to all share the same open space. Even a 6×8 corner with a curtain gives a kid enough privacy for what they need. You don’t need a door or a full wall – just a visual boundary that they get to control. Second, if you do all share one bedroom, switch your late-night screen time to a red light filter, and keep a small 5-watt night light by the bathroom door so kids don’t feel awkward getting up in the middle of the night. That small change cut Milo’s bedwetting accidents in half even before we rearranged. Third, for younger kids under 5, sharing one room works totally fine – most little kids don’t need that private space yet, and the proximity makes night wakings way easier. It’s once they hit elementary school that the need for their own space kicks in, even a tiny one.
We’re still saving for a bigger place, hopefully a three-bedroom in a couple of years where Milo gets a real room with a real door and a window that looks out at the street. Some nights, when I’m folding laundry on our bed and I can hear Milo giggling to himself behind his curtain, I think this weird little setup we have is better than any big fancy room we could have bought. It’s not perfect, and I still bump my hip on the bookcase at least once a week, but it meets what we need right now. We don’t have it all figured out, and that’s okay.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » 1 vs 2 Bedrooms for a Family of 3: What We Learned After Two Years of Trial and Error