Why Good School Programs Vanish When Their Founder Leaves (And What Actually Stays)
I was waiting for my third grader to get released from school last May, coffee sweating through the paper cup in my hand, when Ms. Lopez stepped out the front door carrying a cardboard box marked TROWELS, SEEDS, SIGN. Ms. Lopez was the art teacher who’d started the school’s community garden eight years earlier, and she was retiring that week. When I asked what would happen to the garden after she left, she leaned against the fence and shrugged. “It’ll go back to weeds,” she said. “No one else knows all the little stuff that keeps it going.”
She was right, by the end of the following school year, that’s what happened. The garden had been lauded by the district as a model outdoor learning program. The principal put a plaque by the gate. The PTA gave Ms. Lopez a gift card to the local nursery. But no one ever asked her to write down what she actually did every month. She kept the volunteer list in her phone, negotiated discounted lumber with the hardware store owner down the street, remembered which plots got too much shade to grow tomatoes, and emailed parent volunteers reminders every single Wednesday. When she left, all that went with her. The PTA didn’t have a line item for soil in the budget. No one stepped up to coordinate volunteers every week. By June, the fence was leaning, the tomato cages were rusted, and the hand-painted sign that said “Grow What You Give” was propped against the tool shed, out of the rain.
I thought about Ms. Lopez’s garden a few months later, when the district cut the “check-in slip” mental health program at my older son’s middle school. The program had been started by a counselor named Mia who’d gotten a three-year grant to launch it. The idea was simple: kids who were having a hard day could leave an anonymous slip for a counselor, who’d check in with them within 24 hours. It was wildly popular—my son had used it once when he failed a math test and wasn’t ready to talk to me about it yet. Then Mia took a job closer to her kids’ high school, the grant ran out, and the district cut the entire program. Most of us parents assumed that was that.
Last semester I chaperoned a field trip for my son’s 10th grade class, and I overheard a freshman ask his teacher where to leave a check-in slip. The teacher didn’t miss a beat. She nodded to a blue fabric folder taped to the side of her desk. “Leave it there, I send all slips over to the counseling office every afternoon,” she said. No one gets a stipend for this. No one reports on it to the district for grant requirements. It’s not a branded program anymore. It’s just something the teachers got used to doing, so they kept doing it. That’s when I realized what school culture actually keeps, and what it loses.
We tend to get upset when a good program vanishes with the person who built it, and for good reason. But it’s rarely because the school doesn’t care. Most of the time, it’s because we build the wrong things to last. We build the big, formal program with a name and a plaque and a grant report, but we leave all the small, messy, working parts in the founder’s head. What actually survives, though, isn’t the formal program. It’s the small habits that seep into how everyone does their job. The two minutes of quiet at the start of class that started as part of a social emotional program that’s now gone. The habit of letting kids leave a note when they don’t want to talk out loud. The memory of growing tomatoes and giving them away that sticks with kids long after the plot is overgrown.
If you’re a parent or a teacher who wants to keep the good stuff going when someone leaves, there are small concrete things you can do, no big committee or budget required. If you love a program that’s run by one person, ask the leader to jot down three non-negotiable things that make it work—just three bullet points on an email. For the garden, that would be “weekly 30-minute volunteer clean up on Wednesdays, $200 a year for seeds and soil, student roster for watering over breaks.” Send that email to the PTA and one school admin, and ask them to add it to the school’s shared public drive, not just stored on someone’s personal computer. Once a year, the PTA can just spend two minutes at a board meeting checking that the document is still there and the budget line is still in place. That’s it. You don’t need a 50-page operations manual.
Last month, I walked past the garden at the elementary school and saw three fifth graders pulling weeds in one corner. They’d been in the garden when they were in second grade, they told me, and they wanted to grow sunflowers to put by the front entrance for graduation. Their teacher helped them apply for a small PTA mini-grant for seeds and stakes. It’s not the whole eight-plot community garden Ms. Lopez built. It’s just one small corner of sunflowers.
No one knows if it’ll turn into the full program again next year. No one knows if someone will step up to expand it. But that’s okay. The parts that matter didn’t vanish when Ms. Lopez retired. They just waited, small, for someone to want them again.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Good School Programs Vanish When Their Founder Leaves (And What Actually Stays)