Should Students Keep Phones in Their Bags Or Lockers? A Middle School Teacher Explains What Works
The hallway smelled like buttered popcorn from the 7th grade home ec bake sale when Lila stopped me by the classroom door yesterday, eyes shiny. She’d gotten a referral that morning for having her phone in her backpack, and the office had held it until the final bell. Her mom was supposed to text her an update on her little brother’s peanut allergy reaction — he’d been sent home from elementary school that morning, and Lila was supposed to go to a neighbor’s house instead of their empty house after school. No text got through, and she’d spent the whole day panicking that her brother was in the ER and no one could tell her.
Our district flipped its phone policy this fall, after two years of mandatory locker storage for all student phones. Before the first bell, every kid had to drop their phone in a locked homeroom bin or their assigned locker, and couldn’t get it back until after the final bell. Parents pushed back hard enough that the school board changed it: now, the rule was phones off, stored in backpacks for the whole day, out of sight. But after three kids were caught scrolling through answer keys during state testing last week, the debate started back up: should we go back to mandatory lockers, or let kids keep turned-off phones in their bags?
I was grabbing a diet soda after Lila left when Mrs. Henderson, the 8th grade math teacher who’s been here 22 years, leaned against the counter next to me. “Told you this would happen,” she said. “If it’s in the building, it shouldn’t be within reach. Out of sight, out of mind. I had a kid cheat on his algebra midterm last month with a phone in his hoodie pocket. Why are we bending over backwards for this?” She’s not wrong. I’ve pulled three phones out during quizzes this month already, kids scrolling TikTok instead of working on their short responses.
I get both sides, though, because I’m also a parent of a 10th grader at the high school three blocks over, where they still mandate all phones go to lockers at the start of the day. Last March, my son’s after-school ride got in a minor fender bender on the way to school, and couldn’t get ahold of him to tell him he’d be an hour late. My son sat outside the locked building for 45 minutes, cold, because he couldn’t call me to come get him early. I still get annoyed thinking about it. That’s the thing no one talks about as much as cheating: kids have actual, real needs that require them to be reachable sometimes. Family medical stuff, changing custody pickups, last-minute ride changes, mental health emergencies that need a quick check-in with a parent.
Our 7th grade team got together after school last month, after the testing incident and before Lila’s scare, to talk about what we could change instead of jumping all the way back to mandatory lockers. We landed on a few small, concrete changes that have worked way better than I expected. First, we posted clear expectations in every classroom: phones turned completely off, not just vibrate, buried at the bottom of your backpack, out of reach for the whole class period. If you need to have it on vibrate for a specific reason — a sick parent, a college admissions call, a scheduled medical appointment update — you just tell me before class starts, quietly, no announcement to the whole class, and that’s fine. No questions asked, no penalty.
Second, we put a plain fabric bin on the front counter of every classroom, labeled “Phone Drop Off — No Questions Asked.” Any kid who wants to put their phone there for the day, to avoid temptation, can do it. No one has to know why they’re doing it, no shame attached. Kids who struggle with impulse control can choose to opt out of having it in their bag without drawing attention to themselves. Third, consequences are progressive, not automatic. First offense: phone stays on my desk until the end of the period. Second: I hold it until the end of the day. Third offense, it goes to your locker for the rest of the quarter, and you get it back after school each day.
It’s been four weeks since we started this, and we’ve gone from an average of three phone violations a day across the grade to less than one a week. I’ve had half a dozen kids tell me they use the bin every day, because they know they’ll get tempted to check it if it’s in their bag. One kid with ADHD told me it takes the pressure off his mom to remind him to leave it at home, because he can just drop it up front and not worry about it. Last week, a mom emailed me to say her daughter has panic disorder, and knowing her phone is in her bag if she needs to step out and call her therapist during an attack makes it possible for her to stay at school instead of going home early. I still catch a kid scrolling every once in a while, but it’s way less than it was, and the big emergency situations that used to pop up with mandatory locker storage don’t happen anymore.
Last night, I got a text from Lila’s mom thanking me for talking through the policy change with the office. Earlier that week, she’d had to text Lila that their dog needed an emergency vet visit after school, and Lila got the message between classes, no problem. The school board is still talking about a district-wide mandatory locker policy for next year, and there are a lot of good arguments for it — less distraction, less cheating, less cyberbullying happening during the school day. I get it. What works for our 7th grade team might not work for a high school with 1,200 kids, or for teachers who don’t have the bandwidth to check in with kids about individual needs. There’s no perfect answer here. Right now, though, this middle ground is working for us. We’re still tweaking it, still listening to what kids and parents need, and that’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Should Students Keep Phones in Their Bags Or Lockers