When Your Kid Asks “What Do I Need To Do Before I Get Kicked Out”: Teacher Tips For Behavior And Anxiety
I was mid-lesson on cell organelles last month, eraser dust dusting the front ledge of my whiteboard, half my 7th graders doodling in the margins of their notebooks, when Javi shot his hand straight up. He wasn’t half-slouching, shy about it like most kids when they don’t know the answer. He leaned forward, elbow on his desk, and waited. I called his name, and he asked, clear as day, “Ms. Lopez, what do I need to do before I get kicked out of class?”
The room went quiet. A couple kids snickered. I froze for a second, because I knew Javi’s file by heart: three referrals in the first month of school, a note from his counselor that he’s dyslexic and struggles with unmanaged ADHD, a conference with his mom three weeks prior where she cried and said he’d rather get in trouble than admit he can’t read the grade-level textbook. I’d already given him two warnings that period: one for tapping his pencil so hard it shook the kid’s desk next to him, one for yelling to the soccer team across the field through the open window. I was two seconds from writing a third, and he’d called me out on it.
I told the class to keep working on their guided questions, and said Javi and I would talk after the bell. He slouched back in his chair, and the class moved on, but I couldn’t stop thinking about the question the rest of the period. It wasn’t a threat. It wasn’t a joke, even if the other kids took it that way. It was a real question.
When the bell rang, kids poured out, leaving crumpled granola bar wrappers and a single neon sock by the door. Javi lingered, shoving both hands deep in the pocket of his gray hoodie, waiting. I leaned against the counter by the door and asked him what he really wanted to know. He kicked a loose tile with his sneaker and said, “Mr. Henderson kicked me out of science last semester, and I didn’t know I was supposed to bring my homework. I got in extra trouble because I didn’t have it. I got two warnings today already. I just want to know what to grab if it happens.”
Turns out, he’d been thinking about this all period. He wasn’t planning to misbehave on purpose—he just knew some days his brain wouldn’t settle down, and he’d end up breaking a rule before he could stop himself. He was planning for the worst case scenario, because no one had ever told him what that scenario actually looked like.
I pulled a neon pink sticky note off my pad and grabbed a Sharpie. I wrote down step by step, just like he asked: 1. Grab your chromebook and the worksheet we’re working on. 2. Leave your backpack and extra jacket here, I’ll keep it safe for you. 3. Walk straight to the front office, check in with Ms. Rosa, tell her you’re from my class. 4. They’ll have a seat for you to finish your work, and you can come back first thing tomorrow. I signed my name at the bottom and handed it to him. He folded it small and stuffed it in the zipper pocket of his notebook, and said thanks.
I talked to his mom a week later at our monthly check-in, and she told me he’d asked her the exact same question two nights before, over spaghetti dinner. She’d brushed him off, told him “if you stop breaking rules you won’t get kicked out,” and dropped it. She had no idea he was waking up an hour early some days, panicking that he’d mess up that day and have no clue what to do next.
That’s the thing no one tells you about working with kids who act out: half the time, the bad behavior isn’t about breaking rules. It’s about the fear of what happens when you break the rules, when no one’s ever explained it to you. Most of us, as teachers or parents, jump straight to “don’t break the rules” when a kid asks this question, but that doesn’t answer what they’re actually asking. They don’t want a lecture on being good. They want a clear, step-by-step plan for when they can’t be good, which takes all the messy, unknown chaos out of the consequence.
After Javi, I started keeping a stack of pre-written sticky notes by my desk, just in case. Three other kids have asked me the same question in the last month, and I just hand one over, fill in the blanks for their specific situation, and move on. For parents, if your kid asks this at home, the first step isn’t to call the teacher and yell about how your kid is being targeted, or to ground your kid for even thinking about getting kicked out. It’s to sit down and ask them what they’re scared of, then help them map out exactly what will happen. Then you can call the teacher and talk about why they’re getting so many warnings in the first place.
If your kid already has a consistent number of warnings before removal, write that down too. Javi knows three warnings equals a trip to the office, so we added that to his sticky note too, so he can track it himself. It gives him a tiny bit of control when he feels like his brain is spinning out of it.
Last week, Javi got that third warning. He’d gotten up four times to sharpen his pencil, and I called it. He didn’t slam his desk, he didn’t yell, he didn’t storm out like he did the last time. He just pulled his sticky note out of his notebook, checked it, grabbed his chromebook and worksheet, and walked out quietly. He came back the next day, turned in his finished work, and we moved on. No extra referral, no fight, no suspension.
He still gets more warnings than most kids. He still forgets his homework half the time, and he still teases the kid next to him when he’s bored. We’re still working on helping him ask for a five-minute break when he needs one instead of breaking rules to get out of the room. It’s not a perfect fix, and it doesn’t solve all the problems that lead him to that third warning. But it took the scary unknown out of the thing he was most worried about, and that’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Kid Asks “What Do I Need To Do Before I Get Kicked Out”: Teacher Tips For Behavior And Anxiety