When Your Child Is Left Out of Playdates: Practical Tips From a Mom and Former Teacher
The hand dryer in the art studio bathroom was still blowing warm air on my sleeves when I pulled out my phone to check the time, and saw the post pop up. Four second-grade girls, matching glitter face paint from the birthday party down the street, holding waffle cones drizzled with pink sprinkles, all grinning at the camera. It was the playdate I’d never heard about. Mia was standing right next to me, twisting the elastic on her new blue friendship bracelet, and I froze for half a second before I went to slide my phone back in my pocket. She peeked anyway.
“Who are those girls?” she asked, leaning closer. I didn’t lie. “That’s Lila, Zoe, and Ava, getting ice cream.” She blinked, then kicked a loose piece of gravel by my feet. “I thought Lila said she’d ask me when they did stuff. She told me last week.”
I wanted to jump straight into fixing it. I wanted to pull up Lila’s mom’s contact right there, type a passive-aggressive text, then run home and plan a bigger, better playdate for Mia to prove she was loved. But I caught myself. A year earlier, when Mia was left out of a kindergarten classmate’s birthday party, I’d brushed it off, told her “it was just a small family party, no big deal” and she’d gone straight to her room and didn’t talk to me for three hours. I learned then that minimizing the hurt doesn’t make it go away—it just makes them not want to come to you next time.
Instead, I sat down on the curb next to her and said, “That hurts so much, doesn’t it? You thought you were included, and this makes you feel left out. That sucks.” She nodded, and her eyes got teary, and she leaned into my side. No yelling, no dramatic sobbing, just a 7-year-old standing in a parking lot feeling crummy. That’s all it was, most of the time.
We drove home in silence, Mia curled up with her stuffed rabbit in the backseat, and I didn’t pull out my phone to send any angry texts. As a former first grade teacher, I’ve seen this play out dozens of times. More often than not, exclusion isn’t some pre-planned mean trick. One mom can only fit three kids in her backseat. Two parents bump into each other at the grocery store and decide to get ice cream on the spur of the moment. A kid only asks their current favorite Lego-obsessed friend because that’s all they can think about that day. It’s messy, it’s thoughtless, it’s almost never personal.
By the time we got home and mixed up a batch of chocolate chip cookie dough, Lila’s mom texted. She apologized over and over, said the run-in at the park was totally unplanned, and invited Mia to a trip to the local bounce park the next weekend with all four girls. I thanked her, didn’t make a big deal out of it, then brought the phone to Mia and told her what she said. Then I gave her three specific options: “Do you want to go to the bounce park? Do you want to ask Lila to come over just us this week instead? Or do you want to skip it and do that pottery painting you’ve been asking me for?” She thought for a minute, twisting her bracelet again, then said she wanted to go to the bounce park, and get ice cream alone with Lila afterward. That was her call, not mine.
The biggest mistake I see parents make is rushing to fix the problem before the kid even has a chance to feel it. If you jump in and text the other mom, or plan a big rival playdate to prove how popular your kid is, you take away their chance to learn that they can sit with uncomfortable feelings, and that they get to choose what happens next.
When it happens over and over, though, it’s okay to step back from the big group. A friend of mine has a 9-year-old son with ADHD who was left out of almost every large group playdate in his class. She spent months pushing for inclusion, forcing him into big groups that left him overstimulated and upset, until she realized he didn’t even want to be there. He’d rather play Minecraft with one quiet friend than run around with five yelling boys. Now she plans one small one-on-one playdate a month with that friend, and he’s happier than he’s ever been. It’s a small shift, but it takes all the pressure off everyone.
I also started making a point, when I plan playdates for Mia, to ask if there’s anyone in her class who hasn’t been invited to much lately. Last month she mentioned the new girl hadn’t been to any playdates since school started, so we invited her over to paint pumpkins. She stayed for three hours and didn’t want to leave. It’s a two-minute text, and it makes a bigger difference than any big speech about kindness.
Last week, another group playdate popped up on my feed that Mia wasn’t invited to. She saw it before I did, while she was looking at a drawing Lila sent her. She just shrugged, passed me the phone, and said “That’s a hiking playdate. I hate hiking, and those boots they make you wear are gross. Let’s go get our own ice cream anyway.”
We went, got waffle cones with pink sprinkles, just like the ones in the original photo, and sat on the park bench watching dogs chase frisbees. It wasn’t a big dramatic moment with a neat ending. Exclusion will keep happening, I think—when she’s a teen, when she’s an adult, people will leave her out of things. I can’t fix that for her. I can’t make everyone invite her everywhere. What I can do is help her learn that the hurt doesn’t last forever, that she gets to choose what makes her happy, and that it’s okay to say it hurts instead of brushing it off. Some days she still goes to her room sad. Most days, we end up with cookies or ice cream, and that’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Child Is Left Out of Playdates: Practical Tips From a Mom and Former Teacher