Acoustic or Electric for a Teenager’s First Guitar: A Parent & Music Teacher’s Practical Guide
Last March, I stood in the back of our town’s tiny local music shop, breathing in the familiar smell of rosin, new wood, and stale lemon Pledge, while my 14-year-old nephew Jake bounced between two walls. On the left, propped up on neat wooden stands, were the shiny new steel-string acoustics my sister, his mom, had her eye on. On the right, hung a rack of scuffed, used electrics, and Jake couldn’t stop staring at a beat-up black Squier Strat with a faded Turnover sticker peeling off its lower bout.
“That one’s cool, but we’re here to get you a starter guitar,” my sister said, nodding toward a $300 Yamaha that came with a free gig bag and tuner. “Everyone starts on acoustic. Builds your finger strength, teaches you proper basics.” Jake shifted his weight, stuffed his hands in his hoodie pockets. “All those acoustics look like they’d hurt my fingers just holding ‘em. All the songs I like are on electric.”
I’ve taught beginner guitar to local teens for eight years, so this conversation isn’t new. I’ve had it with parents every other month, usually when their kid is begging for an electric and the parent is convinced starting on anything else is a waste of money. Two years ago, I had a 13-year-old student named Lila whose dad insisted she start on a full-size steel-string, the same one he learned on in the 90s. After two lessons, she stopped showing up. When I texted her dad to check in, he said she’d complained her fingers hurt too much to practice, and decided she “just wasn’t musical.”
I walked over to the Strat, pulled it off the rack, and handed it to Jake. It was priced at $175, less than half what the Yamaha cost. The shop owner had already adjusted the action – how high the strings sit off the fretboard – a week prior, so it was easy to play. Jake plugged it into a practice amp, twisted the volume knob to just above a murmur, and fumbled through the opening riff of one of his favorite songs. He got three bars in, missed one note, and his face lit up. It wasn’t perfect, there were a couple of muffled frets, but it sounded like the song he’d been looping on his phone every day for a month.
My sister crossed her arms. “He’s just gonna mess around with distortion and never learn actual chords. What’s the point of that?”
I get where that concern comes from. The old rule that you have to start on acoustic to build good fundamentals has been around forever, but it doesn’t hold up for most teens. The biggest barrier to a teen sticking with guitar isn’t bad habits from electric; it’s quitting before they even get good enough to develop bad habits. Steel-string acoustics have thick strings and usually higher action than electrics, which means you have to press a lot harder to get a clear note. For a new player with soft fingertips, that means every chord sounds muffled, your fingers hurt after five minutes, and you can’t play anything that sounds like the music you actually like. Why would you keep picking it up?
Electric guitars have thinner strings, lower action, and you only need a fraction of the pressure to get a clean sound. Calluses still build, just a little slower. Distortion does hide small mistakes at first, but that’s a feature, not a bug. When you can play a riff that sounds close to your favorite song after a week of practice, you want to practice more. That motivation is worth more than any early “proper” training. I’d rather have a kid play 10 minutes of messy distorted riffs every day than force them to spend an hour a week drilling open chords on a guitar they hate.
If noise is a concern, almost every new electric practice amp has a headphone jack. That means your teen can practice after dinner without driving the rest of the family crazy, and they don’t have to feel self conscious about sounding bad while they learn. Acoustics are loud, whether you sound good or not, and that’s a turn off for a lot of shy teens.
What if you’re still worried about cost? Most local music shops rent instruments for $15 to $25 a month, and most will put your rental payments toward the purchase if your kid sticks with it. That’s way less risky than dropping $400 on a guitar they quit after a month. I always tell parents to do that if they’re on the fence.
We let Jake test both guitars that day, 15 minutes on each. After 15 minutes on the Yamaha, his fingertips were pink, and he’d only gotten through two chords without muting a string. After 15 minutes on the Strat, he’d played through the entire verse of his favorite song, warts and all. My sister agreed to buy the Strat.
It’s been eight months now. Jake practices 20 to 30 minutes almost every day after he finishes his homework. He started a garage band with two kids from his 10th grade math class, and they’re playing their first small show at the local youth center next month. A couple of months back, he asked to borrow my old steel-string to learn a couple of acoustic songs he likes, so now he plays both. His calluses built up just fine, and he knows more open chords now than most of my beginning adult students who started on acoustic.
I don’t tell parents there’s one right answer to this question. If your teen is obsessed with folk music or wants to write their own songs sitting in their bedroom, an acoustic makes perfect sense. The problem only comes when parents pick the guitar they think their kid should have, instead of the one their kid actually wants. The point of a first guitar isn’t to make them the next big musician. It’s to give them a hobby that feels theirs, something they look forward to doing after a long day of school and homework. I don’t know if Jake will stick with guitar forever, or if the band will ever play another show after next month. Right now, though, it’s his thing. That’s more than enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Acoustic or Electric for a Teenager’s First Guitar: A Parent & Music Teacher’s Practical Guide