What It’s Really Like Having the ‘Nice’ Boy: Parenting Tips for Supporting People Pleasing Kids
I was leaning against the vinyl wall of the indoor bounce park refilling my water bottle last weekend when I saw it. My 10-year-old son Jax had been eyeing the last chocolate sprinkled cupcake at his teammate’s birthday party for 20 minutes, even mentioning it on the drive over. Then the birthday boy’s 7-year-old little brother barrelled past, knocked it straight out of Jax’s hand, and grabbed a new one off the tray before Jax could even blink. Jax immediately stepped back, held up his hands, and grinned that easy, familiar grin. “No worries!” he said. “I wasn’t that hungry anyway.”
It’s the compliment everyone leads with when they talk about Jax: he’s such a nice boy. Coach says it after every practice, his teacher writes it in every comment section of his report card, other parents pull me aside at pick up to say they wish their kid was as calm and kind as mine. For the first few years, I ate it up. What parent doesn’t want to hear their kid is well-behaved and easy to love? I didn’t see the weight of that label until we got in the car to leave that bounce park. Jax slumped into his booster seat, kicked the back of my seat once, and didn’t say a word for 10 minutes. When I asked if he was okay, he stared at his scuffed soccer cleats and mumbled, “I really wanted that cupcake.”
It wasn’t the first time this had happened. A month earlier, he’d saved three weeks of allowance to buy a new Lego engineering book at the school book fair. When he got to the display, a boy in his class said he’d been wanting that book first, and Jax just stepped aside and let him take it. He came home, locked his bedroom door, and cried into his pillow because he was too embarrassed to say it was his first pick. He told me later he didn’t want to “start a fight or be mean.”
That’s the hidden side of having the “nice” boy no one talks about. We sort young boys into two tight boxes, don’t we? There’s the loud, disruptive kid that draws all the attention and complaints, and the calm, compliant nice kid that everyone celebrates. The problem is, the nice boy quickly learns his value is tied to how comfortable he makes other people. His own wants and frustrations become an afterthought, because no one asks about them. Why would they? He’s not causing any trouble.
After the book fair incident, I started testing small, simple changes to help him untangle his identity from the “nice boy” label. The first thing I changed was what I praise. I used to say “good job being so nice” all the time, when he shared his toys, when he let someone else go first, when he backed down from a disagreement. Now I don’t praise the niceness itself. I praise honesty when he speaks up for what he needs. If he tells his friend he doesn’t want to play tag right now, I’ll pull him aside later and say “I really liked that you told your friend how you felt. That took courage.” It’s a small shift, but it reinforces that being honest matters more than being universally liked.
I also have a go-to phrase I use now when he says “it’s fine” after something goes wrong, which is 9 times out of 10 not true. I say, “It doesn’t look like it’s fine to me. What are you actually feeling?” It gives him permission to stop pretending, without pushing him to make a big scene in front of other people. Sometimes he still shrugs it off, but more often than not, he’ll end up telling me what’s bugging him once we’re in the car alone.
To build his confidence slowly, we do one “Jax picks” thing every day at home. It can be anything: the side for dinner, the show we watch after homework, which route we take to the bus stop. If he says “I don’t care, whatever you guys want,” I don’t let it go. I say “Everyone else already picked something this week. This turn is yours, just name one thing you want.” It’s such a low-stakes practice, no one gets upset if his pick is different, but it teaches him that his preferences matter enough to share. I even talked to his teacher about this, and she started doing a quick 10-second check-in with him once a week when assigning groups or projects. She just pulls him aside quietly and asks “does this group work for you, or do you want to switch?” She told me he used to never say anything, but last month he told her he’d rather not work with a group that was distracting him, and she switched him without anyone else noticing. That’s the small adjustment teachers can make that takes no extra time, but makes all the difference for quiet nice kids who won’t speak up in front of the class.
After the bounce park, I stopped at the McDonald’s drive through and bought Jax a chocolate cupcake with extra sprinkles. He ate it in the passenger seat while we drove home, and we talked about how it’s okay to want things. It’s okay to be disappointed when you don’t get them, and it’s okay to say that out loud. You don’t have to be nice to everyone all the time to be a good person.
It’s not like this has fixed everything. Just last week, his soccer coach asked who wanted to play forward in the weekend game, the position Jax has been begging to try for months. Another kid yelled it out first, and Jax immediately leaned back and didn’t say a word. After the game, I didn’t lecture him about standing up for himself. We got our usual ice cream, and I just said “Next time, can you just try raising your hand before he yells? That’s all I ask, just try.” He nodded, and ate his sprinkled cone, and that was that. It’s a work in progress. He’s still a nice boy, and that’s a good thing. But now we’re working on making sure he’s nice to himself, too. That part doesn’t get talked about much, but it’s the most important work we’re doing right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What It’s Really Like Having the ‘Nice’ Boy: Parenting Tips for Supporting People Pleasing Kids