What I Learned When I Realized I Was Lied to About My Own Learning Struggles
I was kneeling on my childhood bedroom floor last spring, sorting through a stack of old report cards after my mom moved into a smaller condo, when I found it: the crumpled, yellowed note my third-grade teacher sent home in 1998, the one my mom never mentioned after that parent-teacher conference. “Lila is easily distracted, talks too much, and doesn’t try hard enough to keep up with grade-level work,” it read. The words hit me different than they would have 25 years earlier, because I’d just picked my own 8-year-old son up from his neuropsych evaluation for ADHD that same morning.
I grew up hearing the same line on repeat, from teachers, from relatives, even from my parents: “You’re so smart, you just don’t apply yourself.” I got straight Bs with inconsistent Cs in math, always forgot my lunch or my homework folder, could read an entire 300-page novel in a single rainy Saturday but couldn’t memorize my times tables for the life of me. In high school, I skipped study hall to sit in the parking lot and talk with my friends because sitting still at a desk filling out worksheets felt like physical torture. Everyone just nodded and said I was lazy, that I didn’t care enough about my future. I believed it for 20 years. I beat myself up for dropping out of community college my second year, for quitting three different office jobs because I couldn’t keep up with the daily routine, for always feeling like I was one step behind everyone I knew. I thought I just lacked willpower.
When my son’s first-grade teacher first pulled me aside and suggested he might have inattentive ADHD, I reacted exactly how you’d expect someone raised on that lie to react. I smiled and said “No, he’s just a busy little boy. He’s smart, he just needs to focus harder.” It took six more months of him coming home crying because he got in trouble for forgetting his reading book again, of him sitting at the kitchen table for an hour to do 10 questions of math and only finishing two, before I agreed to the evaluation. When the doctor handed me the report and said his working memory was two full standard deviations below average, that his inattention showed up across every setting from school to home to soccer practice, that this wasn’t a problem of will—it was a difference in how his brain processed tasks, that’s when I went digging through those old boxes at my mom’s. That’s when I realized the whole story of my education had been a lie. The lie was simple: any learning struggle is a failure of effort, not a difference in how your brain works.
The first thing that hit me, that I want other parents to hear, is that if your kid can do complex, sustained work on things they care about but can’t seem to finish school work, that’s not laziness. That’s a red flag that doesn’t get talked about enough. My son can sit for two hours straight building a complicated Lego set, but can’t finish 10 minutes of spelling worksheets. I was exactly the same: I could write 10 pages for a history paper I cared about, but couldn’t get through 20 minutes of algebra homework. A concrete thing I tell people to do is keep a simple two-week log: jot down when your kid struggles, what the task is, and what they can do when they’re interested. It takes 30 seconds a night, and it’s way more useful than taking a teacher’s generic “they don’t try” comment at face value.
I’ve stopped saying “just try harder” completely. Instead, I use small, specific adjustments that don’t cost anything and don’t need the school’s approval to use. When my son does homework, we split it into 10-minute chunks, with a 5-minute break between each chunk to jump on the trampoline or run around the backyard. He keeps a fidget spinner on the table to twist while he reads, which cuts his distraction in half. Instead of yelling at him for forgetting his homework folder, we have a large whiteboard by the front door that we fill out together every night after homework, and he checks it himself every morning before we leave. If he remembers his folder five days in a row, he gets a small pack of stickers or a new loose Lego brick. It’s simple, it’s low-effort for me, and it’s cut our morning fights by 90%.
Last month, he came home with a failed math test because he finished the front page and forgot the back page existed. When I was a kid, my mom would have grounded me and told me I wasn’t paying attention. Instead, we sat down and counted how many questions he got right on the front: all 15. I said “You know this material perfectly. The problem isn’t that you don’t know it, it’s that your brain gets done with the front and stops looking, right?” He nodded and said that’s exactly what happened. Then we practiced one simple trick: after you finish a side, run your finger along the edge of the paper to check if there’s another side. We practiced it three times that night, and he hasn’t made that mistake since.
I still slip up sometimes. Last week, I caught myself saying “can’t you just sit still?” when he was bouncing during homework, and I had to apologize and remind both of us that his brain just needs to move to work. I still have days where I miss a work deadline because I forgot to write it down, and I have to stop myself from calling myself lazy like I did for 30 years. We don’t have everything figured out. My son still gets inconsistent grades, and we’re still waiting on the school to approve his formal accommodations. But he doesn’t come home from school crying that he’s stupid, that he doesn’t try hard enough. That’s enough for right now.
The lie I was told took me three decades to unpack. I can’t go back and change my own education, but I can stop passing that lie on to the next kid. There’s no perfect fix, no big end to this story. We’re just adjusting, one small trick at a time, and that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned When I Realized I Was Lied to About My Own Learning Struggles