What Do I Do If My Child Is Struggling With Math? Real Tips From A Classroom Teacher
Last Tuesday, I was folding clean socks at the kitchen counter when my fourth grader, Leo, slammed his math workbook shut so hard granola crumbs flew off the edge of the table. “I’m never doing math again,” he yelled. “I’m just bad at it. Fractions are stupid anyway.”
I’ve been a fourth grade teacher for 12 years, so I’ve seen this exact meltdown dozens of times from other kids’ desks. But when it’s your own kid sitting across from you, face red, fists clenched, all the lesson plans and strategies fly right out of your head. A couple years ago, I would’ve pulled a chair right next to him, dug out my old fraction manipulatives from my classroom closet, and walked him through every problem step by step. I’d pull up extra practice worksheets, reassure him he wasn’t bad, he just needed to try harder. What that got me was a kid who cried through homework every night and refused to raise his hand in math class even when he knew the answer. We tried a popular after-school tutoring program for two months, and he came home every week red-eyed saying the tutor talked too fast and made him feel stupid for getting answers wrong. We quit, and I started over, with really small, really low-fuss changes.
The first change I made was ditching the label “math” for anything that wasn’t required school homework. Now, when we bake chocolate chip cookies and I need him to halve a ¾ cup of sugar, I don’t say “see, this is a fractions problem! You’re doing math!” I just ask him to measure. When he’s saving up for a new skateboard deck that costs $80 and he gets $12 a week in allowance, I just ask “how many more weeks do you think we need to wait before you can order it?” I don’t call it a word problem. I don’t cheer extra loud when he gets it right. Last month, when we planted tomato plants in the backyard, he wanted five plants, and I just said “hold up, each needs two square feet, our bed is 4 by 3 feet. Is there enough room?” He stood there, counted on his fingers, mumbled to himself for a minute, and said “yeah, 12 total, 10 for the plants, we’ve got extra.” I handed him the trowel and that was it. No big lesson, no fanfare. Math just becomes part of daily life, not something scary you only do at a desk.
For the required homework that causes the meltdowns, I set a hard 15-minute limit. 15 minutes a night, no exceptions. If we hit 15 minutes and he’s still stuck, frustrated, and not getting anywhere, I close the book, write a quick note to his teacher that says we worked for 15 minutes and hit a wall, and we’re done for the night. When I was teaching, I never minded notes like that. I’d rather a kid stop before they start hating math than force them to work through an hour of frustration that doesn’t teach them anything anyway. That one change took almost all the fighting out of our afternoons. Leo knows the timer is going to go off eventually, even if he’s stuck, so he doesn’t feel like he’s trapped at the table forever.
When he does ask for help, I don’t show him a fancy trick or re-explain the rule the teacher just taught. I translate it into something he can touch or see. Last week, he was stuck on a problem that asked how much ⅜ plus 2/8 was, and instead of writing it out on the paper and going on about common denominators, I grabbed a granola bar from the pantry, broke it into eight equal pieces, and pushed three over to one side and two over to the other. “How many pieces is that all together?” I asked. He stared for two seconds and said “five, duh, so ⅝.” He wrote the answer down and went back to his game ten minutes later. That’s way easier than any curriculum hack, and it helps him see what the numbers actually mean, instead of just memorizing steps to forget later.
I also stopped acting like I’m perfect at math. I mess up calculations all the time when we’re out, and I say that out loud. If I’m figuring out the tip at dinner, I’ll say “wait, 20% of $52 is… that’s $10 right? Wait no, that can’t be, let me count again. Ugh, I got that wrong, sorry.” It normalizes getting it wrong. Kids think all adults know all the math answers, so when they get a problem wrong, they think that means they’re bad at it forever. Seeing me mess up and fix it takes away that pressure.
It’s not all fixed. Leo still complains about math homework. He still freezes up sometimes when he gets a pop quiz, and he still comes home with Bs and Cs on tests when he gets too nervous to finish. Last Monday, he cried after getting three long division problems wrong on a quiz, and we skipped homework to get ice cream anyway. But he doesn’t slam his workbook and yell that he’s never doing math again anymore. Last weekend, he figured out how to split the cost of a new skate video with two of his friends, all on his own, without asking me for help.
That’s enough for me. I don’t need him to be an engineer or a math competition winner. I just need him to not be scared to try. Some days it works, some days it doesn’t, and that’s okay. This is just what we do for math right now, and we’ll adjust when we need to.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Do I Do If My Child Is Struggling With Math