Helping A Quiet Struggling Kid In A Chinese Primary School: What Actually Worked
The third grade math classroom smelled like chalk dust and fermented bamboo shoots from someone’s lunch last April, when I first noticed Xiao Ming. He sat in the back row, by the window cracked open to let in the spring humidity, twisting the frayed edge of his faded blue school uniform sleeve. The teacher was calling on kids to answer 15 times 7, and half the class was leaning out of their desks yelling the answer before she even finished asking. When she called Xiao Ming’s name, the room went quiet for half a second. He went red from his ears to his collar, stared at his desk, and didn’t make a sound. I leaned over to see his notebook, and the number 105 was written clear as day in his neat, small handwriting.
The homeroom teacher sighed after class, motioning me away from his desk. “He’s a migrant kid, moved here from a village in Dazhou last year. He’s slow, doesn’t talk, doesn’t cause trouble. Don’t waste your time on him, there’s 47 other kids I have to get through the midterm.” I nodded, but the moment stuck with me. I was volunteering as a teaching assistant that semester, and I’d already noticed how many kids like him slip through the cracks in large, test-focused Chinese classrooms—the quiet ones who never act out, so no one stops to check if they’re keeping up.
I stayed back that day to grade papers, and everyone left except Xiao Ming, who was still sitting at his desk drawing on the back of an old worksheet. I walked over, didn’t mention the math question, just pointed at the page. “That’s a really cool plane. What kind is it?” He tucked the worksheet under his textbook for a minute, then slowly pulled it back out. It was a J-20 fighter jet, all the tiny details of the wings drawn in sharp pencil. “My dad fixes plane parts at Shuangliu Airport,” he mumbled, so quiet I almost couldn’t hear him.
Over the next couple weeks, I learned the whole picture. His parents work six 12-hour days a week, leave the house before he wakes up, get back after 8 PM. He does his homework alone at a cheap after-school program down the street from their apartment. The village school he attended had one teacher covering three grades, so he never learned half the English and math other kids mastered in second grade. When he did try to answer a question once, a few boys laughed at his thick rural accent, and he hasn’t spoken up in front of the whole class since. At parent-teacher conferences, his mom told me she had no idea how far behind he was. “He never says anything is wrong,” she said, wiping her chapped hands on her canvas apron. “We’re so tired when we get home, we just ask if he finished his homework, he says yes, so we leave it.”
That’s the thing I didn’t fully understand before working with Xiao Ming: the biggest barrier for kids like him isn’t always a lack of ability, it’s that everyone assumes no news is good news. We only pay attention to kids who act out or beg for help, and quiet kids who are too embarrassed or overwhelmed to ask get left behind. The good news is you don’t need a lot of extra time or money to make a difference—just small, specific changes that lower pressure.
The first thing I tried was stopping the pressure to speak up publicly. A lot of people think you need to push quiet kids to “come out of their shell” by calling on them in front of the class, but that just makes them shut down harder. Instead, I started leaving a sticky note on his desk every morning before class. It had one quick question about the material we were covering that day, and I told him he didn’t have to say a word out loud—just write the answer down and stick it on my desk when he was done. If he got it right, I’d leave him an airplane sticker (I bought a pack for 5 yuan at the dollar store down the street) on the next day’s note. It took 30 seconds a day, and it let him practice without the stress of everyone looking at him.
For his mom, I suggested one small change to how she talks about school at home. Instead of asking “Do you have any problems with homework?” which almost any kid will answer “no” to (especially a kid who doesn’t want to add more stress to his overworked parents), I told her to ask one specific, low-stakes question every night: “What was one question that was hard for you today?” She started doing that, and after a week, he brought home his math notebook and showed her all the problems he couldn’t figure out. She can’t help him with them herself—she only finished middle school—but she can text me a photo, and I go over them with Xiao Ming for 10 minutes after class once a week.
I also asked him to draw the plane diagrams for our class science bulletin board, playing to the thing he was already good at instead of only focusing on the things he struggled with. He didn’t have to present it or anything, just draw during art class. A few kids came over to look while he worked, and he ended up telling them all about different plane parts, quiet but steady. He wasn’t scared because he was talking about something he knew, not a math question he might get wrong.
It’s been six months since I left that school. Xiao Ming still doesn’t raise his hand in whole class. He still twists the edge of his sleeve when a teacher walks by his desk. But his math score went from a 52 on the midterm to a 68 on the final, and he passed his first English unit test ever last month. His mom texted me a photo of the test, with Xiao Ming peeking over her shoulder half-smiling in the background. There’s still a lot that’s uncertain: his parents can’t afford private tutoring, the class is still too big for the homeroom teacher to check in with him every day. But it’s moving forward, slow. You don’t have to fix a kid like Xiao Ming overnight. Most of the time, small, consistent low-pressure steps are enough to start.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Helping A Quiet Struggling Kid In A Chinese Primary School: What Actually Worked