What To Do When Other Parents Say Your Daughter Plays With The Wrong Kid
I’m leaning against the sun-warmed brick wall of the elementary school exit, stirring a half-melted iced coffee that’s already too watery, when Sarah from the PTA sidles over. She lowers her voice, like she’s sharing a secret that will save me from disaster: “I heard your Lila’s been playing with Mia Carter at recess. I just thought I should let you know – Mia got sent to the office last week for pushing a first grader, and from what I hear, her home life is… messy. I wouldn’t let my Emma play with her, if it were me.”
Before I can answer, Lila comes around the corner, holding Mia’s hand. Both of their jeans are smudged with grass, glitter glued to their cheekbones from morning art class. Lila’s wearing a lopsided paper necklace Mia folded for her, Mia’s clutching a crayon drawing Lila made of her rescue chihuahua. Lila skids to a stop in front of me: “Mom, can Mia come over Saturday? We’re building a fairy house in the backyard and we need extra sticks.” Mia peeks around Lila’s shoulder, half-smiling, like she already expects me to say no. I wave to Mia’s grandma, who’s waiting by their old minivan three spots down, and she waves back, tired but grateful. I tell the girls yes, of course.
I’d heard versions of this warning about Mia before, in the year my second grader has known her. She doesn’t live with her parents – her mom struggled with addiction, her dad left a couple years ago, so it’s just her and her grandma on a fixed income. She’s been written off by most of the other parents in the class: she’s too loud, she hits when she’s mad, she’s a bad influence. I’ll admit, the first time Lila mentioned her, I felt that little twinge of worry too. What if she teaches Lila bad words? What if she gets her hurt?
I decided not to ban the friendship before I met her. I made a small, simple rule for myself: if Lila wants to play with Mia, we host the playdates at our house. That way I can see how they interact, step in if things get out of hand, and it’s no extra stress for Mia’s grandma, who can’t drive far anyway. That’s the first thing I’d tell any parent in this spot: don’t rely on other people’s stories to judge a kid. Invite them over, see for yourself.
What I saw in those first few playdates wasn’t a bad kid. Mia can climb the old oak in our backyard faster than any kid I’ve ever seen. She taught Lila how to do a standing cartwheel, something I couldn’t teach her after a dozen clumsy tries. She never asks for anything, but she lights up when I put out chocolate chip cookies, because her grandma doesn’t bake much. Once Lila tripped over the garden hose and scraped her knee bad, and Mia had her inside with a band-aid and a lollipop before I even heard her cry.
Yeah, she gets frustrated faster than most 8-year-olds. Once, when they were playing board games, Lila won and Mia flipped the board over and yelled that it was stupid. I didn’t kick her out, I didn’t pull Lila aside and say “See what I warned you about?” I just walked over, picked up the scattered cards, and said “That hurt Lila’s feelings when you flipped the board. I know you were mad you lost, but name calling and breaking things isn’t okay. Let’s try again, or we can pick something else to do.” Mia sat quiet on the couch for five minutes, picking at her nail polish, then went over and mumbled an apology to Lila. After that, she was extra careful the next playdate, checking in with Lila when they disagreed on rules. I don’t think a lot of people talk to her that way – calm, not immediately angry or ready to send her away.
Most parents buy into this idea that one “difficult” kid will ruin your well-behaved kid, but I’ve found the opposite is true. The second thing I learned is to ask your kid what they like about their friend, instead of jumping to judgment. When I asked Lila why she liked playing with Mia so much, she said “All the other girls only let me be the evil fairy. Mia lets me be the fairy queen whenever I want. She doesn’t care if I get mud on my dress.” That told me more about their friendship than any warning from another parent ever could.
Boundaries don’t have to mean banning the friendship, either. That’s the practical part I’ve figured out. If Mia says something that hurts Lila, I don’t brush it off. I sit with both of them and talk about how words hurt, and what you can say instead when you’re mad. When Mia said a cuss word she’d learned from her mom’s old boyfriend at our house last month, I didn’t throw a fit or send her home. I just said “That’s a word people use when they’re really upset, but it’s not polite to say, so we don’t use it in our house, okay?” She nodded, and hasn’t said it since. I tell Lila all the time, if she ever doesn’t want to play with Mia anymore, or if Mia does something that makes her uncomfortable, she can come tell me, and we’ll figure it out together. No guilt, no pressure.
I still get the side eye from other parents at pick up, when Lila runs to meet Mia instead of the group of popular girls. I still wonder sometimes if I’m doing the right thing. Some weeks they fight and Lila plays with other girls for a few days, that’s just how kid friendships work. It’s not perfect. I don’t know how it’ll be a year from now, when they get older and friendships get more complicated. But I know that banning Lila from being friends with Mia wouldn’t teach her anything good. It would teach her that you only hang out with people who fit what other people think is perfect, that you turn your back on people who need a friend. Right now, what’s working is just keeping the door open, having the small hard conversations when they come up, and letting kids be kids. Mia’s not a bad kid. She’s just a kid who’s had a harder start than most. And my daughter gets to learn that people aren’t just what other people say they are. That seems like a pretty good lesson to me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When Other Parents Say Your Daughter Plays With The Wrong Kid