How to Set Boundaries With My Spoiled Niece: Practical Tips for Aunts and Uncles
It was 86 degrees in mid-August, my iced oat coffee was sweating through the cup onto my hand, and I had a work call scheduled in 18 minutes when 10-year-old Lila sat down hard on the Disney store floor and started yelling. I’d promised her a pack of glitter gel pens for back-to-school, $8, that was our agreement when my sister asked me to watch her for an hour while she ran a work errand. Then she spotted the 3-foot light-up sloth priced at $45, and all bets were off. “You’re the worst aunt ever,” she screamed, kicking my shoe. “You never get me anything.”
I’d been here a hundred times before. Lila is my sister’s only kid, and my sister works 60-hour weeks as a nurse, feels constant guilt for the time she misses, and almost never says no to Lila to avoid making her upset. For years, I’d been the fun aunt who went along with it. I’d caved on the $60 gaming accessory for Christmas, I’d let her eat all my fancy dark chocolate I’d bought for a date when she came over, I’d rearrange my entire work schedule to take her to the arcade when she begged. I didn’t want to rock the boat with my sister, I didn’t want Lila to think I didn’t love her, so I just gave in, then went home and resented the whole thing. That day in the Disney store, though, I was tired. I’d pulled a late shift finishing a project, my coffee was gone, and I just didn’t have it in me to cave.
I knelt down to her level, voice quiet, so the other shoppers staring would calm down. “I know that sloth is really cool, and I get why you want it,” I said. “We agreed today I was buying you gel pens, and that’s all I budgeted for. If you still want it next week, you can use your birthday money you’ve been saving, and I’ll help you order it for cheaper online. Let’s go pay for the pens, okay.” She kept yelling, so I grabbed the pens we’d picked out, paid, and walked out to the car. I leaned against the door and waited. Two minutes later, she stomped out after me, pouting so hard her cheeks turned pink, and climbed in the backseat.
That night, I called my sister to talk about it. I didn’t lead with “you’re spoiling your kid” — I knew that would just make her defensive. I said, “I love having Lila over, I love spending time with her, but I need to set clear rules for when she’s with me. I’m not telling you how to parent your house, this is just what works for mine and my budget.” She was quiet for a minute, then admitted she knew Lila was used to getting everything she wanted, and she was okay with me setting my own lines, as long as I wasn’t mean about it.
That was four months ago, and I’ve learned a few things that work, that don’t require big fights or ruining your relationship with your sister or the kid. First, I lay out all the rules the second Lila walks in the door, not when she’s already broken one. I keep it simple, no long lectures: “No going into my desk or bathroom makeup drawers without asking, all trash goes in the can, when I’m on a work call you have to play quietly until I’m done, and we don’t take things that aren’t ours without asking.” Second, I set the budget before we leave the house. I don’t say “we’ll see” if she asks what we’re getting — I say, “Today we’re getting lunch and one small thing under $10, that’s it.” No room for wishful thinking that leads to begging.
Third, I don’t negotiate once I’ve said no. Repeating the same explanation over and over just gives her attention for bad behavior, and she learns that if she yells long enough, you’ll give in. I say it once, and then I just wait. If we’re out and she can’t calm down, we leave. Fourth, I follow through with small, natural consequences, no big scary punishments. When she went into my bathroom last month and used my $20 fancy lip gloss to draw on her arm, I said, “I told you my makeup isn’t for you to use. Now it’s all gone, so I’m taking $20 from your allowance to replace it.” She cried and said it was unfair, but I didn’t back down.
A lot of people say aunts and uncles shouldn’t discipline their niblings, that it’s not your place. But this isn’t discipline for discipline’s sake. It’s respecting my own time, my budget, and my stuff, and that actually helps Lila, too. She’s used to people giving in to her to avoid conflict, so she never learns that other people have limits. I still do nice things for her — we bake chocolate chip cookies every Saturday she’s over, I save up for a big birthday gift every year, I listen to her rant about her mean math teacher for 20 minutes straight. Boundaries don’t mean I don’t love her. They mean I can show up for her consistently, instead of giving in and resenting it later.
It’s not perfect. Sometimes I cave when I’m tired and just want 10 minutes of quiet. Sometimes my sister buys her the thing I said no to, to avoid drama at her house, and that’s okay — that’s her choice. Last week, Lila asked to borrow my hoodie before she went outside, and she cleaned up her cookie crumbs off the couch without me asking. That’s small progress, but it’s progress. I don’t need her to be a perfect kid, and I don’t need to be a perfect aunt. I just need boundaries that work for me, and so far, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Set Boundaries With My Spoiled Niece: Practical Tips for Aunts and Uncles