1 vs. 2 Bedrooms for a Family of 3: What We Learned Testing Both Options
Last Wednesday I stood in our hallway at 7:15 a.m., holding a half-full sippy cup and listening to my 5-year-old scream through her closed bedroom door that she “didn’t want the dark to eat her socks”. Two years ago, this moment would have been impossible. Back then, we lived in a one-bedroom apartment, and every sock, every midnight scare, every 6 a.m. wakeup call happened within 15 feet of our bed.
When we moved to our current city for my husband’s job, we had two options in our strict budget. The first was a 750 square foot one-bedroom with a big open living room that got sun all afternoon. The second was a 620 square foot two-bedroom, where the second “kid bedroom” was barely big enough to fit a twin bed and a 2-drawer dresser, and it didn’t have a window that opened. Half the parents we asked said we’d be stupid to not give our daughter her own room—independence starts early, they said. The other half said we’d regret giving up our only shared space, that we’d never have two minutes to ourselves as a couple. We flipped a coin, basically, and picked the one-bedroom first, figuring we could swap if a bigger two-bedroom opened up in our building. Eighteen months later, it did, and we moved. So we’ve lived both sides of the debate, and I can tell you there’s no one right answer.
Our set-up in the one-bedroom wasn’t fancy. We got a $40 fabric room divider from Target, pushed it into the corner by the sliding glass door, and called that Lila’s. We hung her art on the divider, put her crib against the wall, and stacked all her toys in a cubby shelf that was only for her. When she was 3, it worked fine. She never had trouble falling asleep, because she could see the light from our phone screens if she woke up scared. But I started noticing small things as she turned 4. She never played alone. If I wanted to read a book on the couch, she’d drag every single doll and puzzle over to my feet. If I got up to make coffee, she’d abandon whatever she was doing to follow me. She never got to practice being in her own space on her own terms, because there was no space that was just hers. We couldn’t even close a door to give her that privacy. Date night after she went to bed meant me and my husband sitting on the balcony in 40-degree weather, drinking cheap wine and whispering so we didn’t wake her.
When we moved last June, I thought we’d hit the parenting jackpot. Instead, Lila refused to sleep in the room for the first month. She’d scream until we dragged her mattress back to our floor, and we all slept squished together for weeks. I started thinking we’d made a huge mistake, that we’d given up all that living room space for nothing. Slowly, though, things shifted. One Saturday I was cleaning the kitchen, and I realized it had been 20 minutes since I’d heard from her. I peeked down the hall, and her door was closed. I knocked, and she yelled “come in!” She’d pulled all her stuffed animals into a circle around her and was playing school, completely absorbed. That had never happened before.
I started connecting the dots after that. All that talk about kids needing their own space to grow into independence isn’t just empty advice. But it also doesn’t have to be a whole room. When we were in the one-bedroom, I made the mistake of not treating her nook like the real thing. I’d move her toys around to make space for guests, I’d step into her corner to get to the balcony without knocking. Once I realized that, I started trying small changes, even before we moved. I started knocking on the side of the divider before stepping into her space, I bought a cheap kid-sized lock for the cubby so she could “lock” her stuff away from us if she wanted. Those small things gave her the same sense of ownership that a separate door does. That’s the thing no one tells you when you’re debating this choice: the actual walls are less important than the fact that the space is clearly, exclusively the kid’s.
If you’re currently trying to decide between 1 and 2 bedrooms for your family of three, here’s the concrete stuff I’d tell you, not the vague “follow your heart” nonsense. If your kid is under 4, you don’t need a separate room. Just pick a corner, get a cheap divider, label it as theirs, and respect their boundaries there. That’s enough to meet their needs right now. If your kid is 4 or older, and they’re starting to ask for privacy or refuse to play alone, try carving that small defined space first before you shell out more money for an extra bedroom. If that works, great. If it doesn’t, then you can think about moving. For us, once Lila hit 5, the extra bedroom did make sense. She gets to practice closing the door when she changes, she gets to have 20 minutes of alone play every morning that I never got when we shared the whole space.
But it’s not all perfect. Our living room is so small we can’t fit a proper dining table, so we eat every meal on the coffee table. Last week we had my parents over, and three of us had to sit on the floor. Lila still crawls into our bed at 3 a.m. at least twice a week, and I have to fumble down the dark hallway to put her back if I want any space. I still think sometimes about that big sunny living room we had in the one-bedroom, and how nice it was to spread out when we had friends over.
After Lila finished screaming about the dark eating her sock, I pushed her bedroom door open an inch. She was standing on her mattress, one bare foot on the comforter, pointing at the gap under the dresser where her sock had fallen. “I just need you to watch me get it,” she said. I leaned against the doorframe, and she stretched, wiggled, and fished it out herself, then pulled it on over her ankle. “Okay, you can go now,” she said, and pulled the door almost closed behind me. It’s not the perfect set-up, and I don’t know if it’s the right one for every family. But right now, for us, that half-closed door is enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » 1 vs