Why Some Online Communities Say: “To Post, Your Account Must Be Older Than 10 Days and Have 100 Positive Karma”
Ever excitedly crafted the perfect comment or post for an online community, only to hit “submit” and be met with a frustrating message? Something like: “In order to post, your account must be older than 10 days and have 100 positive karma.” If you’re new to platforms like Reddit or similar forums, this can feel like hitting a brick wall. What does it mean? Why does it exist? And, crucially, how do you get past it? Let’s break it down.
The “Why” Behind the Wall: Fighting Spam and Building Trust
Think of a vibrant online community like a bustling neighborhood. It thrives on genuine interaction, shared interests, and mutual respect. But just like a real neighborhood, it attracts unwanted guests: spammers, scammers, trolls, and bots. These entities can flood the community with low-quality posts, malicious links, fake reviews, harassment, and irrelevant ads, quickly degrading the experience for everyone else.
This is where the account age requirement (like 10 days) and the karma threshold (like 100 positive karma) come into play. They act as a sophisticated “front gate” system:
1. Slowing Down Bad Actors: Spammers and trolls want instant results. Requiring them to wait 10 days significantly disrupts their automated processes. They can’t just create hundreds of accounts and start blasting immediately. It forces them to invest time, making their “business” model less profitable and efficient. Bots are often detected and banned before they even reach the 10-day mark.
2. Proving Good Faith Participation: Karma is essentially community feedback. Upvotes (positive karma) signal that other users found your contribution valuable, relevant, or helpful. Downvotes (negative karma) signal the opposite. Requiring 100 positive karma means you’ve demonstrated, through actions seen by others, that you’re likely here to contribute constructively. It’s not just about having karma; it’s about having karma earned through positive engagement.
3. Encouraging Observation: That initial 10-day period isn’t just passive waiting. It’s an opportunity (and expectation) for new users to lurk. Read the rules, understand the community culture, see what kind of posts are appreciated, and learn the nuances before jumping in. This helps prevent well-meaning newbies from accidentally violating norms simply out of unfamiliarity.
4. Protecting Established Discussions: Some communities, especially those discussing sensitive topics, controversial issues, or specialized knowledge (like programming or medical advice), need extra protection. High-value discussions can be easily derailed or poisoned by new accounts with malicious intent. These barriers help maintain signal over noise.
Karma Demystified: What Exactly is “Positive Karma”?
Karma is a reputation score, primarily used on platforms like Reddit. Here’s the simple breakdown:
Upvote (⬆️): When someone likes your post or comment, finds it helpful, or agrees with it, they can upvote it. This increases your karma.
Downvote (⬇️): If someone finds your post irrelevant, offensive, incorrect, or against the community rules, they might downvote it. This decreases your karma.
Positive Karma: This specifically refers to your net karma earned primarily through upvotes. The requirement focuses on this positive contribution. It’s not enough to just have an account; you need to have contributed things the community found valuable enough to upvote. Having 100 karma doesn’t mean 100 upvotes on one post; it’s the cumulative total from your positive contributions.
Beyond Reddit: A Widespread Practice
While Reddit popularized the specific combination of “account age + karma,” the underlying principles are used widely across the web:
Forums: Many forums require a minimum number of posts (or “thanks”) before accessing certain sections or features like private messaging.
Q&A Sites (e.g., Stack Overflow): Require minimum reputation to ask questions, answer questions, comment, or vote. Reputation is earned through helpful answers and questions getting upvoted.
Marketplaces & Review Sites: Often require verified purchases or account age to leave reviews, preventing fake or retaliatory feedback.
Comment Sections: Some news sites or blogs require social media login or minimal interaction before commenting.
How to Legitimately Earn Your Posting Privileges (Without Cheating!)
Seeing that barrier might tempt you to look for shortcuts. Resist! Buying accounts, karma farming in low-quality subs, or using bots almost always leads to bans. Instead, focus on authentic participation:
1. Find Your Niche: Start in smaller, more niche communities (subreddits) related to your genuine interests. These often have more welcoming atmospheres and lower interaction thresholds. Look for “ask” subreddits (like r/AskReddit, r/NoStupidQuestions) or hobby-focused ones.
2. Be a Helper: Scan the “New” queue in your chosen communities. Can you answer someone’s question helpfully? Do you have a relevant link or resource? Providing genuine assistance is one of the fastest ways to earn upvotes.
3. Engage Thoughtfully in Comments: Instead of diving straight into making posts, participate in existing discussions. Add insightful comments, ask clarifying questions, or share relevant personal experiences (where appropriate). Quality comments often earn significant karma.
4. Understand the Rules & Culture: Before you post or comment, READ the subreddit’s rules (usually found in the sidebar or “About” section). What’s considered on-topic? What are common pitfalls? Mimic the tone of successful posts.
5. Contribute Quality Content (When Possible): If you find something truly interesting, funny, or informative that aligns perfectly with a subreddit, share it! Ensure it hasn’t been posted recently (use the search!). Original content (OC) is especially valued.
6. Be Patient and Genuine: Focus on being part of the community, not just hitting a number. The karma will naturally follow constructive engagement over the 10 days (and beyond). Authenticity resonates.
The Flipside: Community Responsibility
While these barriers are necessary, communities also have a responsibility:
Clear Communication: The rules and requirements must be easily accessible and unambiguous.
Fair Moderation: Moderators should enforce rules consistently and transparently.
Welcoming Core Members: Established users can help by guiding new members constructively when they make mistakes instead of just downvoting.
Conclusion: More Than Just a Barrier
That message – “In order to post, your account must be older than 10 days and have 100 positive karma” – might seem like an annoying obstacle when you first encounter it. But it represents a community’s effort to protect its integrity and foster quality discussions. It’s a system designed to filter out the noise and elevate authentic voices. By understanding the why and focusing on genuine participation within your areas of interest, you can quickly move from being a lurker to a valued contributor. The wait and the effort to build positive karma aren’t just hurdles; they’re your initiation into becoming a trusted member of the digital neighborhood. Happy (and constructive) posting!
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Some Online Communities Say: “To Post, Your Account Must Be Older Than 10 Days and Have 100 Positive Karma”