Why Schoolmates Sometimes Turn Into Frenemies
We’ve all seen it happen: the eye-rolls in the hallway, the whispered gossip during group projects, or the passive-aggressive comments on social media. School and university environments, which are supposed to foster collaboration and growth, often become breeding grounds for mean-spirited behavior. But why do classmates—people who share similar goals and experiences—sometimes treat each other so poorly? The answer lies in a mix of psychology, social dynamics, and the pressures of growing up.
The Quest for Social Hierarchy
During adolescence and early adulthood, individuals are still figuring out their identities and where they fit in society. Schools and universities act as microcosms of the real world, complete with unspoken rules about popularity, achievement, and social status. In this environment, students may resort to belittling others to elevate themselves.
A study by researchers at Arizona State University found that teens often use exclusion or ridicule to establish dominance within peer groups. For example, mocking someone’s appearance or academic performance can temporarily boost the aggressor’s social standing. This behavior isn’t always malicious in intent; sometimes, it’s a misguided attempt to gain acceptance from others. As one high school senior admitted anonymously, “I joined in making fun of a classmate because I didn’t want to be next.”
Fear and Insecurity: The Root of Rudeness
Beneath the surface of snarky remarks lies a deep well of insecurity. Students navigating academic pressures, family expectations, or personal insecurities may project their anxieties onto peers. Psychologists call this “displaced aggression”—attacking others to avoid confronting one’s own flaws or fears.
Consider the straight-A student who mocks a classmate for asking “dumb questions.” Their cruelty might stem from a fear of losing their top ranking or being exposed as less capable. Similarly, university students competing for internships or research opportunities might undermine peers to reduce perceived competition. As Dr. Lisa Damour, author of Untangled: Guiding Teenage Girls Through the Seven Transitions into Adulthood, notes, “When young people feel threatened—whether socially or academically—they often default to self-protection, even if it hurts others.”
The “Pack Mentality” Phenomenon
Group dynamics play a significant role in amplifying cruelty. Research shows that individuals in crowds or cliques are more likely to engage in behavior they’d avoid alone. This “mob mentality” reduces personal accountability—after all, “everyone else is doing it.”
Take cafeteria culture: A student might privately think a rumor is untrue but laugh along to avoid social isolation. Universities aren’t immune either. Fraternity hazing rituals or exclusive club initiations often normalize humiliation under the guise of tradition. As one college sophomore shared, “I hated making freshmen do embarrassing tasks during rush week, but seniors said it ‘built character.’ I didn’t want to seem weak by objecting.”
Digital Detachment: When Screens Fuel Sarcasm
The rise of social media and anonymous messaging apps has added fuel to the fire. Online interactions lack face-to-face accountability, making it easier to type hurtful comments than to say them aloud. A 2023 report by the Cyberbullying Research Center found that 64% of students witnessed peers being targeted in group chats, often through memes or subtweets (indirect social media jabs).
Anonymity tools like fake accounts or campus confessions pages take this further. “People post the nastiest things about others’ relationships or grades,” said a university student moderator of such a page. “They’d never say it openly, but hiding behind a screen makes them bold.”
Cultural and Systemic Influences
Sometimes, meanness is learned rather than innate. In highly competitive academic environments—think cutthroat college prep schools or programs with strict grading curves—students absorb the message that success requires stepping on others. Parents or teachers who prioritize winning over kindness indirectly endorse this behavior.
Media also plays a role. Reality TV shows glorify drama and “clapbacks,” while viral TikTok trends often reward sarcastic humor. Over time, young people internalize these patterns, viewing cruelty as entertaining or normal.
Breaking the Cycle: What Actually Helps
While meanness among peers feels inevitable, solutions exist. Schools that implement empathy-building programs, like peer mediation workshops or literature classes exploring moral dilemmas, see reduced bullying rates. Universities are adopting anonymous reporting systems for harassment and training professors to address classroom conflicts early.
On an individual level, setting boundaries helps. As author and educator Rosalind Wiseman advises, “Practice responding calmly to rude comments—something as simple as ‘That wasn’t cool’ can shift group dynamics.” Bystander intervention training, now common on campuses, teaches students to safely defuse tense situations.
For those on the receiving end, it’s crucial to remember that cruelty often reflects the perpetrator’s struggles, not the victim’s worth. Seeking support from trusted mentors or counselors can provide perspective.
Final Thoughts
Classroom meanness isn’t just “kids being kids”—it’s a complex interplay of fear, social conditioning, and environmental factors. By addressing root causes rather than just punishing surface-level behavior, educators and students can create communities where kindness isn’t seen as uncool, but as a strength. After all, the classmates who lift each other up today often become the colleagues and leaders who drive positive change tomorrow.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Schoolmates Sometimes Turn Into Frenemies