Why Schoolmates Sometimes Turn Into Frenemies
Have you ever wondered why classrooms and college hallways—spaces meant for learning and growth—often become battlegrounds for gossip, exclusion, or outright cruelty? From whispered insults to public humiliation, the dynamics between peers can feel shockingly harsh. While not every student experiences or participates in mean behavior, it’s a widespread phenomenon that leaves many asking: Why are classmates so nasty to each other?
To understand this, we need to peel back layers of social psychology, developmental challenges, and cultural influences. Let’s explore the roots of this behavior and what it reveals about human nature in educational settings.
—
The Pressure Cooker of Social Hierarchies
Schools and universities are microcosms of society, complete with their own social rankings. From elementary cliques to college sororities, there’s an unspoken competition for status. Research shows that adolescents and young adults often use aggression—verbal or relational—to climb social ladders. For example, putting others down can temporarily elevate one’s own standing within a group.
This behavior is amplified by insecurity. A student struggling with self-doubt might belittle others to deflect attention from their own perceived flaws. In a 2021 study published in Child Development, researchers found that teens who felt socially excluded were more likely to engage in “preemptive strikes” against peers to avoid rejection. Essentially, fear of being targeted first drives some to become the aggressor.
—
The Role of Group Mentality
Humans are wired to seek belonging, and group dynamics often override individual morals. Psychologists call this “deindividuation”—the loss of self-awareness in crowds. In classrooms, this might manifest as students joining in bullying to avoid becoming the next victim or to gain approval from dominant peers.
Consider the classic example of a class “outsider” being mocked. Even well-meaning students might laugh along to fit in, rationalizing it as “just a joke.” Over time, this behavior normalizes, creating a culture where cruelty feels acceptable.
—
The Copycat Effect: Learning From Adults
Students aren’t born knowing how to be mean; they often mimic what they see. If teachers, parents, or older siblings model dismissive or aggressive communication, young people internalize these patterns. A university student raised in a household where sarcasm was used as a weapon might unconsciously replicate that style with peers.
Even subtle cues matter. When educators favor certain students or turn a blind eye to exclusionary behavior, it sends a message that hierarchy matters more than kindness.
—
Digital Anonymity Fuels the Fire
While face-to-face meanness is age-old, technology adds a new dimension. Cyberbullying allows classmates to harass others without immediate consequences. A nasty comment online can be posted in seconds but haunt the recipient for years. The distance created by screens also reduces empathy—it’s easier to forget there’s a human behind the profile picture.
—
The Crush of Academic Competition
In high-stakes academic environments, peers aren’t just friends—they’re rivals. Cutthroat competition for grades, scholarships, or internships can breed resentment. Students might sabotage others’ projects, spread rumors about academic dishonesty, or downplay classmates’ achievements to gain an edge.
A 2020 study from Stanford University revealed that in highly competitive programs, students reported higher levels of peer mistrust. When everyone’s racing for limited opportunities, collaboration often takes a backseat to self-interest.
—
The Empathy Gap
Young people are still developing emotionally. The prefrontal cortex—the brain region responsible for impulse control and empathy—isn’t fully mature until the mid-20s. This biological reality means teenagers and undergraduates might struggle to grasp the long-term impact of their words. A thoughtless insult (“Your presentation was cringe”) might feel trivial to the speaker but deeply wound the listener.
Additionally, not all students are taught emotional literacy. Those who haven’t learned to name or manage their feelings may lash out when stressed, jealous, or overwhelmed.
—
Cultural Narratives That Glorify “Mean”
Popular media often romanticizes social aggression. From reality TV villains to influencers who gain followers through drama, young people are bombarded with examples of meanness being rewarded. Phrases like “I’m just keeping it real” or “No filter!” are used to justify harsh behavior. Over time, this shapes perceptions that kindness equals weakness.
—
Breaking the Cycle: What Can Be Done?
While meanness among peers is common, it’s not inevitable. Here are steps educators, parents, and students can take:
1. Teach Conflict Resolution Early: Schools should integrate social-emotional learning (SEL) programs that emphasize empathy, active listening, and respectful disagreement.
2. Redefine Success: Reduce hyper-competitiveness by celebrating teamwork over individual wins. Project-based grading or group scholarships can encourage cooperation.
3. Model Healthy Behavior: Adults must demonstrate constructive communication. A professor who openly admits mistakes or a parent who apologizes after snapping teaches accountability.
4. Create Safe Reporting Channels: Many students stay silent about bullying due to fear or shame. Anonymous reporting apps and trusted counselors can bridge this gap.
5. Encourage Offline Connections: Schools and universities should design spaces that foster face-to-face interaction—book clubs, intramural sports, or mentorship programs—to rebuild community.
—
Final Thoughts
Classmate cruelty often stems from insecurity, immaturity, and environments that prioritize status over humanity. However, understanding the “why” behind the behavior is the first step toward change. By addressing root causes and fostering cultures of empathy, educational institutions can transform from arenas of rivalry into spaces where students lift each other up. After all, the lessons we learn about kindness in school often stick with us long after we’ve forgotten the quadratic formula.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Schoolmates Sometimes Turn Into Frenemies