Why Mario and Prodigy Are More Different Than You Think
When you think of video games, titles like Super Mario Bros. probably come to mind—colorful worlds, jumping on enemies, and rescuing princesses. But in recent years, a new category has emerged: educational games like Prodigy, which combine gameplay with math practice or other academic skills. At first glance, both types of games seem similar—they’re interactive, engaging, and designed to keep players coming back. However, their purposes, mechanics, and long-term impacts on players diverge in fascinating ways. Let’s break down what sets these two categories apart.
1. Goals: Entertainment vs. Learning Outcomes
The most obvious difference lies in their core objectives. Games like Mario are built purely for entertainment. The goal is to create an immersive experience where players escape reality, enjoy challenges, and feel a sense of accomplishment through skill mastery. For example, beating a tough level in Mario feels rewarding because you’ve honed reflexes and problem-solving skills, but the game doesn’t prioritize teaching algebra or grammar.
Educational games like Prodigy, on the other hand, are structured around learning objectives. In Prodigy, players explore a fantasy world where battles and quests are tied to solving math problems. Progress depends not just on quick reflexes but on correctly answering questions aligned with school curricula. The fun isn’t just in the gameplay; it’s woven into practicing multiplication tables or fractions. While entertainment is still part of the design, the primary focus is reinforcing academic skills.
2. Feedback Systems: Points vs. Progress Tracking
Both types of games use feedback to motivate players, but they do it differently. In Mario, you collect coins, earn extra lives, or unlock secret levels. These rewards are immediate and tied to in-game achievements. The feedback loop is simple: Do well, get a prize. This keeps players engaged but doesn’t connect to real-world skills.
Educational games take feedback a step further. In Prodigy, solving a math problem correctly might let your character cast a powerful spell, but the game also tracks which concepts a player has mastered and where they need improvement. Teachers and parents can access reports showing a student’s strengths and weaknesses, turning gameplay into actionable data. The feedback isn’t just about winning; it’s about measurable growth over time.
3. Player Motivation: Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic
Mario thrives on intrinsic motivation—the pure joy of playing. There’s no external pressure to finish the game; you play because it’s fun. Kids (and adults!) return to these games simply for the thrill of exploration and competition.
Educational games often blend intrinsic and extrinsic motivators. For instance, Prodigy uses exciting quests and character customization to make learning feel like an adventure (intrinsic). However, many schools and parents also incentivize play by linking it to classroom goals or homework requirements (extrinsic). This dual approach can encourage consistency but risks making the game feel like a chore if not balanced carefully.
4. Skill Development: Broad vs. Targeted
Traditional games like Mario indirectly foster skills like hand-eye coordination, pattern recognition, and strategic thinking. These are valuable, but they’re not explicitly academic. A player might get better at timing jumps or memorizing level layouts, but those skills don’t translate directly to a math test.
Educational games aim for targeted skill development. Prodigy aligns its content with grade-level standards, ensuring that gameplay directly supports classroom learning. If a student struggles with division, the game adapts to provide more practice in that area. Over time, players build confidence in specific subjects, making these games a supplemental tool for formal education.
5. Long-Term Engagement: Beating the Game vs. Continuous Learning
A classic game like Mario has a clear endpoint: defeat Bowser, save Peach, and watch the credits roll. Once you’ve mastered the game, there’s little reason to revisit it unless you’re chasing speedrun records or higher difficulty modes.
Educational games are designed for ongoing engagement. Prodigy regularly updates its content, adds new challenges, and adjusts difficulty based on the player’s progress. Since learning is a continuous process, the game evolves alongside the student. This creates a longer-lasting relationship between the player and the game, though it requires careful updates to avoid repetition.
6. Audience: Universal Appeal vs. Niche Learning
Mario appeals to almost anyone—kids, teens, adults—because it’s easy to pick up and universally enjoyable. You don’t need to love math or history to appreciate dodging Goombas or racing friends in Mario Kart.
Educational games cater to a more specific audience. Prodigy is primarily aimed at K-8 students (and their teachers/parents) looking to reinforce math skills. While the gameplay is fun, its niche focus means it’s less likely to attract casual gamers outside its target demographic.
The Overlap: Can a Game Be Both Fun and Educational?
The line between “normal” and educational games isn’t always clear. For example, Minecraft started as a sandbox game but later introduced an Education Edition tailored for classrooms. Similarly, games like Civilization teach historical concepts through empire-building gameplay.
The key difference remains intent. Mario wasn’t designed to teach math, but that doesn’t mean it lacks educational value—it encourages perseverance, creativity, and critical thinking. Conversely, Prodigy uses gamification to make learning math feel less like homework. The best educational games strike a balance where the learning is seamless, not forced.
Final Thoughts
At their core, both Mario and Prodigy succeed by making complex tasks feel rewarding. The difference lies in what they reward: one prioritizes skill and enjoyment, while the other ties progress to academic growth. Neither approach is “better”—they serve different needs. For parents and educators, understanding these distinctions can help choose the right tool for the moment: a fun break with Mario or a stealthy math lesson with Prodigy. After all, the best games—whether educational or not—are the ones that keep us coming back for more.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Mario and Prodigy Are More Different Than You Think