Why Many Americans Feel They Excelled in Language Arts Over Math
When reflecting on their school years, a common refrain among Americans is, “I was better at language arts than math.” Whether chatting with coworkers, scrolling through social media, or reminiscing with old friends, this self-assessment pops up frequently. But why does this perception persist? Is it rooted in actual academic performance, cultural attitudes, or something deeper about how we learn and value different subjects? Let’s unpack this phenomenon and explore what it reveals about education, confidence, and societal narratives.
The Confidence Divide: Words vs. Numbers
Language arts—encompassing reading, writing, and communication—often feel more intuitive to students. From a young age, children are immersed in storytelling, vocabulary-building games, and casual conversations that reinforce language skills. Math, on the other hand, introduces abstract concepts (like algebra or geometry) that demand structured problem-solving. For many, this shift from concrete to abstract thinking creates a stumbling block.
Research supports this divide. Studies show that students tend to rate their confidence in language-related tasks higher than in math, even when their performance in both subjects is comparable. This gap isn’t necessarily about ability but perception. Language arts often provide multiple avenues for self-expression and creativity, allowing students to “hide” mistakes behind subjective interpretation. Math, however, feels binary—answers are right or wrong, leaving little room for ambiguity. The fear of being “exposed” for a wrong answer can fuel anxiety and self-doubt.
Cultural Narratives: “I’m Just Not a Math Person”
Society plays a surprising role in shaping these attitudes. From movies to memes, cultural messaging often frames math as inherently difficult or exclusive to “geniuses,” while language skills are portrayed as accessible and universal. How many times have you heard someone joke, “I can’t even calculate a tip!” but rarely, “I can’t write a coherent sentence”?
These narratives start early. Parents might openly admit their own math struggles in front of children, normalizing the idea that math is a hurdle. Meanwhile, reading and writing are treated as foundational life skills. By the time students reach high school, the belief that math requires a “special aptitude” becomes ingrained. In contrast, language arts are seen as a reflection of effort—something anyone can improve with practice.
Classroom Dynamics: Where Do Students Shine?
Teaching methods also contribute. Language arts classes often emphasize discussion, personal reflection, and projects that validate diverse perspectives. A student who struggles with grammar might still earn praise for a creative story. Math classrooms, however, traditionally prioritize speed, precision, and standardized procedures. A single misstep can derail an entire problem, leading to frustration.
This dynamic disproportionately affects students who thrive with collaborative or creative learning styles. For example, visual learners might grasp geometry concepts through diagrams but hit a wall with algebraic equations taught through rote memorization. Without varied teaching approaches, math can feel alienating, while language arts offer more flexibility to connect with individual strengths.
The Gender Factor: Stereotypes and Self-Perception
Gender stereotypes further muddy the waters. Despite similar performance levels in early education, girls often report lower confidence in math by middle school. Cultural cues—like toys marketed as “for boys” (e.g., science kits) vs. “for girls” (e.g., writing journals)—subtly reinforce the idea that STEM fields are masculine. Conversely, language arts are perceived as nurturing and empathetic, traits traditionally associated with femininity.
These biases influence self-assessment. A girl who aces both English and calculus might downplay her math skills to align with societal expectations. Boys, meanwhile, may feel pressured to emphasize STEM prowess, even if they prefer literature. Over time, these gendered perceptions solidify, shaping career choices and academic identities.
The Long-Term Impact: Careers and Everyday Life
The belief that “I’m better at language arts” doesn’t vanish after graduation. It echoes in career paths and daily decisions. Many adults avoid roles requiring quantitative skills, even if they’re capable, simply because they’ve internalized the idea that math isn’t their strength. This avoidance limits opportunities in fields like finance, data analysis, or engineering.
Ironically, strong communication skills are equally vital in nearly every profession. The ability to write clearly, persuade audiences, or explain complex ideas often determines career advancement. Yet, because language arts feel more “natural,” their importance is sometimes overlooked. Meanwhile, math anxiety persists, with many adults relying on calculators for basic tasks, reinforcing the cycle of self-doubt.
Rethinking How We Teach (and Talk About) Math
Changing this narrative starts in the classroom. Educators are increasingly adopting strategies to make math more engaging and less intimidating. Project-based learning, real-world applications (e.g., budgeting or cooking), and celebrating progress over perfection help demystify the subject. Schools are also emphasizing growth mindset principles—teaching students that effort, not innate talent, drives success in any field.
Parents and mentors can reframe conversations, too. Instead of saying, “I was bad at math,” adults might say, “Math challenged me, but I kept trying.” Highlighting stories of late-blooming mathematicians or professionals who use math creatively (e.g., architects, musicians) can broaden perceptions of what math “looks like.”
Embracing Multipotentiality: It’s Okay to Love Both
Ultimately, the language arts vs. math divide is a false binary. Humans are multipotential—capable of excelling in diverse areas. Consider poets who adore coding or engineers who write novels. The key is fostering environments where kids (and adults) feel permitted to explore both words and numbers without judgment.
So, the next time someone says, “I was better at language arts,” it’s worth asking: Was it really about ability, or the way we’re taught to view our strengths? By challenging stereotypes and embracing balanced learning, we might just raise a generation that feels confident tackling essays and equations—no apologies needed.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Many Americans Feel They Excelled in Language Arts Over Math