Why “Just Get an Evaluation” Can Backfire With Worried Parents
Imagine this: Sarah, a kindergarten teacher, notices Liam struggling to recognize letters and follow simple instructions compared to his peers. Concerned, she gently tells his parents at pickup, “I’m seeing some delays. You should really just get a full evaluation.” She means well – she wants Liam to get support. But for Liam’s parents, Mark and Jessica, the world tilts. “Evaluation?” Their minds race: What’s wrong? Is it serious? What does this mean? That simple, well-intentioned suggestion often lands like a lead weight, creating more barriers than it removes.
The phrase “just get a full evaluation” is thrown around frequently in educational and therapeutic circles. It sounds logical, even responsible. But for many parents, especially those navigating concerns about their child’s development for the first time, it’s frequently the worst possible first step. Here’s why, and what professionals can do instead to build bridges, not walls:
1. It’s Overwhelming and Fear-Inducing:
Jargon Overload: “Full evaluation” is professional jargon. To a parent, it might sound like a daunting, complex, and potentially scary medical or psychological process. They don’t know what it entails, how long it takes, or what the potential outcomes are.
Implied Severity: Hearing this directive often translates instantly in a parent’s mind to: “Something is seriously wrong with my child.” It triggers fears about labels, lifelong challenges, and an uncertain future.
Information Vacuum: Without context, parents fill the void with worst-case scenarios found online or through anecdotal (often inaccurate) stories.
2. It Skips the Crucial Step of Listening and Validating:
Dismissing Parental Experience: Jumping straight to “get an evaluation” can feel like the professional isn’t truly hearing the parent’s specific observations, worries, or the unique context of their child and family. It shuts down conversation.
Missing Nuance: Parents are experts on their children. Their detailed observations about how Liam struggles at home, or when he seems most frustrated, are invaluable. Skipping this step means missing crucial diagnostic clues and failing to build rapport.
Invalidating Concerns (or Creating Them): For parents already anxious, it confirms their deepest fears abruptly. For parents surprised by the suggestion, it can feel like their concerns are being dismissed or, conversely, that worries they hadn’t even considered are suddenly paramount.
3. It Often Fails to Explain the “Why” and the “How”:
Lacks Purpose: Why is an evaluation needed? What specific questions might it answer? How could understanding Liam’s learning profile help him? Parents need this rationale to move from fear to motivation.
No Roadmap: “Get an evaluation” gives zero guidance. Where do they go? (Pediatrician? School? Private clinic?) How do they start? (Referral needed? Insurance hurdles?) What types of professionals are involved? This lack of direction leaves parents paralyzed.
Ignores Practical Barriers: Cost, insurance complexities, long waitlists, transportation, taking time off work – these are massive real-world obstacles the simple directive ignores.
4. It Can Breed Defensiveness and Delay Action:
Feeling Attacked: Parents naturally feel protective. A sudden call for an evaluation can feel like criticism of their parenting or their child, leading to defensiveness and resistance.
Shutting Down: Overwhelmed by fear and lack of information, parents might simply disengage. They might avoid future communication with the teacher or therapist, delay seeking any help, or actively resist the suggestion.
Damaged Trust: This initial misstep can fracture the crucial parent-professional partnership needed for the child’s long-term success.
So, What’s a Better First Step? Building Bridges, Not Issuing Orders
Instead of leading with “get an evaluation,” professionals should focus on collaborative exploration and informed next steps. Here’s how:
1. Start with Observation and Active Listening: “Ms. Johnson, I’ve noticed Liam finds it tricky to remember the names of letters when we work in small groups. What have you observed at home when reading or playing letter games?” Listen deeply to their response.
2. Validate Concerns and Feelings: “It sounds like you’ve noticed some similar frustrations during homework time. It’s understandable to feel concerned when things seem harder for them.” This builds trust and shows empathy.
3. Share Specific Concerns Clearly (Without Jargon): Instead of vague worries, be concrete: “Right now, Liam is working on recognizing 5 basic letters. Most peers recognize 10-15. He also needs directions repeated or shown visually more often than others during activities.” Focus on the impact on learning or participation.
4. Frame the “Why” of Potential Next Steps: “Understanding why Liam finds these things challenging would help us figure out the absolute best ways to teach him and support him, both here and at home. Different kids learn in different ways.”
5. Introduce Evaluation as ONE Possible Tool (Later): “One way to get that clearer picture is through a comprehensive evaluation. This isn’t about finding something ‘wrong,’ but about mapping out Liam’s unique strengths and learning style to pinpoint where he needs different strategies.” Explain it as a discovery process.
6. Explain the Process Simply: “If we go that route, it usually involves talking to specialists who might observe Liam, play some games with him, or ask you more questions. They’ll put all that information together to help us understand how he learns best.” Briefly outline steps without overwhelming.
7. Offer Guidance and Partnership: “This can feel like a lot. I’m here to help. We can talk about who does these evaluations – sometimes the school can, sometimes it’s through your doctor or a private center. We can look at options together.” Provide clear next actions: “Could I share some information about the process? Would you like to talk about who to contact first?”
Shifting the Focus: From Label to Blueprint
Ultimately, the goal isn’t just to get a child evaluated; it’s to understand them better to provide the right support. By approaching parents with empathy, collaboration, and clear information, professionals transform “Just get an evaluation” from a frightening directive into an informed, shared decision.
Think of the evaluation not as an end point labeled with a diagnosis, but as the beginning of creating a detailed blueprint. This blueprint, built on understanding a child’s unique neurological wiring, learning style, strengths, and challenges, guides everyone – parents, teachers, therapists – in constructing the most supportive and effective environment possible. When professionals take the time to lay the foundation of trust and partnership first, parents are far more likely to walk through the door of evaluation feeling supported, informed, and ready to use the insights it provides to help their child truly thrive. The first step isn’t a referral; it’s a conversation built on respect.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why “Just Get an Evaluation” Can Backfire With Worried Parents