Why “Every Single College” Might Be the Worst Advice You’ve Ever Heard
The phrase “apply to every college” sounds like a safety net for anxious students, but in reality, it’s one of the worst strategies imaginable. Scattering applications like confetti might feel proactive, but it often leads to burnout, wasted resources, and—ironically—lower chances of finding the right fit. Let’s unpack why blanket-applying to schools is a flawed approach and how to avoid falling into this trap.
—
The Myth of “More Applications = Better Options”
The college admissions process has become a numbers game. Students are told that applying to 20+ schools increases their odds of acceptance somewhere. But here’s the catch: quality trumps quantity. Admissions committees can spot generic applications from a mile away. When essays and supplemental materials aren’t tailored to a school’s values, culture, or programs, applicants risk blending into a sea of mediocrity.
For example, a student passionate about environmental science who applies to a tech-focused institute “just because” is unlikely to showcase alignment with that school’s mission. Worse, spreading yourself thin across too many applications often means sacrificing the depth and authenticity that make essays memorable.
—
The Hidden Costs of Overapplying
Let’s talk logistics. Each application costs money—anywhere from $50 to $100 per school—and many require supplemental essays or portfolios. A student applying to 25 colleges could easily spend over $2,000 on fees alone, not to mention hours of work. This “spray and pray” method disproportionately burdens low-income families and adds unnecessary stress.
But the real cost isn’t just financial. Students who apply indiscriminately often end up with a pile of acceptance letters from schools they never seriously considered. Suddenly, they’re forced to choose between unfamiliar options, risking buyer’s remorse. As one college counselor put it, “It’s better to have five thoughtful choices than 20 random maybes.”
—
The “Bad Fit” Trap: When Every College Feels Wrong
Here’s a harsh truth: Some schools are objectively terrible matches for certain students, no matter how prestigious they seem. A socially anxious introvert might drown in a massive lecture hall at a state university. A hands-on learner could wither in a theory-heavy liberal arts program. A student needing robust mental health support might find themselves stranded at a school with understaffed counseling services.
Yet, when applicants don’t research schools deeply, they miss these red flags. They might end up at a “top-ranked” institution only to realize its cutthroat culture clashes with their collaborative nature. Or they could overlook a lesser-known college that perfectly aligns with their goals. Blindly applying everywhere increases the likelihood of ending up in a mismatched environment.
—
The Rankings Ruse: Why Prestige Isn’t Everything
The obsession with Ivy Leagues and “Top 20” lists fuels the “apply everywhere” mentality. But rankings rarely reflect individual needs. For instance:
– A school celebrated for its engineering program might have lackluster humanities departments.
– A rural campus might offer idyllic study conditions for some but isolation for others.
– A college with a strong Greek life scene could alienate students who prefer quieter communities.
Worse, some institutions aggressively market themselves while downplaying drawbacks like low graduation rates, poor faculty-student ratios, or inadequate career services. Applicants seduced by glossy brochures or viral social media campaigns might overlook these pitfalls.
—
How to Avoid the “Every College” Mistake
1. Start with self-reflection.
Before listing schools, ask: What do I need to thrive? Consider learning style, social preferences, career goals, and non-negotiables (e.g., financial aid, proximity to home).
2. Research with precision.
Dig beyond websites. Talk to current students, attend virtual tours, and scour forums like Reddit for unfiltered opinions. Look for patterns: Do art majors complain about outdated facilities? Do alumni struggle to find jobs in their field?
3. Create a balanced list.
Aim for 8–12 schools total, categorized into reach, match, and safety schools. Ensure every option aligns with your priorities—even the safeties. As admissions consultant Michelle Kretzschmar says, “A true safety isn’t just a school you’ll get into; it’s one you’d happily attend.”
4. Quality over quantity in applications.
Tailor each submission. Mention specific professors, courses, or clubs that excite you. Show how you’d contribute to campus life. Admissions officers reward authenticity, not checkbox exercises.
—
The Bottom Line: Fit Matters More Than You Think
College isn’t a trophy to collect; it’s a life-changing experience. A poorly matched school can lead to transferring, dropping out, or lingering dissatisfaction. By resisting the “apply everywhere” panic and focusing on intentional choices, students save time, money, and energy—and ultimately find communities where they’ll grow and succeed.
As you draft your list, remember: The goal isn’t to win a popularity contest with acceptance letters. It’s to find places where you’ll genuinely belong.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why “Every Single College” Might Be the Worst Advice You’ve Ever Heard