Why Does School Feel Like a Never-Ending Sadness Marathon?
Ever sat in class wondering why every subject feels like a crash course in human suffering? From war-torn history lessons to literature filled with tragedy and science classes that dissect existential threats like climate change, it’s easy to feel like education is stuck on “doom mode.” But why does so much of what we learn seem downright depressing? Let’s unpack this frustration and explore what’s really going on—and whether it’s time for a classroom vibe shift.
The Curriculum’s Dark Side
Flip through a typical high school syllabus, and you’ll find no shortage of heavy topics. History classes dwell on genocides, oppressive regimes, and societal collapses. English departments favor Shakespearean tragedies (Hamlet’s existential crisis, anyone?) and dystopian novels like 1984. Even science isn’t immune: lessons on nuclear weapons, pandemics, and ecological disasters can leave students feeling powerless.
This isn’t a coincidence. Education systems globally prioritize teaching humanity’s mistakes and darkest moments. But why? One argument is that understanding suffering fosters empathy and critical thinking. By studying the Holocaust, for example, students grapple with the consequences of prejudice and authoritarianism. Similarly, analyzing climate data pushes learners to confront urgent global challenges. In short, “depressing” content often serves as a mirror to reality—a tool to prepare young people for a complex world.
Why the Gloom?
If the goal is to create informed citizens, why does the scale tip so heavily toward the bleak? Here are three factors at play:
1. The “Never Again” Mentality
Many educators believe that teaching tragic history prevents repetition. Wars, systemic injustices, and environmental crises become cautionary tales. The logic is sound: if we don’t understand past failures, we’re doomed to repeat them. But when every unit feels like a parade of horrors, students risk disengaging. It’s like serving vegetables at every meal—nutritious, but hardly appetizing.
2. The Bias Toward “Serious” Knowledge
There’s an unspoken hierarchy in academia: solemn topics are seen as intellectually rigorous, while lighter subjects (like pop culture or everyday joy) are dismissed as frivolous. This bias seeps into curricula, sidelining stories of resilience, innovation, or everyday happiness. Imagine a history class that spent equal time on medical breakthroughs and plagues, or an English course pairing Kafka’s Metamorphosis with Terry Pratchett’s wit. Balance is rare.
3. Institutional Inertia
Education systems are slow to change. Textbooks and standardized tests often reflect outdated priorities. For instance, U.S. history courses still emphasize battles and presidents over social movements or technological advancements. This inertia means depressing content stays front-and-center simply because “that’s how it’s always been taught.”
Shifting the Narrative: Can Schools Teach Hope?
Critiquing the system is easy—but what would a more balanced education look like? Here’s where the conversation gets interesting:
1. Reframe How We Teach “Negative” Topics
Tragedy doesn’t have to equal hopelessness. Take climate change: instead of ending lessons with melting ice caps, teachers could spotlight renewable energy innovations or youth-led conservation projects. Similarly, history classes could pair events like the Civil Rights Movement with modern activists continuing the fight. The key is to highlight agency—what can we do?—rather than leaving students feeling defeated.
2. Expand the Canon
Why not teach scientific discoveries that saved lives (penicillin, vaccines) alongside ethical dilemmas? Or balance Lord of the Flies with novels celebrating human connection, like The House on Mango Street? Including diverse voices and genres can counterbalance the gloom. For example, Indigenous stories often weave resilience and environmental stewardship into narratives of struggle.
3. Let Students Drive the Conversation
A Stanford study found that learners retain information better when they actively connect it to their lives. Instead of lecturing about the French Revolution’s bloodshed, teachers might ask: How would you address inequality in your community? Projects that empower students to solve real-world problems—designing mental health resources, launching recycling initiatives—turn despair into action.
4. Train Teachers to Navigate Nuance
Educators need support to handle heavy topics sensitively. Professional development programs could teach strategies for discussing trauma without triggering anxiety. For example, using art or music to process historical events, or incorporating mindfulness breaks during intense lessons.
The Bigger Picture: What’s the Purpose of School?
Underlying the “depressing curriculum” debate is a fundamental question: What should education do? If schools exist solely to prepare workers, then focusing on humanity’s flaws makes sense—it’s a tough world out there. But if education aims to nurture well-rounded, mentally healthy citizens, then joy, creativity, and hope deserve equal billing.
This isn’t about sugarcoating reality. It’s about recognizing that students need both the tools to critique the world and the inspiration to improve it. As writer and educator bell hooks argued, true learning occurs when rigor meets compassion.
Final Thoughts
So, do we only learn “depressing shit”? Not exactly—but the scales are tipped. The good news? Change is possible. Schools in Finland and New Zealand, for instance, have redesigned curricula to emphasize well-being and environmental stewardship alongside traditional subjects. Students in these systems report higher engagement and optimism.
The next time a lesson leaves you feeling drained, remember: Education isn’t just about absorbing information. It’s about questioning why certain stories get told—and demanding space for narratives that spark curiosity, connection, and maybe even a little hope. After all, the future isn’t written yet. Why should our classrooms act like it is?
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Does School Feel Like a Never-Ending Sadness Marathon