Why Calling Classmates “Stupid” Does More Harm Than We Realize
We’ve all witnessed it: A student raises their hand in class, answers a question incorrectly, and someone mutters, “That’s so stupid.” Maybe it’s a sarcastic laugh during a group project when someone shares an unconventional idea. Or perhaps it’s a casual insult disguised as a joke: “Only an idiot wouldn’t get this.” These moments might seem small, but the impact of labeling classmates as “stupid” ripples far beyond the classroom. Let’s unpack why this behavior is damaging, how it shapes learning environments, and what we can do to foster kindness over cruelty.
The Power of Words in Shaping Mindsets
Words aren’t just sounds; they carry weight. Psychologist Carol Dweck’s research on “fixed” vs. “growth” mindsets reveals how language influences self-perception. When students hear peers call them “stupid,” it reinforces a fixed mindset—the belief that intelligence is static. Over time, this can lead to avoidance of challenges, fear of failure, and disengagement. A student who internalizes the label might stop participating in discussions or asking questions, thinking, “Why try if I’m just going to embarrass myself?”
But the harm isn’t limited to the targeted individual. Witnessing this behavior normalizes disrespect. It teaches bystanders that mocking others is acceptable, even entertaining. This creates a toxic culture where learning becomes a competition to avoid humiliation rather than a collaborative journey.
The Social Dynamics of Insults
Why do some students resort to calling others “stupid”? Often, it’s a misguided attempt to assert dominance or deflect insecurity. By putting others down, they might feel temporarily superior or mask their own struggles. For example, a student struggling with math might mock a peer’s calculation errors to avoid admitting, “I don’t understand either.”
This behavior also reflects broader societal attitudes. We live in a world that often equates intelligence with worth, where mistakes are seen as failures rather than opportunities to grow. When kids absorb these messages, they replicate them in their interactions, perpetuating cycles of judgment.
Real Consequences Beyond the Classroom
The effects of verbal belittling extend far beyond hurt feelings. Studies link prolonged exposure to peer insults to anxiety, depression, and lower academic performance. A 2021 study in the Journal of Educational Psychology found that students who faced regular mocking in class were 34% more likely to skip school and 28% less likely to seek help from teachers.
Additionally, labeling peers as “stupid” stifles creativity. Innovation thrives in environments where people feel safe to take risks. If every “silly” idea is met with eye rolls, students learn to self-censor. Imagine how many groundbreaking inventions or solutions never saw the light of day because someone feared ridicule.
Breaking the Cycle: What Can We Do?
Changing this pattern requires effort from everyone—students, teachers, and parents alike. Here are practical steps to create a culture of respect:
1. Model Empathetic Language
Teachers and parents can set the tone by praising effort over outcomes. Instead of saying, “You’re so smart!” try, “I admire how hard you worked on this.” When a student struggles, frame mistakes as learning opportunities: “That didn’t work—what could we try next?”
2. Address the Behavior, Not the Person
If a student insults a classmate, avoid shaming them. Instead, calmly say, “Comments like that make it harder for everyone to learn. Let’s focus on solutions.” This redirects the conversation to collective responsibility.
3. Teach Critical Thinking About Intelligence
Discuss the concept of multiple intelligences (e.g., emotional, artistic, logical) to show that “smart” isn’t one-size-fits-all. Highlight role models who succeeded through perseverance, like Thomas Edison’s 1,000 failed attempts before inventing the lightbulb.
4. Create Safe Reporting Channels
Many students stay silent because they fear retaliation. Schools can implement anonymous reporting systems or assign “kindness ambassadors” to mediate conflicts.
5. Celebrate Vulnerability
Share stories of famous scientists, artists, and leaders who openly discuss their struggles. Normalize phrases like, “I don’t know—can someone help me understand?”
The Ripple Effect of Kindness
When we replace mockery with encouragement, the results are transformative. I once taught a student named Jake, who rarely spoke after being called “clueless” in middle school. During a physics lesson, he hesitantly suggested an unconventional approach to a problem. Instead of laughter, his classmates responded with curiosity: “Wait, how did you think of that?” That moment boosted Jake’s confidence, and he became one of the most active contributors in class.
Small acts of kindness—like saying, “I see what you’re trying to say” instead of “That’s wrong”—build trust. They remind us that intelligence isn’t about having all the answers; it’s about asking questions, experimenting, and growing together.
Final Thoughts
Labeling classmates as “stupid” isn’t just mean-spirited; it’s counterproductive. It erodes self-esteem, stifles potential, and poisons the learning environment. But by choosing empathy over judgment, we can create classrooms—and communities—where everyone feels safe to learn, stumble, and thrive. After all, education isn’t a race to the top; it’s a shared journey where every voice deserves respect. Let’s make sure our words reflect that.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Calling Classmates “Stupid” Does More Harm Than We Realize