Why Are Classmates So Mean to Each Other? Understanding Schoolyard Cruelty
We’ve all witnessed it: the eye-rolls in class, the whispered insults in hallways, or the public humiliation during group projects. School and university environments, though meant to foster growth and collaboration, often become breeding grounds for meanness. But why do peers—people who share similar goals and challenges—turn so harshly against one another? Let’s unpack the psychology and social dynamics behind this unsettling behavior.
1. The Social Hierarchy Game
Schools and universities function like micro-societies with their own unspoken rules. Students often jockey for status, forming cliques or alliances to secure their place in the social pecking order. This “survival of the coolest” mindset can lead to exclusion, gossip, or even bullying.
Think of it this way: If someone feels insecure about their own position, putting others down becomes a twisted way to climb higher. A student might mock a classmate’s outfit to deflect attention from their own social insecurities. Research shows that adolescence and early adulthood are peak times for social anxiety, making young people hyper-aware of how others perceive them—and sometimes overly eager to control that narrative.
2. Stress and Projection
Academic pressure is a silent driver of cruelty. Students juggling exams, part-time jobs, and family expectations often feel overwhelmed. When stress isn’t managed healthily, it can morph into frustration directed at peers.
For example, a university student struggling with a heavy course load might snap at a groupmate for minor mistakes, not because the groupmate deserves it, but because the stress has reached a boiling point. In competitive environments, peers are seen not as allies but as rivals. This “everyone for themselves” mentality fosters resentment, not camaraderie.
3. The Pack Mentality
Humans are social creatures wired to seek belonging. Unfortunately, this instinct can backfire. When a group collectively decides to target someone, individuals within that group may participate in cruelty—even if they privately disagree—to avoid becoming the next target.
This “pack mentality” explains why entire friend groups might ostracize a former member or why classrooms erupt in laughter at one person’s expense. The fear of social rejection overrides empathy. As psychologist Dr. Lisa Damour notes, “Teens and young adults often prioritize fitting in over doing what’s right, especially when they’re still developing their moral compass.”
4. Lack of Conflict Resolution Skills
Many students simply don’t know how to handle disagreements maturely. Raised in environments where disagreements are either avoided or met with shouting matches, they replicate these patterns in peer relationships.
Imagine two classmates arguing over a project grade. Instead of calmly discussing the issue, they resort to personal attacks or passive-aggressive comments. Without guidance on healthy communication, minor conflicts escalate into personal vendettas. Schools often focus on academic outcomes while overlooking emotional intelligence training, leaving students ill-equipped to navigate interpersonal challenges.
5. Copying What They See
Students aren’t immune to the influences around them. If they observe teachers, parents, or older siblings using sarcasm, ridicule, or aggression to solve problems, they mirror those behaviors. A professor who publicly shames a student for a wrong answer inadvertently teaches the class that humiliation is an acceptable tool.
Similarly, media plays a role. Reality TV shows and social media influencers often glorify drama, clapbacks, and “roasting” as entertainment. Young people internalize these interactions as normal—even aspirational—without understanding the real-world harm they cause.
6. The Anonymity of Digital Spaces
Modern meanness isn’t confined to face-to-face interactions. Online platforms allow students to harass peers anonymously or with reduced accountability. A nasty comment on Instagram or a mocking TikTok video can spread cruelty far beyond the classroom walls.
The digital barrier makes it easier to dehumanize others. As one high schooler shared anonymously, “It’s like you forget there’s a real person behind the screen. You just type whatever comes to mind.”
7. Unresolved Personal Struggles
Sometimes, cruelty stems from a classmate’s own unresolved pain. A student dealing with family issues, identity crises, or mental health challenges might project their anger onto peers. It’s not an excuse for bad behavior, but it’s a reminder that hurt people often hurt people.
For instance, a university student grappling with feelings of inadequacy might belittle others’ achievements to cope with their own fears of failure. Recognizing this doesn’t justify the behavior, but it highlights the importance of addressing root causes.
Breaking the Cycle: What Can Be Done?
While meanness in schools is complex, it’s not inevitable. Here’s how communities can foster healthier environments:
– Teach Emotional Literacy: Integrate social-emotional learning (SEL) into curricula. Role-playing scenarios, mindfulness exercises, and conflict resolution workshops can equip students with tools to communicate kindly.
– Model Respectful Behavior: Adults in educational settings must lead by example. A teacher who admits mistakes or addresses conflicts calmly shows students how to handle disagreements constructively.
– Create Safe Reporting Channels: Many students stay silent about bullying because they fear retaliation. Anonymous reporting systems and trusted counselors can encourage victims and bystanders to speak up.
– Celebrate Diversity: Schools and universities should actively highlight the value of different perspectives. When students feel respected for who they are, they’re less likely to attack differences in others.
Final Thoughts
Cruelty among classmates isn’t just “kids being kids” or a rite of passage. It’s a symptom of deeper societal and psychological issues that demand attention. By understanding the “why” behind the behavior, we can create environments where kindness isn’t the exception—but the norm. After all, schools and universities shouldn’t just be places to learn math or history; they should be spaces where we learn how to be better humans.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Are Classmates So Mean to Each Other