When “Take What You Want” Meets Education: Navigating Freedom and Responsibility
The phrase “Take what you want,” they said carries a rebellious charm, evoking images of bold individualism and unfiltered ambition. It’s the kind of statement that might inspire someone to chase dreams without apology or to prioritize personal goals above societal expectations. But when this mantra collides with the world of education—a space built on structure, guidance, and shared knowledge—it raises critical questions: How do we balance the freedom to choose with the responsibility to learn? What happens when students are encouraged to “take what they want” without a roadmap?
Let’s unpack this idea and explore its implications for learners, educators, and lifelong growth.
—
The Allure of Autonomy in Learning
The concept of taking what you want in education isn’t entirely new. Think of Montessori classrooms, where children select activities aligned with their interests, or university electives that let students craft their academic journeys. Autonomy in learning fosters engagement, creativity, and ownership. When students feel they’re in the driver’s seat, they’re more likely to invest effort and retain knowledge.
Take Finland’s education system, often praised for its student-centered approach. Finnish schools emphasize self-directed projects and minimize standardized testing, trusting learners to pursue topics that resonate with them. The result? Consistently high academic performance and a culture that values curiosity over compliance.
But here’s the catch: autonomy works best when paired with support. Telling someone to “take what they want” without scaffolding is like handing them a map without a compass. Students need frameworks to make informed choices—whether that’s mentorship from teachers, access to resources, or exposure to diverse perspectives.
—
The Pitfalls of Unchecked Freedom
Imagine a high school student told to “take what they want” from their curriculum. Without guidance, they might avoid challenging subjects (like math or science) to stick with familiar territory, limiting their growth. Or consider a college freshman selecting courses based solely on trends or peer pressure, only to realize later they’ve missed foundational skills.
This dilemma mirrors a famous thought experiment: the “paradox of choice.” Psychologist Barry Schwartz argues that too many options—without context—can lead to anxiety, indecision, and regret. In education, freedom without direction risks creating learners who are overwhelmed rather than empowered.
History offers cautionary tales, too. The 1960s “free school” movement, which rejected traditional structures in favor of student-led learning, produced mixed outcomes. While some thrived in self-directed environments, others floundered without clear goals or accountability. As one alumnus later reflected, “Freedom felt exciting until I realized I didn’t know what to do with it.”
—
Striking the Balance: Guided Empowerment
So, how do we reconcile the appeal of taking what you want with the need for structure? The answer lies in guided empowerment—a blend of autonomy and mentorship that prepares learners to navigate choices thoughtfully.
1. Curated Options, Not Endless Menus
Instead of overwhelming students with limitless choices, educators can design “pathways” that align with their goals. For example, a middle school might offer themed project weeks (e.g., environmental science, creative writing, or robotics) where students pick a focus but work within a structured framework. This balances exploration with skill-building.
2. Mentorship as a Compass
Teachers and advisors play a crucial role in helping students reflect on their decisions. A college counselor, for instance, might ask probing questions: Why does this course interest you? How does it fit into your long-term vision? These conversations transform impulsive choices into intentional ones.
3. Failure as Feedback
When students “take what they want,” missteps are inevitable—and that’s okay. The key is reframing failure as part of the learning process. A student who struggles in a self-selected internship, for example, gains insights about workplace dynamics and personal strengths.
—
Real-World Lessons: When “Taking What You Want” Works
Let’s look at examples where this philosophy succeeds:
– Micro-credentials and Skill-Based Learning
Platforms like Coursera or LinkedIn Learning allow professionals to “take what they want” from thousands of courses. Learners stack skills (e.g., coding + data analysis) to pivot careers or stay competitive. Here, autonomy thrives because users have clear objectives and access to reviews/ratings.
– Project-Based Learning (PBL)
Schools adopting PBL let students design projects around community issues, like creating a sustainable garden or launching a podcast. While topics are self-chosen, teachers provide rubrics and check-ins to ensure rigor. The result? Passion-driven work that meets academic standards.
– Self-Directed Higher Ed
Institutions like Hampshire College eliminate traditional majors, allowing students to design interdisciplinary programs. However, they pair this freedom with intensive advising to ensure academic coherence. Graduates often credit this model for fostering creativity and adaptability.
—
The Ethical Dimension: What Are We Taking From?
The phrase “Take what you want” often overlooks a critical question: At whose expense? In education, this could manifest as privilege—where well-resourced students access opportunities while others lack basic tools. True empowerment requires addressing systemic barriers.
For instance, open educational resources (OERs)—free textbooks and course materials—help democratize access to knowledge. Similarly, mentorship programs for first-generation college students ensure that autonomy doesn’t become a luxury.
—
Final Thought: Ownership with Intention
The spirit of “Take what you want” isn’t about reckless individualism; it’s about claiming agency over your growth. Whether you’re a student crafting a unique academic path, a teacher designing flexible curricula, or a lifelong learner exploring new skills, the goal is to pair freedom with purpose.
As educator Parker Palmer once wrote, “The soul thrives on paradox.” In education, that means embracing both the courage to choose and the humility to seek guidance. After all, the most rewarding journeys aren’t about taking what you want—they’re about wanting what enriches not just yourself, but the world around you.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When “Take What You Want” Meets Education: Navigating Freedom and Responsibility