When Respect Fades: Navigating a Broken Relationship with Your Department Head
Losing respect for someone in a position of authority—especially someone you once admired—can feel like a emotional earthquake. Whether you’re a teacher, academic professional, or part of an administrative team, working under a department head who’s lost your trust creates a toxic undercurrent in daily life. The phrase “I’m disgusted and have lost all respect for my head of section” isn’t just a complaint; it’s a cry for solutions. Let’s explore how to navigate this painful situation while protecting your well-being and professional integrity.
Understanding the Root of the Problem
First, pinpoint why the respect vanished. Was it a single incident—like unethical behavior or public humiliation—or a series of smaller actions that eroded trust over time? For example, a department head who takes credit for team efforts, dismisses valid concerns, or enforces policies inconsistently can gradually dismantle morale. In education, where collaboration and fairness are pillars, such behavior feels particularly jarring.
Take Maria, a high school science teacher, who discovered her department head altered student grades to boost the school’s ranking. The betrayal wasn’t just about academic dishonesty; it shattered her belief in their shared mission to prioritize student growth. Identifying the “why” helps clarify whether repair is possible or if boundaries need to shift.
The Emotional Toll of Disillusionment
Anger, disappointment, and even grief are normal reactions. You might feel stuck between wanting to speak up and fearing retaliation—especially if the department head holds power over promotions or workload distribution. This emotional limbo can lead to burnout, cynicism, or a loss of passion for work you once loved.
A common mistake is to internalize these feelings, blaming yourself for the situation (“Maybe I’m overreacting?”). But dismissing your emotions only deepens resentment. Acknowledge that your feelings are valid. As psychologist Dr. Emily Carter notes, “Disgust is often a moral response. It signals that someone has crossed a line you deem non-negotiable.”
Practical Steps to Regain Control
1. Assess Objectively: Write down specific incidents that damaged your respect. Avoid generalizations like “They’re unfair” and focus on facts: “They dismissed my proposal without review” or “They mocked a colleague in a meeting.” This clarifies whether the issue is fixable or systemic.
2. Seek Perspective: Talk to trusted peers. Are others feeling similarly, or is this a personal clash? In one university department, three faculty members realized they’d all been excluded from key decisions by their section head. Banding together gave them courage to address the pattern collectively.
3. Communicate with Care: If you decide to confront the issue, frame conversations around impact rather than blame. For example: “When decisions are made without team input, it creates confusion about priorities. Could we discuss a more collaborative process?” This reduces defensiveness while highlighting the problem.
4. Document Everything: Keep records of concerning interactions—emails, meeting notes, or witness accounts. Documentation protects you if the situation escalates and provides clarity if you later involve HR or higher leadership.
When Repair Isn’t Possible
Sometimes, respect can’t be rebuilt. The department head may refuse accountability, or their values may fundamentally clash with yours. In such cases, focus on what you can control:
– Set Boundaries: Limit interactions to what’s necessary. Politely decline meetings that aren’t mandatory, and keep conversations professional and task-focused.
– Invest in Allies: Build relationships with colleagues or mentors outside the department. Their support can counterbalance the negativity.
– Protect Your Passion: Reconnect with what drew you to your role initially. Design a project, mentor a student, or join a committee where your contributions feel valued.
The Bigger Picture: Is This the Right Environment for You?
Chronic disrespect from leadership often reflects deeper institutional issues. Ask yourself: Does this organization align with my values long-term? For some, transferring departments or seeking roles elsewhere becomes the healthiest choice.
Take Alex, a college admissions officer who left after his department head ignored racist remarks from a board member. “Staying felt like complicity,” he said. Within a year, he found a role at an institution that prioritized inclusivity—a decision that reignited his commitment to education.
Final Thoughts
Losing respect for a leader isn’t just a workplace problem; it’s a human one. While the path forward might be messy, it’s also an opportunity to clarify your values, advocate for healthier systems, and reclaim agency. Whether you stay or leave, prioritizing your integrity ensures that someone else’s failures don’t dim your own light. After all, in education—and in life—we grow not by ignoring discomfort, but by navigating it with courage.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Respect Fades: Navigating a Broken Relationship with Your Department Head