When Kids Call the Babysitter “Dad”: Understanding Childhood Attachment
Imagine this: You’re sprawled on the living room floor, building a Lego castle with two giggling boys. The younger one hands you a mismatched brick and says, “Thanks, Dad!” without missing a beat. Your heart skips. Wait—did he just call me Dad? You’re their babysitter, not their parent. Is this normal? Awkward? A sign of something deeper?
Let’s unpack why kids sometimes assign family titles to caregivers and what it means for their emotional world—and yours.
Why Do Kids Mix Up Roles?
Children’s brains are wired to seek safety and connection. When a caregiver—whether a parent, grandparent, or babysitter—provides consistent comfort, play, and care, little ones naturally associate that person with the primal role of “protector.” The word “Dad” isn’t just a label for them; it’s a symbol of trust, familiarity, and love.
Dr. Emily Carter, a child psychologist, explains: “Young kids categorize relationships based on function rather than biology. If you’re fulfilling a nurturing role—making snacks, bandaging scraped knees, reading bedtime stories—their brains may instinctively link you to the ‘parent’ category, even temporarily.”
Is It “Weird”? Let’s Reframe That
The short answer: No, it’s not strange—but it is meaningful. Here’s why:
1. They’re Testing Boundaries
Kids experiment with language constantly. Calling you “Dad” could be a way to gauge your reaction (“Will he laugh? Get upset?”) or explore social dynamics. One boy might do it playfully, while another uses it to process complex feelings about his own family.
2. You’ve Earned Their Trust
For a child to assign a parental title is a compliment. It means they feel secure enough with you to let their guard down—a testament to your bond. As single parent and blogger Jenna Miller writes, “When my son called his daycare teacher ‘Mom’ once, I initially panicked. But then I realized: It meant he felt loved in both places.”
3. They’re Navigating Family Concepts
Children in blended families, foster care, or nontraditional setups often develop flexible definitions of family. A babysitter who spends weekends with them might occupy a unique emotional “slot” that overlaps with parental roles.
How to Respond (Without Awkwardness)
If being called “Dad” makes you uncomfortable—or if you worry about confusing the kids—here’s how to handle it with sensitivity:
– Acknowledge the Emotion, Then Redirect
Say something like, “I love spending time with you too! But remember, I’m your babysitter [or friend/your name]. Let’s call me [preferred term] so everyone’s on the same page.” Keep your tone light to avoid shaming them.
– Collaborate With Parents
Mention the habit casually to the boys’ parents: “Just a heads-up—your youngest called me ‘Dad’ during our last playdate. It’s sweet, but I wanted to check how you’d like me to handle it.” Most parents will appreciate your transparency.
– Use It as a Teaching Moment
For older kids (4+), you might say, “I know families come in all shapes. Who are the special grown-ups in your life?” This opens a dialogue about relationships without dismissing their feelings.
When to Dig Deeper
Occasionally, a child repeatedly calling a non-parent “Dad” signals unresolved emotions. Watch for:
– Recent family changes (divorce, a parent’s absence, a new sibling)
– Expressions of longing (“I wish you were my dad every day.”)
– Anxiety when separating from you
In these cases, gently ask open-ended questions: “What makes ‘Dad’ a good word to use?” or “What’s your favorite thing about your family?” Share observations with parents so they can address underlying needs.
The Bigger Picture: Kids Need “Village” Figures
Historically, children were raised by extended networks—aunts, neighbors, elders. Modern life often isolates families, making babysitters, coaches, or teachers critical “villagers.” When kids bestow familial titles, it reflects a healthy instinct to expand their circle of support.
As author Brené Brown writes, “Connection is why we’re here.” Whether you’re “Dad,” “Mr. Alex,” or “The Snack Wizard,” what matters is that you’ve become a safe harbor in their world.
Final Thoughts
So, is it weird to be called “Dad” as a babysitter? Not at all. It’s a quirky, heartfelt reminder that you’ve created a space where these boys feel seen and cherished. Embrace the sweetness of the moment—while gently guiding them toward language that respects everyone’s roles.
After all, the fact that they want to call you “Dad” might be the best review your babysitting skills could ever get.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Kids Call the Babysitter “Dad”: Understanding Childhood Attachment