When “Get an Evaluation” Isn’t the Best First Step for Your Child’s Struggles
You see your child wrestling with schoolwork, falling behind peers, or showing signs of frustration that break your heart. You muster the courage to share your concerns – maybe with a teacher, a family member, or in an online parenting group. Often, the immediate, well-intentioned advice echoes back: “You need to get them evaluated.”
While securing a comprehensive evaluation is frequently a vital piece of understanding and supporting a child with learning differences or developmental needs, jumping straight to “just get a full evaluation” as the very first step can sometimes be counterproductive, overwhelming, and frankly, the worst place to start. Here’s why, and what a more effective initial approach might look like.
Why “Just Get an Evaluation” Can Backfire:
1. It Overwhelms Parents: Hearing this directive often comes when parents are already anxious and confused. The prospect of navigating complex medical, psychological, or educational systems, understanding jargon, finding qualified professionals, dealing with potential costs or insurance hurdles, and facing the unknown can feel paralyzing. It adds significant stress to an already stressful situation.
2. It Implies Complexity Before Gathering Basic Clues: Suggesting a formal evaluation immediately frames the child’s struggles through the lens of a significant underlying disorder or disability. While this might be the case, it overlooks simpler explanations that should be explored first. It’s like calling the structural engineer before checking if a fuse is blown.
3. It Skips Crucial Observation & Information Gathering: A formal evaluation provides a snapshot, but valuable insights come from sustained, careful observation in the child’s natural environments (home and school). Rushing to testing can bypass this essential step of understanding the specifics of the struggle: When exactly does it happen? Under what conditions? What seems to help, even a little?
4. It Might Not Be Actionable Right Away: Even after an evaluation, results take time to process, reports need interpretation, and implementing recommendations (like an IEP or therapy) can be a lengthy bureaucratic process. Parents left waiting during this period often feel even more helpless, having skipped simpler strategies they could have tried immediately.
5. It Can Cause Unnecessary Anxiety for the Child: While evaluations are designed to be child-friendly, the process of being tested by unfamiliar adults in unfamiliar settings can be intimidating for a child already struggling. Starting with less intrusive strategies respects the child’s comfort zone.
A More Effective First Step: Mindful Observation & Targeted Action
Instead of leaping straight to the evaluation stage, consider this more measured, empowering initial approach:
1. Observe Deeply and Specifically: Don’t just note “struggling with reading.” What is the struggle? Is it decoding words (sounding them out)? Fluency (reading speed and smoothness)? Comprehension? Does it happen with all texts or certain types? When does your child seem most frustrated? Keep a simple log noting dates, times, specific tasks, behaviors, and any environmental factors (tired, hungry, noisy room).
2. Communicate Clearly with the Teacher: Schedule a focused conversation. Share your observations calmly and ask for theirs. What specific academic or behavioral challenges do they see in the classroom? How does it compare to peers? What strategies have they tried? What seems to work, even partially? Are the struggles consistent across subjects or situations? This collaboration is gold.
3. Try Simple, Evidence-Based Strategies at Home: Based on your observations and the teacher’s input, implement small interventions:
Reading Struggles: Try short, focused reading sessions with high-interest books. Use audiobooks paired with physical text. Break down multi-step directions.
Focus/Attention: Experiment with structured breaks during homework, reducing distractions, using visual timers, chunking tasks into smaller steps.
Organization: Implement simple routines (e.g., backpack check before bed), use visual schedules or checklists, provide designated homework spaces.
Emotional Regulation: Practice simple calming techniques (deep breathing, counting), name feelings, offer quiet spaces for decompression.
4. Track the Impact: Did the small changes make any difference? Did something work well for a short period? Did something make it worse? Your log becomes crucial here. This data reveals patterns and shows what the child does respond to.
5. Build Your Knowledge Base: While observing and trialing strategies, start learning. Look for reputable resources (like understood.org, Child Mind Institute, LD Online) about common learning challenges. Understand terms like dyslexia, dyscalculia, ADHD, executive function, etc., not to self-diagnose, but to understand potential frameworks and see if descriptions resonate with your observations.
So When Is “Get an Evaluation” the Right Step?
This mindful approach doesn’t mean avoiding evaluations forever. It means building a stronger foundation for when an evaluation is necessary. Consider moving towards a formal evaluation when:
Simple Interventions Aren’t Enough: You’ve tried consistent, targeted strategies at home and school over several weeks or months with minimal or no progress.
Concerns Persist or Intensify: The struggles continue significantly impacting the child’s academic progress, social interactions, or emotional well-being.
Observations Strongly Suggest a Specific Need: Your detailed observations and research align strongly with known learning or developmental profiles.
You Need Formal Documentation: Accessing specific school-based services (like an IEP or 504 Plan) or certain therapies often requires a formal diagnosis or comprehensive evaluation report.
You Feel Stuck and Need Expert Insight: When you’ve gathered data and tried strategies but still feel lost about the underlying cause and best path forward.
The Bottom Line: Start with Understanding, Not Testing
Telling an anxious parent to “just get a full evaluation” often overlooks the emotional landscape and bypasses foundational steps. Starting instead with careful observation, open communication with teachers, trying manageable strategies, and informed learning empowers parents. It transforms them from passive recipients of directives into active, informed advocates who understand their child’s unique profile before entering the evaluation process. This approach leads to more effective evaluations when they are needed, reduces parental overwhelm, and ensures that the path to support is built on a solid understanding of the child, not just a test result. The goal isn’t to avoid evaluations, but to ensure they happen at the right time and for the right reasons, maximizing their usefulness in helping your child thrive. Take a breath, observe, connect, and try the small steps first. You might be surprised by what you learn.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When “Get an Evaluation” Isn’t the Best First Step for Your Child’s Struggles