When Classroom Movies Spark Uncomfortable Conversations
The final day of seventh grade is supposed to feel like a victory lap—a time for signing yearbooks, swapping summer plans, and enjoying low-stakes classroom activities. For my science class, that meant watching Up, the animated adventure about a widower fulfilling his lifelong dream. But what started as a lighthearted movie day turned into an unexpected lesson about history, assumptions, and the power of a single question.
Lamiyah, the girl who sat next to me, had a reputation. Teachers called her “spirited”; students called her a troublemaker. She’d crack jokes during quiet work time, challenge instructions she deemed unfair, and ask questions that made adults pause. That day, as Carl Fredricksen’s house floated across the screen, Lamiyah raised her hand. Not waiting to be called on, she blurted, “Hey, Ms. Collins? Did you know some old couple adopted Black kids just to make ’em pick cotton?”
The room froze. A few kids giggled nervously. Ms. Collins paused the film. For a split second, her face mirrored the mix of shock and confusion we all felt. Then, in a calm voice, she asked, “Lamiyah, where did you hear that?”
What followed wasn’t a reprimand or a dismissal but a conversation. Lamiyah explained she’d read online about a couple in the 1950s accused of exploiting adopted children for labor. Ms. Collins acknowledged the dark history of child labor and systemic racism in America, tying it to the film’s themes of loss and resilience. She didn’t shame Lamiyah for interrupting or shut down the topic. Instead, she asked us: Why might someone share a story like that during a movie? What does it mean to question what we see—or don’t see—in stories?
—
When “Troublemakers” Teach Us to Look Deeper
Lamiyah’s comment felt jarring because it clashed with the mood of the scene. Yet her question revealed something classrooms often miss: Kids notice gaps in narratives. The movie Up opens with a poignant montage about Carl’s life, but like many stories, it doesn’t address every societal issue. Lamiyah’s interruption, though awkward, highlighted how media shapes—and sometimes sidesteps—our understanding of history.
After class, I asked Lamiyah why she’d brought it up. “People forget stuff,” she shrugged. “Like, yeah, the movie’s sad, but real life’s sadder sometimes.” Her bluntness masked a sharper point: Stories aren’t neutral. They reflect the storyteller’s choices. By questioning those choices, even clumsily, she pushed us to think critically about what gets left out.
—
How Teachers Can Turn Awkward Moments into Learning
Ms. Collins’ response was a masterclass in navigating uncomfortable topics. She could’ve dismissed Lamiyah’s comment as off-topic or inflammatory. Instead, she:
1. Validated the concern: By asking Lamiyah to elaborate, she signaled that student voices matter, even when they disrupt plans.
2. Provided context: She linked the comment to broader historical patterns without oversimplifying.
3. Engaged the class: Turning the moment into a discussion encouraged empathy. (“Why might someone share that story? How do we balance enjoyment of media with critical thinking?”)
This approach didn’t “solve” the issue, but it transformed a potential conflict into a shared learning experience.
—
Why “Troublemakers” Are Often Misunderstood
Lamiyah’s label as a troublemaker says more about our comfort zones than her intent. Students who challenge norms or ask uncomfortable questions are often seen as disruptive, not insightful. But curiosity isn’t always polite. When Lamiyah interrupted Up, she wasn’t trying to ruin the movie; she wanted us to see beyond the screen.
Research shows that “difficult” students often feel disconnected from school when their perspectives aren’t acknowledged. Lamiyah’s willingness to speak up—even awkwardly—suggests she was invested in the class, not indifferent.
—
Lessons Beyond the Last Day of School
That afternoon stuck with me because it revealed how classrooms can be spaces for messy, important conversations. Here’s what I took from it:
– Critical thinking isn’t tidy: Questions that challenge the status quo will feel uncomfortable. That’s okay.
– Context matters: Ms. Collins didn’t just address Lamiyah’s comment—she connected it to larger themes, helping us see why it was relevant.
– Every student has a story: Labeling kids as “troublemakers” risks silencing voices that could teach us something vital.
Years later, I ran into Lamiyah at a coffee shop. We laughed about the Up incident. “I was just so bored of movie days,” she admitted. “But Ms. Collins actually listened. That kinda blew my mind.”
Sometimes, the most enduring lessons aren’t in the curriculum. They’re in the moments when someone dares to ask, “Hey, did you know…?”—and a teacher dares to lean in instead of looking away.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Classroom Movies Spark Uncomfortable Conversations