What Would You Teach? The Art of Choosing in Unplanned Moments
Picture this: It’s the middle of a meticulously planned lesson on fractions. You’re deep into demonstrating equivalent fractions when a student near the window suddenly gasps, points outside, and exclaims, “Look! A hawk just caught a squirrel!” Instantly, twenty heads swivel towards the window, fractions utterly forgotten. The carefully constructed learning environment dissolves into a buzz of excitement and murmurs about nature, predators, and perhaps a little squeamishness.
The question hangs in the suddenly charged air: What would you teach in this situation?
This scenario, or variations of it – a heated argument erupting between students, an unexpected current event dominating the news cycle, a poignant question arising from a shared text – happens constantly in classrooms. These are the unplanned, often chaotic moments where the script gets tossed aside. What we choose to do next isn’t just about regaining control; it’s a profound teaching decision in itself. It reveals our priorities, our adaptability, and ultimately, what we believe matters most for our students’ growth.
So, how do we navigate this crucial choice? It’s rarely a simple binary of “stick to the plan” or “abandon ship completely.” It’s about reading the room, assessing the moment’s potential, and making an intentional, often split-second, decision about where the richest learning lies right now.
1. Anchoring to Core Goals (But Maybe Not the Ones You Planned):
The first instinct might be frustration – the fractions lesson was important! And it still is. But pause for a second. What are the deeper skills or concepts underlying your planned lesson? Critical thinking? Observation? Problem-solving? Connection-making? The hawk incident, while disruptive, offers a potent opportunity to practice these very skills, just applied to a different, highly engaging context.
What could you teach? You could pivot towards a mini-inquiry: “What observations can we make about predator-prey relationships right now?” “What adaptations might help the hawk hunt successfully?” “How does energy transfer work in an ecosystem?” This leverages the spontaneous engagement to practice observation, questioning, and scientific reasoning – core goals that transcend any single lesson plan.
2. Prioritizing Student Needs & Well-being:
Sometimes the unplanned moment isn’t exciting wildlife but a conflict, emotional distress, or a question revealing deep anxiety or confusion. Ignoring it to plough on with Shakespeare sends a powerful, negative message: “Your feelings and experiences are less important than the curriculum.” Teaching isn’t just about content; it’s fundamentally about human connection and development.
What could you teach? You teach empathy. You teach conflict resolution. You teach emotional vocabulary and regulation. You create a safe space. This might mean facilitating a respectful conversation about the argument, acknowledging the student’s anxiety sparked by a news event, or simply offering a brief moment to process difficult feelings (“It sounds like that news about the storm is worrying some people. Let’s take two minutes to write down or share one feeling it brings up.”). The lesson here is about social-emotional learning and community building – arguably the most vital foundation for all other learning.
3. Cultivating Critical Thinking & Real-World Connection:
When a major news event breaks, or a student asks a complex, off-topic question rooted in current affairs (“Why are they fighting in that country, Miss?”), it presents a golden, albeit challenging, opportunity. These moments connect the sometimes abstract world of the classroom to the messy, complex reality students inhabit.
What could you teach? You teach information literacy. You teach how to ask clarifying questions. You teach perspective-taking and the dangers of oversimplification. Instead of delivering an instant opinion or shutting it down, you might say: “That’s a huge and important question. Let’s unpack it. What do we already know? What reliable sources could we look at to understand different viewpoints? What are some questions we still need answers to?” This teaches the process of grappling with complexity far more than any pre-packaged answer could.
4. Seizing the “Teachable Moment” for Social Awareness & Ethics:
Moments involving exclusion, bias, fairness, or ethical dilemmas (even seemingly small ones during group work) demand attention. Brushing them aside implicitly condones the behavior or misses a chance to build a more just classroom culture.
What could you teach? You teach about fairness and equity. You teach about standing up for others. You teach respectful communication. You teach examining our own assumptions. This involves facilitating a discussion about why a comment was hurtful, analyzing the fairness of a group decision-making process, or exploring the ethical implications of a scenario in a story. The lesson is about citizenship and ethical reasoning.
5. Modeling Adaptability and Curiosity:
Perhaps the most powerful lesson of all is how you, the teacher, respond. Do you get flustered and rigid? Or do you demonstrate calm flexibility and a willingness to explore? Your reaction teaches students how to handle the unexpected, how to shift gears, and that learning isn’t confined to a pre-ordained box.
What could you teach? You teach resilience. You teach intellectual curiosity (“Wow, that is fascinating! Let’s see where this takes us for a few minutes.”). You teach that it’s okay not to have all the answers (“That’s a great question; I don’t know the full answer. Let’s find out together.”). You teach that learning is a dynamic, responsive process.
Making the Choice: The Pause & Assess Protocol
There’s no magic formula, but a quick mental checklist can help:
1. Pause: Take a breath. Resist the panic reflex.
2. Assess the Moment: What happened? Why is it significant? What’s the emotional temperature? What learning potential does it hold?
3. Connect to Core Values/Goals: Does this moment touch on critical thinking, empathy, safety, ethics, or core concepts? How?
4. Evaluate Urgency & Depth: Is this a fleeting distraction or something profound needing attention? Can it be addressed briefly or does it merit deeper exploration?
5. Make the Intentional Choice: Decide: Stick firmly to the plan? Briefly acknowledge and redirect? Pivot significantly? Abandon the plan entirely?
6. Communicate the Shift: Explain your reasoning to students if needed (“This seems really important to explore right now because…” or “We need to address this quickly to make sure everyone feels safe, then we’ll get back to…”).
The Transformative Power of the Unplanned
The art of choosing “what to teach in this situation” lies at the heart of responsive and impactful teaching. It moves us beyond mere curriculum delivery into the realm of shaping learners who are critical thinkers, empathetic citizens, adaptable problem-solvers, and ethically aware individuals. While fractions are essential, the lessons learned when a hawk flies by, a conflict erupts, or a difficult question hangs in the air often resonate far more deeply, precisely because they are unscripted and real. These are the moments where we don’t just teach a subject; we teach how to be human in a complex world. By embracing the challenge of the unexpected, we transform interruptions into some of the most valuable learning opportunities we’ll ever have.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Would You Teach