What Have You Tried to Help Your Child with Their Emotions, and How Well Did It Work? Navigating the Messy, Beautiful Journey
Parenting often feels like navigating uncharted waters, especially when those waters involve the powerful currents of a child’s emotions. What have you tried to help your child with their emotions, and how well did it work? If your answer involves a mix of successes, failures, moments of pure frustration, and flashes of insight, welcome to the club. Supporting our kids emotionally is one of the most challenging yet crucial parts of raising resilient, empathetic humans. Let’s explore some common strategies parents try, the real-world results, and what we can learn from them.
The Well-Intentioned (But Often Flawed) First Responses:
1. “Don’t Cry!” or “It’s Not a Big Deal!” (The Dismissal):
What You Tried: Seeing your child upset over something that seems trivial (like a broken cookie), you instinctively try to minimize the pain to make it stop.
How Well Did It Work? Usually, not well at all. While it might work momentarily for a very minor hiccup, more often it backfires. The message received is: “Your feelings aren’t valid,” or “I can’t handle your big feelings.” This often escalates the tantrum or teaches kids to bottle up emotions, leading to bigger explosions later. It rarely builds emotional awareness or coping skills.
2. The Distraction Tactic:
What You Tried: “Look, a shiny toy!” or “Let’s go get ice cream!” when the tears start flowing.
How Well Did It Work? This can be a useful tool in the moment for toddlers or preschoolers experiencing overwhelming frustration or minor bumps. It provides a break. However, relying on it heavily teaches kids to avoid difficult feelings rather than process them. The underlying emotion doesn’t get addressed, potentially surfacing later. It works as a temporary band-aid, not a long-term strategy.
3. Logical Reasoning During the Storm:
What You Tried: Your child is mid-meltdown because their tower collapsed. You launch into a calm, logical explanation of physics or the concept of rebuilding. “See, honey, the blocks weren’t balanced…”
How Well Did It Work? When emotions are high, especially for young children, the logical prefrontal cortex goes offline. Your well-reasoned arguments literally cannot be processed. This often leads to increased frustration for both parties – the child feels unheard, and you feel ignored. It rarely resolves the immediate emotional crisis.
4. Threats or Punishments for “Bad” Emotions:
What You Tried: “Stop screaming or you’re going to timeout!” or “If you don’t calm down right now, no screen time!”
How Well Did It Work? This might suppress the expression of emotion temporarily out of fear. However, it doesn’t teach healthy emotional regulation. It reinforces the idea that certain feelings (anger, sadness, frustration) are “bad” or punishable, increasing shame and confusion. It damages the connection between parent and child.
Shifting Gears: Strategies That Tend to Work Better (But Require Patience!)
1. Validating and Naming Feelings:
What You Try: “Wow, you look really frustrated that your tower fell down.” “It’s so disappointing when we can’t go to the park, huh? You feel sad.”
How Well Does It Work? This is often transformative, though it takes practice. Naming the emotion helps children understand their inner world. Validation (“It’s okay to feel angry/sad”) tells them their feelings are acceptable. It doesn’t mean you condone behavior (like hitting), but you accept the feeling itself. This builds emotional vocabulary and self-awareness. Results? Often calms the initial storm faster as the child feels understood. Long-term, it fosters emotional intelligence. Works well across ages.
2. Staying Present and Offering Comfort (Co-Regulation):
What You Try: Instead of talking them out of the feeling, you get down on their level. You offer a hug (if they accept it), sit quietly nearby, or use a calm voice: “I’m right here. It’s tough.”
How Well Does It Work? Young children especially rely on the calm nervous system of a trusted adult to help regulate their own. Your calm presence is a powerful anchor. This builds deep security and models regulation. It might not stop the crying instantly, but it provides essential safety. Very effective for younger children and foundational for older kids learning to self-soothe.
3. Teaching Simple Coping Skills:
What You Try: After the intense emotion subsides, introduce tools: “When we feel angry, we can take deep belly breaths like this,” “Let’s squeeze this stress ball,” “Would drawing how you feel help?” Practice these when they are calm.
How Well Does It Work? This is where the real learning happens. Kids need concrete strategies. Teaching breathing techniques, using calming jars, creating a “cozy corner,” or having a physical outlet (like jumping jacks) gives them agency. Results vary – some tools click immediately, others take consistent practice. Persistence pays off, building their toolkit over time. Essential for older toddlers through teens.
4. Problem-Solving Collaboratively (Once Calm):
What You Try: After validating and helping them calm down, ask: “What could we do next time?” or “How can we fix this together?”
How Well Does It Work? This empowers children and teaches critical thinking. Instead of imposing solutions, you guide them to find their own (with support). It fosters responsibility and resilience. Works beautifully with preschoolers and up, turning emotional moments into learning opportunities.
The Reality Check: Why “Working” Isn’t Always Linear
It’s crucial to remember that emotional learning is a marathon, not a sprint. What have you tried to help your child with their emotions, and how well did it work? Even the best strategies won’t yield perfect results every time. Here’s why:
Development Matters: A strategy that works for your 8-year-old might be useless for your 3-year-old (and vice-versa). Tailor your approach.
Temperament is Key: Some kids are naturally more intense or sensitive. What calms one child might overwhelm another.
Context is Everything: Hunger, fatigue, overstimulation, or underlying stress (e.g., starting school) make emotional regulation harder for everyone. Don’t judge a strategy’s effectiveness solely on a “bad day.”
Your Own State: If you’re stressed, overwhelmed, or triggered, it’s incredibly hard to respond calmly. Self-care isn’t selfish; it’s essential for effective parenting. Taking a moment to breathe yourself before reacting is a valid strategy!
Progress Over Perfection: Success isn’t the absence of meltdowns; it’s seeing your child gradually learn to identify their feelings, use coping strategies sometimes, and recover a little faster. Celebrate small wins.
Moving Forward: It’s About Connection and Learning
Reflecting on what you’ve tried to help your child with their emotions, and how well it worked isn’t about tallying failures. It’s about gathering data and refining your approach. The core ingredients for success remain consistent:
1. Connection First: Prioritize feeling understood and safe over immediate behavioral compliance.
2. Validation is Key: Acknowledge the feeling before addressing the behavior.
3. Model What You Teach: Manage your own reactions calmly (as best you can!).
4. Teach Skills Proactively: Don’t wait for a crisis to introduce breathing or problem-solving.
5. Be Patient and Persistent: Emotional intelligence takes years to develop.
The journey of helping our children navigate their emotional world is messy, humbling, and profoundly important. Some days you’ll nail it; other days, you’ll wish for a do-over. What matters is showing up, trying, learning, and offering that steady, loving presence. The fact that you’re asking what have you tried to help your child with their emotions, and how well did it work? means you’re already on the right path. Keep going.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Have You Tried to Help Your Child with Their Emotions, and How Well Did It Work