“What Do You Think of This Explanation?” – Why This Question Matters More Than You Realize
We’ve all been there. Someone shares an idea, explains a concept, or walks through a problem-solving process, then turns to the group and asks: “What do you guys think of this explanation?”
At first glance, it seems like a simple request for feedback. But dig deeper, and you’ll uncover a powerful tool for learning, collaboration, and growth—both in classrooms and everyday life. Let’s explore why this question is so impactful, how to respond to it constructively, and why it’s a cornerstone of effective communication.
—
Why Asking for Opinions About Explanations Matters
When someone asks for feedback on their explanation, they’re not just seeking validation. They’re inviting others to:
1. Clarify misunderstandings (Did everyone interpret the explanation the same way?)
2. Identify gaps (Are there missing pieces in the logic or facts?)
3. Spark deeper thinking (Can the group build on the idea together?)
In educational settings, this question transforms passive listeners into active participants. For example, a teacher explaining photosynthesis might pause and ask students, “Does this make sense? How would you explain it to a friend?” This shifts the dynamic from a lecture to a dialogue, encouraging students to process information critically.
—
How to Evaluate an Explanation (Without Sounding Like a Critic)
Not all explanations are created equal. Some are crystal clear; others leave us more confused than before. Here’s how to assess an explanation thoughtfully:
1. Check for clarity.
Ask yourself: “Can I summarize this in my own words?” If the explanation relies heavily on jargon or abstract terms, it might need simplification. For instance, explaining “gravity” as “the force that pulls apples toward the Earth” is more accessible than citing mathematical formulas.
2. Look for logical flow.
A strong explanation connects the dots. Imagine a history teacher describing the causes of World War I. If they jump from alliances to trench warfare without linking the two, learners might struggle to see the big picture.
3. Assess relevance.
Does the explanation address the why behind the what? A math tutor solving an equation step-by-step is helpful, but explaining why those steps work (e.g., “We’re isolating the variable to find its value”) helps students apply the logic to new problems.
4. Gauge engagement.
Ever zoned out during a monotonous lecture? Effective explanations balance detail with storytelling. A science teacher comparing mitochondria to “powerhouses” isn’t just being cute—they’re creating mental hooks to make the concept memorable.
—
How to Respond Constructively (Even If You Disagree)
The phrase “What do you think?” can feel intimidating, especially if you’re unsure or disagree with the explanation. Here’s how to navigate this gracefully:
Start with curiosity.
Instead of saying, “That’s wrong,” try: “Could you walk me through how you reached that conclusion?” This invites the speaker to reflect and lets you pinpoint where the confusion began.
Use the “Sandwich Method.”
Frame feedback positively:
– “I like how you connected X and Y.”
– “I’m curious about the role of Z—could we explore that more?”
– “This makes me think about [related idea]. What do you think?”
Acknowledge subjectivity.
Sometimes, disagreements stem from different perspectives. For example, debating the “best” way to solve a programming problem might reveal multiple valid approaches. Saying, “I see it differently, but your method works well for [specific scenario],” fosters respect.
—
Real-World Applications: From Classrooms to Coffee Chats
This simple question isn’t limited to academics. It’s a life skill:
– At work: A colleague presents a project timeline. Asking, “How does this account for potential delays?” improves planning.
– In relationships: A friend vents about a conflict. Responding, “What part of their actions upset you most?” helps them reflect.
– Online learning: In discussion forums, comments like “Can you elaborate on Point 3?” deepen conversations.
Even controversial topics benefit from this approach. Imagine discussing climate change. Instead of arguing, asking, “What evidence shapes your view?” shifts the focus from winning to understanding.
—
The Risks of Not Asking for Feedback
When explanations go unchallenged, misunderstandings fossilize. Consider these scenarios:
– A student nods along to a confusing lesson, only to fail the exam.
– A team assumes they’re aligned on a project, only to miss the deadline due to miscommunication.
– A social media post spreads misinformation because no one asked, “Wait—is that accurate?”
Silence isn’t golden when it comes to learning. Encouraging questions builds a culture where clarity and critical thinking thrive.
—
Final Thoughts: Embrace the Awkwardness
Asking “What do you think?” requires vulnerability. You’re admitting your explanation might be flawed or incomplete. But that’s where growth happens.
Next time someone poses this question—or you do—remember: It’s not about being “right.” It’s about creating a space where ideas evolve through collaboration. Whether you’re explaining quantum physics or why your favorite movie is a masterpiece, inviting others into the conversation makes knowledge richer, sharper, and more human.
So, what do you think of this explanation? Let’s keep the dialogue going.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » “What Do You Think of This Explanation