Unlocking Better Answers: How to Ask for Suggestions Online (Even When You’re Unsure)
We’ve all been there. You’re stuck, confused, or simply need a fresh perspective. You open your favorite forum, group chat, or social media app, type out a quick plea: “Hi, can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?” and hit send. You wait… and maybe wait some more. Often, the silence is deafening, or the responses you do get feel generic, unhelpful, or miss the mark entirely. Why does this happen? And how can you transform that vague cry for help into a magnet for genuinely useful suggestions?
The problem isn’t that people don’t want to help. It’s that your question, phrased like this, makes helping incredibly difficult. It’s like standing in a vast marketplace shouting, “Sell me something good!” Vendors won’t know where to start. Are you hungry? Need clothes? Looking for tools? Your broad request lacks the essential details helpers need to provide relevant, actionable advice.
Why “Hi, can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?” Often Falls Flat:
1. The Mystery of “This”: What is “this”? Without context, potential helpers are completely in the dark. Is it a broken sink, a confusing software bug, a relationship dilemma, a recipe gone wrong? The possibilities are endless.
2. Lack of Specificity: Even if someone guesses the general area, they need specifics. “Abt this” could mean anything from “how do I fix it?” to “should I replace it?” or “is this normal?”
3. No Clear Goal: What kind of suggestion are you actually seeking? Advice? Recommendations for products or services? Technical solutions? Creative ideas? Helpers need a target.
4. Low Effort Question = Low Effort Answers (or None): A very brief, vague question can signal to others that you haven’t put much thought into the problem yourself. People are often more inclined to help those who demonstrate they’ve tried to help themselves first.
5. Wrong Audience? If you post this in a large, general group, the people best equipped to answer might never see it, buried under other content.
Transforming Your Vague Ask into a Suggestion Magnet:
The good news is that with a little more effort upfront, you can dramatically increase your chances of getting the helpful, specific suggestions you crave. Think of it as giving your helpers the tools they need to assist you effectively.
1. Provide ESSENTIAL Context (What is “THIS”?):
Clearly Define the Subject: Instead of “this,” state the exact thing you need suggestions about. “Hi, can anyone give me a suggestion about fixing a leaky kitchen faucet?” or “Hi, looking for suggestions on budgeting apps for freelancers?” or “Stuck! Need suggestions for vegetarian meal prep ideas that are kid-friendly.” Instantly, your audience knows the playing field.
Share Relevant Background: Briefly explain the situation. Why are you asking? What led up to this? For the faucet: “It started dripping yesterday after I replaced the washer, but it’s worse now.” For the app: “I track invoices manually in spreadsheets but need something to automate reminders and tax estimates.” For the meals: “My 5-year-old is suddenly rejecting anything green!”
2. Be Crystal Clear About the Type of Suggestion You Need:
What’s Your Goal? Are you looking for:
Product/Service Recommendations? (e.g., “Suggestions for a reliable plumber in downtown?” or “Best noise-cancelling headphones under $100?”)
Step-by-Step Solutions? (e.g., “Suggestions on how to troubleshoot this Python error message: ‘IndexError: list index out of range’?”)
Creative Ideas/Brainstorming? (e.g., “Suggestions for unique themes for a 10-year-old’s birthday party?”)
Advice/Options? (e.g., “Suggestions on whether I should repair my 8-year-old laptop or just replace it?”)
Specify Constraints: Mention any limitations! Budget (“under $50”), location (“in Seattle”), time (“needed by Friday”), dietary needs (“nut-free”), technical skill level (“beginner-friendly”), etc. This filters out irrelevant suggestions immediately.
3. Show You’ve Tried (The Magic of “I’ve Already…”):
Briefly mentioning what you’ve already attempted shows initiative and prevents people from suggesting things you already know don’t work. “I’ve already tried tightening the connections under the sink.” “I looked at Mint and YNAB but found their interfaces overwhelming.” “I’ve offered dips and hidden veggies in sauces, but she notices!” This also helps helpers diagnose the problem better.
4. Target the Right Audience:
Post your question in a space frequented by people knowledgeable about your specific topic. A gardening forum is better for plant advice than a general neighborhood group. A programming subreddit is better for code errors than Facebook. Find the niche where experts hang out.
Putting It All Together: From Vague to Valuable
Instead of:
> “Hi, can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?”
Try something like:
> “Hi plumbing experts! My kitchen faucet (single-handle Moen) started leaking heavily after I replaced the cartridge yesterday ([maybe include a photo?]). I’ve tightened all the connections under the sink – still leaking! Looking for suggestions on what might be wrong or if I need a different cartridge model? Trying to DIY fix if possible!”
Or:
> “Calling all freelance designers! I currently track project time and invoices in separate Google Sheets – it’s getting messy. Looking for app suggestions specifically for freelancers to combine time tracking, invoicing, and maybe basic expense tracking. Must work offline sometimes! Tried Harvest but found it pricey for just me. Budget ~$15/month.”
Or:
> “Parenting community help! My 5-year-old has declared war on anything green or resembling a vegetable (except carrots, miraculously). Looking for creative vegetarian meal prep suggestions that are seriously stealthy or visually fun enough to get past the blockade! I’ve tried blending spinach into smoothies (rejected) and hiding lentils in sauce (detected!). Need lunchbox and dinner ideas!”
The Payoff: Better Answers & Stronger Communities
Taking these extra steps isn’t just about you getting better answers (though you absolutely will!). It’s about respecting the time and expertise of the community you’re asking. Clear, well-defined questions:
Get Answered Faster: Experts can quickly identify if they have relevant knowledge.
Attract Higher Quality Responses: People can provide specific, actionable advice tailored to your situation.
Spark More Useful Discussions: Others with similar problems can benefit from the detailed answers your question generates.
Build Your Credibility: Showing you’ve put thought into your question makes others more likely to engage seriously with you.
The next time you feel the urge to type “Hi, can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?”, pause. Take those extra two minutes. Define “this.” Explain your situation. State what kind of help you need. Share what you’ve tried. You’ll transform your plea from a whisper lost in the digital wind into a clear signal that attracts the perfect suggestions to guide you forward. The difference in the responses you receive will be remarkable – suddenly, the online community becomes the powerful resource it was always meant to be.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Unlocking Better Answers: How to Ask for Suggestions Online (Even When You’re Unsure)