Understanding the Controversy Around Early Honorable Dismissal in Philippine Schools
In recent years, a concerning trend has emerged in some Philippine educational institutions: students being granted an Honorable Dismissal even before classes officially begin. This practice, reportedly justified by claims of academic failure, has sparked debates among educators, parents, and students. But how can a student “fail” before the academic term starts? Let’s unpack this issue and explore its implications for the education system.
What Is an Honorable Dismissal?
An Honorable Dismissal is a document issued by a school to certify that a student has left the institution in good standing. It’s typically requested when transferring to another school or pursuing opportunities that require proof of clean academic and disciplinary records. Traditionally, this status is reserved for students who voluntarily withdraw due to personal reasons, health issues, or family obligations—not for those who fail to meet academic requirements.
However, reports suggest that some institutions are misusing this process. Students are allegedly being pressured to request an Honorable Dismissal under the pretext of “failing” before classes even start. This raises critical questions about fairness, transparency, and the ethical responsibilities of schools.
The Problem with Premature “Failure”
The core issue lies in the logic of labeling a student as “failed” before they’ve had a chance to attend classes, complete assignments, or take exams. In normal circumstances, academic performance is evaluated over time through quizzes, projects, and participation. Declaring failure prematurely undermines the purpose of education as a growth-oriented process.
Why would schools engage in such practices? Here are some possible motivations:
1. Inflating Institutional Performance Metrics: Schools with strict academic reputations might attempt to weed out students they perceive as “risky” early on. By removing these students before the term starts, they avoid potential drops in their pass rates or rankings.
2. Administrative Loopholes: Some institutions may lack clear policies for handling enrollment disputes or student withdrawals, leading to ad-hoc decisions that harm learners.
3. Financial or Regulatory Pressures: In rare cases, schools facing accreditation issues or financial strain might misuse dismissals to reduce enrollment numbers without formal expulsion processes.
Impact on Students and Families
The consequences of this practice are far-reaching:
– Unfair Academic Records: A premature Honorable Dismissal linked to “failure” creates a misleading paper trail. Transferring students might face skepticism from new schools or employers, even if the dismissal was unjustified.
– Psychological Stress: Being labeled a failure before proving oneself can damage a student’s self-esteem and motivation. Education should empower learners, not discourage them at the first hurdle.
– Financial Loss: Families invest time and money in enrollment fees, materials, and transportation. A sudden dismissal wastes these resources and disrupts future plans.
Legal and Ethical Gray Areas
Philippine education laws, including the Enhanced Basic Education Act of 2013 and policies from the Commission on Higher Education (CHED), emphasize students’ rights to due process. Schools are obligated to provide clear evaluation criteria and opportunities for students to improve. Issuing dismissals based on hypothetical failure likely violates these principles.
Moreover, the lack of standardized guidelines for Honorable Dismissals creates ambiguity. While CHED provides general rules, enforcement varies across institutions. This inconsistency opens the door to exploitation.
Steps to Address the Issue
To protect students and uphold academic integrity, stakeholders must take action:
1. Strengthen Oversight Mechanisms
Regulatory bodies like CHED and the Department of Education (DepEd) should conduct regular audits of dismissal cases. Schools found misusing Honorable Dismissals should face penalties, including loss of accreditation.
2. Clarify Policies for Withdrawals
Institutions must publish transparent criteria for Honorable Dismissals. For example, deadlines for voluntary withdrawals should be clearly stated, and “failure” should never apply to students who haven’t participated in coursework.
3. Empower Students and Parents
Families should be educated about their rights. If a school pressures a student to request dismissal, they can escalate the issue to CHED’s regional office or legal advisors. Documenting all communications is crucial.
4. Promote Ethical Enrollment Practices
Schools should focus on supporting at-risk students through tutoring, counseling, or flexible schedules instead of pushing them out. Early intervention programs can address learning gaps without resorting to punitive measures.
The Bigger Picture: Rethinking Success in Education
This controversy highlights a systemic problem: equating student success with institutional metrics. Schools under pressure to maintain high pass rates may prioritize numbers over individual growth. However, true educational excellence lies in nurturing resilience, critical thinking, and adaptability—not in filtering out students prematurely.
Parents, educators, and policymakers must collaborate to create systems that value progress over perfection. For instance, competency-based assessments or extended probation periods could give students more opportunities to succeed.
Final Thoughts
The idea of “failing” a student before classes begin is not just illogical—it’s a betrayal of trust. Honorable Dismissals should reflect a student’s circumstances, not a school’s desire to avoid accountability. By advocating for transparency and fairness, we can ensure that every learner has a genuine chance to thrive.
If you or someone you know faces this situation, remember: education is a right, not a privilege. Seek guidance from legal advocates or education NGOs to challenge unjust practices. Together, we can hold institutions accountable and build a system that truly honors its students.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Understanding the Controversy Around Early Honorable Dismissal in Philippine Schools