The Unanswered Questions That Come Full Circle
The first time I held my daughter, her tiny fingers curled around mine with a grip that felt both fragile and unshakable. In that moment, something shifted inside me—a seismic reordering of priorities, fears, and love I hadn’t known possible. Parenthood, as they say, rewires you. But as the years passed and my daughter grew, another realization crept in, one I hadn’t anticipated: her existence illuminated a haunting mystery about my own father. How could he walk away? How could he leave and never look back?
My dad disappeared when I was seven. One day, he was there—teaching me to ride a bike, laughing at my terrible knock-knock jokes—and the next, he wasn’t. No goodbye note, no explanation. Just silence. For decades, I told myself I’d moved on. I built a life, found love, became a parent. But when my daughter turned seven—the same age I was when he left—old questions resurfaced with fresh urgency. How could a parent abandon their child?
The answer, I’ve learned, isn’t simple. It’s tangled in generational differences, unspoken pain, and the strange alchemy of time.
—
The Paradox of Presence and Absence
Becoming a parent cracks open your heart in ways you can’t predict. Suddenly, you’re responsible for this small human who looks to you for safety, joy, and answers to questions like, “Why do stars twinkle?” and “Can we adopt a penguin?” Every scraped knee, every nightmare, every whispered “I love you” carves a deeper bond. It’s exhausting, relentless, and utterly irreplaceable.
Which is why I’ll never understand my father’s choice.
My daughter’s laughter is a compass; her tears are a siren. The idea of missing even a single bedtime story feels like a betrayal. How could someone walk away from this? How could they survive walking away? I used to think my dad’s absence was about me—that I wasn’t enough to make him stay. Now, as a parent myself, I see it had nothing to do with me. It was about him. His limitations. His inability to face whatever demons chased him out the door.
—
The Stories We Inherit
Growing up, I crafted narratives to fill the void. Maybe he’d had a secret life. Maybe he was a spy. (A seven-year-old’s imagination knows no bounds.) As an adult, I uncovered fragments of truth: a man who struggled with addiction, a marriage fraying under financial strain, a generation where fathers weren’t taught to prioritize emotional connection. My dad grew up in an era when men were praised for being providers, not nurturers. Showing up meant paying bills, not showing up emotionally.
But here’s the thing: understanding his context doesn’t heal the wound. I can intellectually grasp why he left—fear, shame, a broken model of masculinity—and still feel the sting of his absence. Forgiving him isn’t about excusing his actions; it’s about releasing the grip of anger that once defined me.
My daughter, in her innocent way, forces this reckoning. When she asks about her grandfather, I don’t lie. “He wasn’t around,” I say, “but that’s why I try so hard to be here for you.” She nods, content with the honesty, and moves on to more pressing matters—like whether unicorns prefer cupcakes or ice cream.
—
The Gift of Breaking Cycles
There’s a peculiar grace in breaking generational patterns. My dad’s absence taught me what not to do. With my daughter, I’m intentional about presence: showing up for school plays, listening to her retell dreams, apologizing when I lose patience. It’s messy and imperfect, but it’s there.
One night, as I tucked her into bed, she whispered, “Daddy, will you ever leave?” The question hit like a punch. I knelt beside her, holding her hand. “No,” I said. “Even when I’m angry or tired, I’ll always be here.” She smiled, reassured, and drifted off to sleep.
In that moment, I felt the weight of history—not as a burden, but as a choice. I can’t rewrite my father’s story, but I can write hers differently.
—
The Questions Without Answers
Parenting has given me more questions than answers. Why do we repeat mistakes? How do we love better than we were loved? Why does my dad’s ghost linger in quiet moments, like when I teach my daughter to swim or help her with homework?
Maybe some mysteries aren’t meant to be solved. Maybe the act of questioning itself is the lesson. My daughter will never meet her grandfather, but she’s inherited his absence in ways she doesn’t yet grasp. And in that void, we’ve built something new: a love that’s deliberate, a bond that refuses to take itself for granted.
I’ll never understand how my dad could leave. But I’m starting to see his departure as a cautionary tale—one that fuels my determination to stay. Parenthood isn’t about perfection; it’s about showing up, day after day, even when it’s hard. Especially when it’s hard.
In the end, my daughter gave me the clarity I’d spent a lifetime seeking: some questions don’t need answers. They just need better stories.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Unanswered Questions That Come Full Circle