The Tutor’s Secret Weapon: Why Knowing Which Explanations Actually Work Changes Everything
Ever rephrased a concept three different ways in a single tutoring session, desperately searching for that elusive “aha!” moment in your student’s eyes? You pour your energy into crafting clear analogies, breaking down complex steps, and drawing helpful diagrams. But afterwards, a nagging question often remains: Did my best explanation actually land? Wouldn’t it be incredibly powerful to know, definitively, which of your teaching approaches resonated most effectively?
The answer, resoundingly, is yes. For tutors dedicated to genuine student progress, understanding which explanations truly “work” isn’t just useful; it’s transformative. It’s the difference between educated guessing and informed teaching.
The Frustration of the Feedback Void
Imagine this common scenario:
1. You explain Topic X using Method A. The student nods politely. You move on.
2. Later, during practice, they struggle with a concept directly tied to Topic X.
3. You backtrack, re-explaining using Method B (a different analogy, a visual aid, a real-world example).
4. This time, you see comprehension click. The student successfully applies the knowledge.
The problem? You only identified Method B as effective after the initial failure. You lost valuable time, and the student experienced unnecessary frustration. Without clear feedback pinpointing that Method A wasn’t landing while Method B did, you have no reliable way to:
Avoid repeating ineffective approaches: You might instinctively use Method A again with the next student struggling with Topic X, simply because it’s your “go-to.”
Replicate success efficiently: While Method B worked for this student, you’re unsure if it was the approach itself, the timing, or something unique to that learner. Can you confidently use it as your primary strategy?
Refine your explanations: Without knowing what specifically made Method B click, further refinement is difficult.
Why Knowing “What Worked” is a Game-Changer
Getting concrete feedback on explanation efficacy offers tutors profound advantages:
1. Boosted Confidence and Reduced Guesswork: Instead of wondering, “Did that make sense?” you know. This reduces anxiety and allows you to focus energy on building the lesson forward, not doubting the foundation. Confidence is contagious and fosters a better learning environment.
2. Sharper Diagnostic Skills: Understanding why an explanation failed (e.g., too abstract, assumed prior knowledge they lacked, unclear sequence) helps you diagnose student misunderstandings faster and more accurately in the future. You start seeing patterns.
3. Personalized Strategy Development: Armed with data on what resonates, you can build a personalized toolkit of explanations tailored to different learning styles and specific stumbling blocks. You become more adaptable and effective with diverse students.
4. Increased Efficiency: Time is precious in tutoring. Knowing which explanations yield the fastest and deepest understanding allows you to streamline sessions, cover more ground, and maximize the value for the student.
5. Continuous Professional Growth: This feedback loop is the essence of reflective practice. It turns every session into a learning opportunity for you as the tutor, accelerating your own development and mastery of teaching techniques.
6. Stronger Student-Tutor Rapport: When students see you actively seeking to understand how they learn best and adapting accordingly, it builds trust and respect. They feel heard and supported, deepening the learning partnership.
How Can Tutors Get This Crucial Feedback?
Knowing it’s valuable is one thing; obtaining it is another. It requires intentional effort:
Ask Direct, Specific Questions: Move beyond “Do you understand?” Try:
“Can you explain that concept back to me in your own words?”
“Which part of that explanation made it click for you? Was it the diagram, the example, or breaking down step 3?”
“Earlier I explained it differently; which way felt clearer to you?”
“What was the most confusing part before it made sense?”
Observe Application Closely: The best feedback is often non-verbal and comes during practice. Watch how the student applies the concept immediately after your explanation. Where do they hesitate? What mistakes reveal gaps in understanding stemming from the explanation itself?
Use Quick Checks for Understanding: Short, low-stakes quizzes, “think aloud” exercises, or asking students to solve a similar but novel problem immediately after an explanation provide concrete evidence of whether understanding was achieved.
Leverage Post-Session Reflection (Yours & Theirs): Briefly note which explanations seemed to spark understanding during the session. Encourage students (or parents, appropriately) to share what was most helpful after they’ve had time to process. A simple end-of-week survey question like “What was the most useful thing your tutor explained this week, and why did it help?” can yield gold.
Analyze Patterns Over Time: Keep track! Note which explanations consistently work well for specific types of concepts or learning styles. This builds your personal evidence-based teaching database.
Addressing the Hesitations
Some tutors might think:
“It takes too much time to ask for feedback.” Actually, targeted questions and keen observation are often quicker than repeating explanations or backtracking due to unnoticed confusion. It’s an investment that saves time later.
“Students might not know how to articulate what worked.” True, especially younger ones. That’s why observation and asking them to demonstrate understanding (“show me,” “explain it to me”) are often more revealing than verbal analysis.
“I already have a good sense of what works.” Experience is valuable, but confirmation bias is real. Actively seeking feedback keeps you honest, challenges assumptions, and uncovers blind spots you didn’t know you had.
The Bottom Line for Tutors
Would tutors find it useful to know which explanations actually worked? It’s not just useful; it’s fundamental to evolving from a knowledgeable helper into a truly impactful educator. This specific feedback closes the loop between teaching effort and learning outcome. It transforms tutoring from an art guided by intuition into a more refined craft driven by evidence. By actively seeking and utilizing this knowledge, tutors empower themselves to teach smarter, not harder, leading to faster student progress, greater job satisfaction, and the undeniable reward of witnessing genuine understanding ignite. Seeking feedback on your explanations isn’t a sign of uncertainty; it’s the hallmark of a dedicated professional committed to excellence. Start asking, start observing, and start unlocking the power of knowing what truly works.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Tutor’s Secret Weapon: Why Knowing Which Explanations Actually Work Changes Everything