The Tutor’s Blind Spot: Why Knowing What Actually Works is Gold Dust
Imagine this: You’re explaining a tricky concept – say, the difference between “affect” and “effect” or how to solve quadratic equations. You try one approach… met with blank stares. You pivot, try another metaphor, another analogy, another step-by-step breakdown. Finally, you see it: the lightbulb moment. Relief washes over you. “Got it!” they say.
But here’s the million-dollar question: Which explanation actually flipped the switch? Was it the third analogy? The specific example you used? The way you broke down step four? Or was it just the cumulative effort that finally paid off? For tutors, navigating the complex landscape of student understanding often feels like walking through fog. We think we know what works, but without concrete feedback on which specific explanations land, we’re often relying on guesswork, intuition, or habit.
The Frustration of the Unknown
Every dedicated tutor experiences this:
The “Repeat Until It Sticks” Trap: Falling back on re-explaining the same way, just louder or slower, hoping repetition alone will do the trick.
The “Shotgun” Approach: Throwing multiple explanations out rapidly, unsure which one, if any, is truly effective. It’s exhausting for both tutor and student.
Assumption is the Enemy: Assuming an explanation worked because the student nodded politely, only to find the same misconception reappear next session.
The Lost Opportunity: Knowing an explanation worked, but not being able to reliably replicate that success with another student struggling with the same concept.
Without specific feedback on what clicked, tutors miss invaluable opportunities for refinement. We might abandon a potentially brilliant approach after one unsuccessful attempt, not realizing it was nearly there, or cling stubbornly to an ineffective one because we lack evidence to the contrary.
Feedback: The Tutor’s Roadmap to Mastery
So, would tutors find it useful to know which explanations actually worked? It’s not just useful; it’s transformative. Here’s why:
1. Sharper Diagnostic Skills: Understanding why a particular explanation succeeded helps tutors diagnose the specific hurdle a student faced. Was it a vocabulary gap? A missing foundational concept? A misunderstanding of the process? Knowing the effective fix reveals the nature of the block.
2. Building a Toolkit of Proven Strategies: Instead of a vague collection of “things I try,” tutors can build a curated arsenal of explanations known to work for specific misconceptions. Imagine having a mental (or actual!) index: “For students confusing photosynthesis and respiration, this analogy worked wonders.” This saves time and increases efficacy.
3. Increased Confidence & Efficiency: Walking into a session knowing you have reliable strategies for common sticking points is empowering. It reduces trial-and-error time, allowing tutors to cover more ground and adapt more swiftly to individual needs.
4. Personalized Teaching Mastery: No two students learn exactly alike. Feedback on what works helps tutors see patterns: “Visual learners respond best to this type of diagram,” or “Students who struggle with abstract concepts need this concrete example first.” This deepens their ability to personalize effectively.
5. Breaking Out of Ruts: We all have our go-to explanations. Feedback forces us to confront whether they are genuinely effective or just comfortable habits. It encourages experimentation with new approaches and validates stepping outside the comfort zone.
How Can We Gather This Golden Feedback?
Knowing which explanation worked requires deliberate effort. It doesn’t just happen passively. Here are practical ways tutors (and those supporting them) can seek it:
Directly Ask the Student (The Micro-Feedback): Don’t just ask “Did that make sense?” (The answer is often a hesitant “yes”). Ask specifically:
“What part of that explanation made it click for you?”
“Was there a particular word, example, or step that suddenly made it clearer?”
“Can you tell me, in your own words, what part finally helped you understand X?”
Use “Think Aloud” Techniques: Ask students to verbalize their thought process as they apply the concept you just explained. This reveals where understanding is solid and where it might still be shaky, indirectly showing if your explanation addressed the core issue.
Leverage Post-Session Reflection Prompts (for the student): A quick digital form or even a verbal wrap-up question: “What was the most helpful thing we did today to help you understand [Topic]?” Frame it positively.
Observed Sessions & Peer Feedback: Having another experienced educator observe a session (with student/parent permission) can provide invaluable insights. They can note which explanations seemed to trigger understanding and which didn’t land. Peer tutors can also discuss successful strategies.
Track Long-Term Application: The ultimate test. Does the understanding stick? Can the student apply the concept correctly in subsequent lessons, homework, or assessments? Consistent application strongly indicates the explanation provided a durable foundation.
Analyze Patterns: Keep a simple journal. After a breakthrough, jot down: the misconception, the explanations tried, which one seemed to work, and any student comments. Over time, powerful patterns emerge.
Beyond the Individual Tutor: Systemic Support
This need for feedback isn’t just an individual tutor’s burden. Tutoring organizations, schools, and platforms play a crucial role:
Building Feedback into Systems: Designing session feedback forms that specifically ask students (or parents) what was most helpful in understanding difficult concepts.
Facilitating Communities of Practice: Creating spaces where tutors can share successful explanations for specific challenges, building a collective knowledge base.
Providing Observation & Coaching: Offering structured observation and feedback from mentors focused on identifying effective explanatory techniques.
Investing in Training: Including modules on how to elicit and utilize student feedback effectively within tutor training programs.
The Transformation: From Good to Great
A tutor armed with knowledge of what explanations truly work is a formidable force. They move beyond being merely knowledgeable to being strategically effective. They spend less time floundering and more time guiding. They build deeper rapport because students feel genuinely understood and effectively helped. Their confidence grows, student outcomes improve, and the entire learning experience becomes more efficient and rewarding.
Knowing which explanation unlocked understanding isn’t just useful feedback; it’s the key to evolving from a good tutor into an exceptional one. It transforms tutoring from an art based largely on intuition into a craft honed by evidence and insight. It’s the difference between navigating that fog with a dim candle and having a clear, powerful spotlight illuminating the path forward. For any tutor committed to making the biggest possible impact, seeking and utilizing this specific feedback isn’t optional – it’s essential. So, let’s start asking the right questions and listening closely to the answers. Our students’ understanding depends on it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Tutor’s Blind Spot: Why Knowing What Actually Works is Gold Dust